Angle of attack sensor. AoA is the actual definition of a stall as it measures the point at which airflow breaks away from the wing, reducing lift.
Re your other points on computer warnings, cockpits can get pretty noisy when shit happens with various alarms, buzzers, horns and voices going off. There's actually a tendency to reduce the number of different alarms and use screen information to indicate the problem (although that may be changing after the Qantas drama in 2010 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qantas_Flight_32).
This 1996 757 Aeroperu crash recording is quite scary: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5QSBlYTJ1Y
They had no functioning pitot tubes and lots of contradictory indications, which triggered a storm of alarms, most of them false. Pilots spend quite some time trying to shut alarms off while trying to figure out their situation with air control. I can't imagine trying to talk and cooperate with colleagues, facing a complex system and a life-or-death situation, while so many loud and stressful sounds are buzzing through my ears.
After 9:00, the plane inverts upside down, a "whoop-whoop" alarm goes off and the plane finally crashes into the sea. The alarm only served the sinister purpose of announcing they were going to die.
There's actually a tendency to reduce
the number of different alarms and
use screen information to indicate the problem
Yes, that'd be good UX. There should be only one actionable task presented at any time to correct errors. In any case, user testing is more important than guidelines.I wonder if grouped alarms make any sense. For instance you can group all alarms related to stalling together, and present the one thing the pilot can do to correct this. This gives the pilot a sense of what is the most effective use of their attention in a bad situation.
QF mishap - the Wikipedia article didn't talk about the alarms.
In the AF447 case, the crew was getting the stall warning. They did the exact opposite of what you are supposed to do to recover from the stall. Computers were not the problem. (The same thing happened to that Colgan Air flight a few years ago. The crew reacted to the stall warning by stalling the plane even more. The plane tried to physically force the controls to nose down, which is how you recover from a stall, but the pilots fought it. Bad UI was not the problem. Bad flying was.)
It seems counter intuitive to nose down when you're falling out of the sky, but it's how you recover.
If one were to apply principles of Tao, it would be to yield. Give the stick pusher nothing to push.
The plane tried to physically force the
controls to nose down,
I'm glad you mentioned that. I thought that's what a plane should do at first, and then on second consideration wondered if the psychology of panicking pilots would be to fight the controls in order to wrest the plane from going down.Given that user interfaces on airplanes are digital now, there are a lot of opportunities to innovate.
For instance, where there are multiple failures and alarms, it might be better for the panel to continuously replay the sequence in which the alarms were set off, more or less like how movies do it to help the viewer understand what is happening on the computer. By showing how a system is failing through time, it shows a causal relationship. In addition, you can provide drill down capabilities.
In the case of Air France, perhaps it could have illustrated the AoA through time, and the flight velocity. Perhaps that would have explained something to the pilot.
There are lots of messages because lots of things can go wrong with an aircraft. They aren't all critical "land now" messages, but may be relevant.
There is actually a fair amount of ergonomics and interfaces design that goes into these systems - at least equal to Amazon's shopping cart, probably more. Same goes for systems like ATC.
"Stall" does mean "dive now" to every pilot. It is extremely questionable whether including this information explicitly would help at all in the chaotic, confused environment in the cockpit at the time. "Why are you pulling the stick back" is way too long as well, although it does raise a fair point about keeping both pilots aware of each other's control inputs.
Making something go in a particular direction at a particular altitude at a particular speed is hard enough. Throw in a stall and the best the plane can do is try to nose down.
I believe there is a way to tell stall just from altimeter and gyro readings when combined with state information (flap position, gear up/down, &c.) about the plane.
great points about the ui design, though.
i think the biggest issue, though, was the controls not announcing (either through force feedback or a blaring alarm or an urgently blinking light) conflicting input on the control sticks. does anyone know why this is a feature in the first place?
This part doesn't sound so useful, in a cockpit with worried pilots.
I think it can easily do that by measuring the G force similar to an accelerometer on iPhone.
Alternate law and normal law introduces two modes. This breaks one of the rules of user experience, especially if it is infrequently encountered. Combined with turning autopilot off on its own, it is bound to cause even more confusion. The plane could have put an alert asking the pilot to go on autopilot, otherwise, it will continue by making educated guesses. (A pilot is no better judge of airspeed than the computer)
Another rule of UX broken is "tell" instead of "announce". The voice should have said "Stall. Dive now" or "Stall. Why are you pulling the stick back?".
The flight computer can reinforce its credibility by demonstrating it has predictive capability. For instance, it can say, "decrease your angle of attack or you will stall in 5 seconds", then "4", "3" "2" "1", "stalling". The voice should demonstrate increased tension and panic as counting down.
It is high time the flight computer act as the "third pilot". It is similar to video judges in competitive sports. Of course people may choose to ignore the computer, but we can then continually review why the computers assessment was wrong and improve on it.
What I don't understand is, how does a plane know it's stalling if the pitot tubes are frozen?
By the way, optical flow meters could have been used as a backup.