News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bpodgursky on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:02PM (#33349403)
It's not important per se, but it's a perfect microcosm of contemporary German energy policy.

Eliminate the clean energy sources, put up a facade of green power which is then bulldozed to facilitate the dirty coal baseload power they now completely rely on.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by munk-a on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:05PM (#33349431)
The heart of the issue in Germany right now is that the Green Party is absolutely dogmatically opposed to anything having to do with nuclear - they're trading out good clean energy sources for an increased reliance on natural resources because of deeply rooted and fundamentally wrong belief that nuclear is not and can never be a clean energy source.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by chess_buster on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:13PM (#33349543)
The heart of the issue in Germany right now is that the conservatives (coal) and the social democrats (gas) had sabotaged the switch to renewable energies during the last decade – which was otherwise well on it's way.

This entire discussion about nuclear is just a propaganda trick by the fossil fuel industry, which knows that nuclear can't be build in time. So people will rely on fossil fuels longer because they wait for nuclear while renewables and storage are presented as unattractive.

Just like Elon did with his hyperloop adventure to sabotage high speed rail.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by tormeh on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#33349678)
I think whether we should build new nuclear plants is a question that can be discussed between reasonable people. On the other hand, shutting down nuclear plants while there are still fossil fuel plants in operation seems ill-advised to me.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by dathinab on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:13PM (#33350301)
Note that most nuclear power plants are so old that they _need_ to be shut down or they will become a risk.

After Fukushima the shutdown of some of them was pulled up by a small amount of years, undoing that decision does make sense and should be done (and somewhat had been done in a roundabout way where the one side can pretend they didn't do it and the other side can complain they didn't do it but should it matter its basically as if the did it).

The problem is that they use the situation as an excuse to push other things which are neither necessary nor sane.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by cauch on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @08:07PM (#33351348)
The situation is of course more complicated than that.

The grid is like a big Tetris board, and nuclear power plants are big multi-prong pieces: they can be good to cover a large surface, but sometimes, they block situations were a better configuration (which is at the end cleaner) is possible.

For example, the evolution of the grid may make a specific nuclear power plant not totally needed (because this region can now get cheap import, because the heavy industries in this area have changed, ...) while still expensive to maintain. In this case, shutting it down is a good idea. Another example, if you say "yeah, maybe we will built a nuclear power plant there, maybe, who knows", the risk of investing in a renewable power plant that would replace a dirty power plant may be not attractive to investors, and the dirty power plant will continue for years. But if you say you will exit the nuclear, then the renewable power plant is suddenly very attractive and the dirty power plant can, at the end of the process, be replaced. Another example, the grid needs a balance between production and demand, but demand is not flat during the day, there are peaks. Nuclear power plants, especially the not recent ones, may not efficiently produce non-flat production. In this case, the grid can evolve in a situation where too much "flat production" exists, and where a "flat production" power plant is the one that is not competitive anymore due to the maintenance costs. ...

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:21PM (#33351827)
Again, it's a matter of investment.

Keeping the old nuke running for ten more years costs more and winds up being less reliable than a new wind farm.

The moral is 'don't let your leader gut zero carbon investment for a 'job' in the gas industry'. Not 'spend your limited zero carbon investment in a much worse way'.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by AlmostAnyone on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:33PM (#33349814)
Oh please. There's no "time" until when nuclear must be built or something fails. And it's slow only because of the anti-nuclear sentiment. It's very much possible to build it quickly - just look across the border.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:44PM (#33350607)
Look where? Even China takes 10 years to build a nuclear plant.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by AlmostAnyone on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:20AM (#33353432)
... And that's supposed to be bad? Even a solar project takes 10 years in Germany.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bryanlarsen on Thursday October 27, 2022 @07:38AM (#33356084)
China can do a solar EV project in 3 months. So if it takes China 40X times as long to do nuclear than solar, how long would nuclear take in Germany if solar takes 10 years?
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by AlmostAnyone on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:22AM (#33358946)
Fortunately it's all about the red tape, not actual construction time. Reduce it and you can build nuclear quickly.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bryanlarsen on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:40AM (#33359256)
Or you can reduce the red tape and build solar in 3 months or wind in 6 months. 10 years is not quick.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by AlmostAnyone on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:14PM (#33361641)
Solar/wind combined can never replace fossil fuels used by industry/for heating/as vehicle fuel. By several orders of magnitude.

So we need both.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bryanlarsen on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:24PM (#33361786)
Renewables supply approximately 25% of Europe's energy. Are you telling me it's impossible to quadruple the amount of renewable power generation in Europe? If Europe switches to heat pumps & EV's etc it'll need to double again. Still less than a single order of magnitude increase.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by AlmostAnyone on Thursday October 27, 2022 @02:48PM (#33362177)
25% of electricity, definitely not 25% of all energy including heating and ground transportation, much less if you also include plane and ship traffic.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by bpodgursky on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:25PM (#33349715)
> This entire discussion about nuclear is just a propaganda trick by the fossil fuel industry, which knows that nuclear can't be build in time

All you have to do is not turn them off, man. Or recommission the ones that were turned off a year ago. This isn't a conspiracy.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#33349673)
>the conservatives (coal) and the social democrats (gas) had sabotaged the switch to renewable energies during the last decade – which was otherwise well on it's way.

Why did they do that?

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:48PM (#33352011)
When many of your leaders on the boards of gas companies, Koch funded organizations, banks with massive fossil fuel investments, and are 'close personal friends' of Putin why would they not?

https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-former-chancellor-gerhard-sch... (he declined after the massive backlash, but is still on the board)

https://www.thelocal.de/20221013/merkel-says-no-regrets-over...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Merz#Other_activit...

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by dathinab on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:43PM (#33349920)
not sure why you are down voted it pretty much sumes the situation up

Nuclear makes _financially_ no sense, only undoing the decision for a earlier shutdown done after fukushima makes sense. But building nuclear power plants takes at least decade a so it's not even an option to consider for short term handling of shortages in the next years and nuclear power was only ever cheap because of it being highly subvention.

It also makes geo strategically no sense as it's a sigle point of failure and a rather catastrophic point of failure, too.

Germany had a budding promising solar and wind industry which was basically killed of by politicians from CDU and SPD. Worse it's more then obvious that the politicians behind it have tight connections to the coal and gas industry to a point you could call it corrupt.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by munk-a on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @06:22PM (#33350390)
If every decade we say "Welp, we can't start building nuclear plants now because they won't be done for a decade" then it'll never happen. That long startup time has been the ongoing boogieman against nuclear since the 90's and it is certainly a real cost - but we can't stop-gap our way to a solution forever. Building out more coal power today while investing in nuclear is fine - it's not fine to just accept that if we can't do it in five years it's not worth doing.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by pencilguin on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @08:12PM (#33351369)
Money is fungible.

Money spent building nukes is money not spent build out renewables that produce much more power for the money, and start producing immediately.

The amount spent on fossil fuels over the decade or two waiting for the nuke to come online would have bought that much renewable capacity that would have been displacing CO2 the whole time.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by vagrantJin on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:19AM (#33353044)
Isn't a nuke a nuclear bomb? If that is the case why call a power plant a bomb?
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by pencilguin on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:37AM (#33353168)
Bombs are also nukes. And apparently US Navy reactor engineers are, too. No one is confused.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by vagrantJin on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:00AM (#33354162)
Or just call it a nuclear power plant to avoid confusion?
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by pencilguin on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:06PM (#33359653)
No one is confused. As I said.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by cauch on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @08:20PM (#33351413)
The problem is that because we need to progress in 5 years, it means that by 10 years we will hopefully have way more renewable solutions, which is cheaper than nuclear. So, investors don't want to pay for a nuclear plant that will be built in 10 years but when up and running, will not be profitable anymore because renewable would have changed the market.

It's a real problem for nuclear plants: we still need them as "baseline continuous" generators, but no-one wants to risk investing for a site when there is a large chance that this specific site will not be needed in 10 years, will be too expensive to run and not competitive, and will go bust.

We made the mistake 10 years ago by not planning ahead (even France, who was going to the nuclear route, messed up by not renewing and maintaining their know-how). But now, it's just true that building an expensive power plant that will not be used is just not a good idea.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by Schroedingersat on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @09:06PM (#33351737)
The choice isn't 'nuclear or not' it's '1 nuclear or 2 renewables'.

If renewable investment was tripled and you could still wrest more money from the coal lobby then building nukes with that would make sense. Until then it just means burning more coal (which is precisely why it's being shilled so hard).

Even then spending money on a sodium ion or iron air battery factory will probably pay off sooner.

Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by woah on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:44AM (#33353614)
It can be damaging politically to admit your wrong about a core aspect of your policy
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by grimjack00 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @09:58AM (#33357538)
They don't have to admit being wrong, they should just state that they have evolved and now have different thoughts on the subject.
Re:Germany Is Dismantling a Wind Farm to Make Way for a Coal... by josefx on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:13PM (#33349547)
They have been dismantling entire towns in that area starting from 2006[1] to keep the coal plants in the area supplied. It would probably be less dramatic if it was just a targeted attack on a random wind farm.

[1] https://www.spiegel.de/panorama/rwe-darf-grundstuecke-von-la...