News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by archon1410 on Monday October 24, 2022 @07:07AM (#33315149)
What is the point of this website? I see it often but doesn't Twitter and Nitter etc automatically provide this functionality? Genuine question.
Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by bloggie on Monday October 24, 2022 @07:29AM (#33315337)
It does and it doesn't: first, twitter often only lets you see the first few posts if you are not logged in; and second, it groups the posts together into something you can read without distracting interspersed comments, like the forum posts of yesteryear.
Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by archon1410 on Monday October 24, 2022 @08:31AM (#33315827)
>twitter often only lets you see the first few posts if you are not logged in

that would be a reason, but I've never personally encountered it. I see full threads even when logged out.

>you can read without distracting interspersed comments, like the forum posts of yesteryear.

I've never encountered interspersed comments on Twitter threads. they're visible the way they're visible in the thread reader website, one after the other. other comments come at the end of the thread.

Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by yreg on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:15AM (#33328525)
I don't need to see an avatar, date and username above each sentence of a blog post. Twitter monologue threads are dumb, the whole premise of the service is to write under 280 characters (used to be 140).
Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by dredmorbius on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:05PM (#33332450)
The practice has some merits.

Sometimes a thread simply evolves out of a conversation.

Sometimes one comment just leads to another.

And sometimes it's helpful, useful, and/or interesting to have individual sentences or paragraphs of a thread split into their own items, so that it becomes more clear what specific parts of a discussion are especially engaging, confusing, interesting, etc. People can comment or respond to specific parts of the thread rather than the whole thing.

For writers who are accustomed to either global/overall feedback, or none at all, this can be enlightening. It's about as close to the experience of giving a live lecture or presentation as exists online, in that in a live presentation people can also respond or react to specific moments as they occur.

Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by yreg on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:27PM (#33336983)
I believe all of that can be done just as well if not better with a traditional comment section like the one here on hn. My other issue is that the conversation is very difficult to follow since it's split into many threads.

>it becomes more clear what specific parts of a discussion are especially engaging, confusing, interesting, etc. People can comment or respond to specific parts of the thread

Quoting solves this.

Obviously Twitter works for you, which I find enlightening since up until now I thought that the experience is subpar for everyone and the reason long form content is posted on twitter is purely because it's easier to spread it around. Clearly there's more to it.

Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by dredmorbius on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @12:53AM (#33339977)
For what it's worth, I don't use Twitter.

My comments above are based on my experience writing, reading, responding to, and otherwise interacting with and observing longer toot threads ("tootstorms" on Mastodon, comparable to "tweetstorms" on Twitter).

And are compared with experiences on numerous other platforms and systems, ranging from Usenet to HN, and in particular including Reddit, G+, Diaspora*, and Mastodon.

Mastodon is a rough Twitter analogue. It tends to give a broader exposure than forum-based or friend-based (e.g., Google+, specific subreddits) forums. And again, in particular what I observe is people responding to specific toots within a longer stream in a way that's simply not evident in other formats. It's not an unallowed good. It is a notable characteristic of the format, however.

Some examples are hashtagged through my profile (though this link doesn't seem to be working at the moment): <https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/tagged/tootstorm>

As an alternative, try: <https://toot.cat/web/tags/tootstorm>

Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by benj111 on Monday October 24, 2022 @09:11AM (#33316181)
It loads a lot quicker for 1
Re:27 years since the Financial Times killed one of England’... by dredmorbius on Monday October 24, 2022 @09:45AM (#33316526)
Twitter throws up multiple dark patterns for me and tends strongly to unreadable/inaccessible at best.

Threadreader presents just the thread, formatted for easy reading, without all the additional Twitter crud. The experience with Threadreader is vastly superior in my experience.