News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Social Recession: By the Numbers by badpun on Monday October 24, 2022 @04:14AM (#33314107)
> You can't be anti-immigration and call yourself an individualist, it's a nationalist (and therefore collectivist) position.

I don't neccessarily disagree with the rest of your post, but the above seems obviously false. Most anti-immigratio people are not for it because of some abstract ideas, but because they see immigrant as direct competitiors for their jobs. That was one of the biggest reasons behing Brexit votes for example.

Re:The Social Recession: By the Numbers by hackerlight on Monday October 24, 2022 @04:41AM (#33314252)
I believe the motive is more ethnonationalist than is admitted to in polite circles. "Culture" or "jobs" is the euphemistic front, but the true reasons are fear of crime/terrorism, and fear of becoming a racial minority and the consequences that will have on their voting power and racial supremacy.

Even if the earnest reason was job competition, I'd say that protectionism isn't individualist, either. Probably it's a motive that doesn't belong on the individualist-collectivist spectrum.

Re:The Social Recession: By the Numbers by badpun on Monday October 24, 2022 @05:17AM (#33314437)
> I believe the motive is more ethnonationalist than is admitted to in polite circles. "Culture" or "jobs" is the euphemistic front, but the true reasons are fear of crime/terrorism, and fear of becoming a racial minority and the consequences that will have on their voting power and racial supremacy.

In the Brexit case, it was white Eastern Europeans coming in to UK and taking over low-paying jobs. So, neither a threat of terrorism nor racial supremacy (they're all white). I guess one could be afaid of some regions losing its inherent British culture though.

Re:The Social Recession: By the Numbers by Scharkenberg on Monday October 24, 2022 @05:37AM (#33314528)
> In the Brexit case, it was white Eastern Europeans coming in to UK and taking over low-paying jobs.

Perhaps true in many people's minds, but it largely seems to be the case that native Brits do not want to do those jobs. Either Brits tend to see themselves as "above that", or there is a serious shortage of workers in those areas (structural problem). Therefore, such jobs were left undone or severely delayed. The UK got what it literally asked for and is now finding out that it didn't actually want that.

Re:The Social Recession: By the Numbers by hackerlight on Monday October 24, 2022 @06:32AM (#33314901)
Brexit was a mish mash of motives. Some of those motives were explicitly collectivist, others were anti-individualist if not collectivist.

Brexit was also partly fear of Muslims, not just job competition with Eastern Europeans. You see this in the internal discussion around Syrian refugees from people like Nigel Farage, Douglas Murray and Sargon of Akkad. They wanted to exit the system that enabled that. This particular motive was collectivist.

In addition, Brexit was partly the typical arrogance and wounded ego you see from declining and fallen empires. The glory days are still fresh in people's minds. There's a feeling that Britain is on the decline. People couldn't accept the egalitarian terms and low status of being just another ordinary EU member state. This also is collectivist through and through.