Are you arguing we shouldn't have such laws because they don't reach 100% of people? That's letting perfect be the enemy of good.
> I recently went through a difficult situation, during which my partner was unable to visit restaurants, even if they were wheelchair accessible. Was that fair?
It is more fair then if restaurants weren't wheelchair accessible.
> Is it more fair to exclude someone on the basis of their financial situation rather than based on their physical disability?
It is more fair than if they were also excluded based on their physical disability.
>If I were to become disabled and not be able to go hiking, I'd miss it more than going to restaurants. Is that fair?
It is more fair than if you were also not able to go to restaurants.
You see? These are all still better. It is not perfect, but arguing that we should do away with these laws because they are not perfect doesn't help it become better, just worse.
Generally, that's the role of a legislature. We could, for instance, exempt restaurants unable to afford renovations from that burden. Unfortunately, there are sticklers like you that would rather those restaurant not exist.
Not only would this be an insane job for the legislature, they aren't equipped to handle the volume.
> If the restaurant owners, none. If the disabled, all. And there isn't really an in-between is there?
Are you sure there's no in-between? I gave this grand total of few seconds of thought. Could perhaps the government or the city step in and provide wheelchair accessibility to select restaurants, based on feasibility, cost, location, and perhaps some other criteria?
Restaurant owners suffer because of these laws. Are you 100% sure the suffering of the restaurant owners under these laws is lesser than the suffering of the disabled without these laws?
I think this is why some laws state “reasonable accommodations”. If a ramp is impossible or unaffordable with the restaurants margins, what should be the course of action? Should the restaurant close? If so, that doesn’t actually improve accessibility.
The current law may already use this barometer and the horror story examples may be overblown, but at least this seems like a reasonable way to approach things.
2. I don't know what your situation was so I don't know but I think your point was that the world isn't fair so why. We strive to do our best within reason. Just because not every situation is fair isn't an argument against making more situations unfair.
3. On poor people not being able go:
A.No restaurant could afford to pay for all the meals if they were required to cover the cost for any person who can't afford it.
B. Most people can afford to go to almost restaurant at least once in their life. When does it become unfair? 2 times a year, 5 a week.
C. How would you determine who could afford it? how would the restaurant verify it?
D. If I spend all my money gambling then want to eat is that fair? If no. How would you determine what a person spent and catalog what's acceptable
E. Come on, this like one of those "they deserved it" remarks from the "being selfish is now socially acceptable " right wing crowd.
I agree we want the world to be fair. I recently went through a difficult situation, during which my partner was unable to visit restaurants, even if they were wheelchair accessible. Was that fair?
What about people who can't financially afford going to a restaurant? Is it more fair to exclude someone on the basis of their financial situation rather than based on their physical disability?
Btw, I love hiking. If I were to become disabled and not be able to go hiking, I'd miss it more than going to restaurants. Is that fair?