Re:What really happened aboard Air France 447
by assemble on Thursday December 08, 2011 @02:37PM
(#3330737)
Yeah, I don't know about the a/c in question; however, the Colgan crash was a result of the pilot fighting the stick pusher and winning. The stick pusher is not easy to override.
It seems counter intuitive to nose down when you're falling out of the sky, but it's how you recover.
Re:What really happened aboard Air France 447
by teyc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @05:22PM
(#3331457)
Exactly.
If one were to apply principles of Tao, it would be to yield. Give the stick pusher nothing to push.
Re:What really happened aboard Air France 447
by teyc on Thursday December 08, 2011 @10:36AM
(#3329457)
The plane tried to physically force the
controls to nose down,
I'm glad you mentioned that. I thought that's what a plane should do at first, and then on second consideration wondered if the psychology of panicking pilots would be to fight the controls in order to wrest the plane from going down.
In the AF447 case, the crew was getting the stall warning. They did the exact opposite of what you are supposed to do to recover from the stall. Computers were not the problem. (The same thing happened to that Colgan Air flight a few years ago. The crew reacted to the stall warning by stalling the plane even more. The plane tried to physically force the controls to nose down, which is how you recover from a stall, but the pilots fought it. Bad UI was not the problem. Bad flying was.)