I've noticed this too (https://github.com/netlify/netlify-cms/releases) with lots of open issues which makes me nervous about using it for client projects.
> Why are there not more alternatives?
Maybe it's hard to make money from? There's quite a few commercial offerings where some try to offer some slice of it as open source.
I'd love a popular alternative to WordPress. Unfortunately, WordPress is still seen as the safe open source choice for ease-of-use of the editors.
See: https://answers.netlify.com/t/is-this-project-dead/70988 https://github.com/netlify/netlify-cms/discussions/6503
Ones that I've used include:
- Statamic https://statamic.com
- Jigsaw https://jigsaw.tighten.com/
Flat File CMS are typical CMS systems (often times written in PHP) that run on the server, but use files (often Markdown/Frontmatter) as their data backend (instead of a DB like Wordpress, Drupal, etc.) – if you're looking for a really nice Flat File CMS take a look at Kirby (https://getkirby.com) or Statamic.
What OP is building (I think) and what others like Netlify CMS and Tina CMS do, are Frontend Applications (typically SPA) that output a set of content files, which can then be fed into a static site generator (like Next.js, Astro, Hugo, Jekyll), which will built a website from it. Often these content files live on Git – so the common interface between a SSG and the "static CMS" is often Git (or a local folder on your file system). So it's a "smaller" concept than flat file CMS. Typically these "static CMS" only care about content and have nothing to do with templating, etc.
After I've launched people pointed the existence of those CMSs. I really built this as something to scratch my own itch, halfway through I decided it could be a library.
But as someone else mentioned, it's quite hard to think of a business model around this. I'll keep working on it just so that I can use it in my own blog. If other people want to use it, that's great.
It feels like today it is a too risky water to dip toes into.
Bugs do appear to still be tracked and tagged though, so it's a confusing state of affairs.
I’m not sure if the right thing to do is build a web editor or smooth out git workflows so that non-technical people can open content files with desktop software to make changes to the content.
Statically generated websites are everywhere and have been popular for many years. Gatsby, Next, Hugo, Jekyll, 11ty, Astro, etc.
Yet, there is a lack of visual editing interfaces for Markdown/Frontmatter/MDX content.
Netlify CMS has been the best solution in this space, and despite many thousands of stars it’s abandoned now.
Tina CMS seems nice, but requires a subscription/cloud account.
Why are there not more alternatives?
Will take a closer look at Outstatic for sure.