News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by danieldk on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:09AM (#33259470)
I think that differs very much per country. The last time I have received an SMS from a human in NL must have been a decade ago. In many European countries, sending SMS was quite expensive, leading to early and very wide adoption of WhatsApp.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Altho on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:41AM (#33259702)
Most European countries have had unlimited SMS way before messaging apps where a thing
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by omnimus on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:35AM (#33261897)
Not true at all. Most european countries are still pay per message.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by alvarlagerlof on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:37PM (#33265404)
Damn
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Altho on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:01AM (#33273360)
As far as I know Belgium, France, Germany, the UK, Greece and I think Spain and Italy have very popular unlimited sms phone plans.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by dns_snek on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:41AM (#33274565)
Maybe on prepaid (pay per use) SIM cards.

Even cheapest monthly subscriptions have at least 500 messages per month bundled, with more typical monthly plans (~$15/mo) having unlimited calls, SMS/MMS messages and around 30 GB of 4G/5G data.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by polskibus on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:14AM (#33259508)
That was ages ago. Most people have unlimited text messages these days (SMS, not MMS).
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by wongarsu on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:45AM (#33259727)
Yes, but the point is that in some countries this happened so late that everyone already switched to Whatsapp before SMS became effectively free. And once everyone is on Whatsapp there's no point in switching back to SMS.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:02AM (#33260869)
Not in most countries I've been...

It became common to get atleast 1000 sms in your plan, combined with maybe 100mb of data back them, then unlimited sms with 1gb of data, and then slowly data went upwards while sms can't go up from "unlimited". 100MB is not enough to leave "the internet" running 24/7 on your phone, so internet-based chat services were unusable for general reachability back then (we're talking about early symbian and stuff like msn messenger era), and you just sent an SMS (becase 1000 is enough for everyone... except teenage girls back then(.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by cabbagesauce on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:26AM (#33259593)
NL is rather small sample to, say, larger countries like Poland that use SMS quite frequently. And depending on carrier, SMS texting most likely will be completely free with most of the current plans.

Signal's rationale is just Signal's own reluctance to build an umbrella messenger. And given they do drop SMS, still won't introduce usernames it's very hard to actually sell it as a WhatsApp replacement.

And now, with WhatsApp supporting password protected cloud backups and up to 2Gb attachments, I'd say Signal will loose the userbase it acquired during the hype and Musk tweet.

In fact, during 2020 Belarus protests, Signal did nothing to support it's own operations during internet semi-blackout in the country, while Telegram tweaked their server side to provide at least some possibility to know what was happening in big cities. So what are the values of Signal — I don't even know. But they sure did support pillagers and rioters in the USA.

To be even more brazen, Signal is not Apple. They stopped innovating. And they don't have enough political power to convince people do things the new way. Even their zero knowledge server is worthless. Check out the story on FBI cracking down on the leader of some right wing proud boys type of armed group. They tracked him and then compelled to give up access to Signal.

Their innovation stopped at providing solid cryptography that was adopted by most decent messengers already. And they aren't visionaries with cancelling SMS.

UPD: the funniest part is that the service that drops the SMS support still relies on SMS to provide account registration.

This is just an unprecedented level of sarcasm.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Gasp0de on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:41AM (#33259701)
Enlighten me please, how can you register with a username and without a phone number in WhatsApp?
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by claudedopplr on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:53AM (#33259785)
Being such a small operation, I think they're making a great decision by focusing on what matters most. "Most startups die by lack of focus". I very much believe this is their first public step towards breaking up with phone number based identity.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by cabbagesauce on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:10AM (#33259927)
>Being such a small operation, I think they're making a great decision by focusing on what matters most.

Currently, it looks like they are focusing on social networking features: stories, emoji stuff, better link previews. Basically everything that competition already did. The roadmap is not public, so I wouldn't take guesses as what may come next. But...

..."dropping support of X as a feature" is some kind of new transcendent approach to product development incomprehensible to common earthlings.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by claudoppl on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:18AM (#33263492)
You seem very frustrated personally for the lack of SMS support on Signal.

I don't agree with your take or arguments, and you seem to keep branching off pejorative comments on their organization and product instead of actually discussing the points. I think the conversation would be more productive if we focus on the same point, i.e.:

  * Focusing on what matters most is a good idea, as nobody serious about secure messaging uses SMS

    * Your argument: irony-covered "dropping features is not a good product development approach". 

      * My counter-argument: it **is** a valid approach, why support a feature that was useful in the past, but it is now dying/not aligned with your core value proposition?

    * Your other argument: their focus is on social networking, and some disdainful comment that "the competition already did it". 

      * My argument: how is catching up with well-established user behaviors across other messaging platforms a bad thing?

I remember when I didn't have a smart phone (I don't come from a privileged background, and this was 2009) and I used twitter over SMS. I really wouldn't care if they dropped support for it now, but back then, I would have churned.

(edited for formatting)

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by cabbagesauce on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:23PM (#33267502)
I'm not frustrated personally, but I know a lot of people who lost their faith in what the organization does.

No one is branching off, but a pretext that your personal take on things must comply with some sort of argumentation protocol that is the only valid blueprint for discussion isn't convincing. Moreover you've managed to somehow unwrap you single comment into a fully fledged dialog while ignoring that their roadmap (the big picture) is not exposed to the public. Given we can only judge isolated decisions, they seem what they are — rather not aligned with the expectations of the userbase.

Personally, I see a pattern of Signal making news in rather negative connotation rather than positive lately.

When it got traction, I felt like it's a new day and the future is bright. But since then, they went with a series of rather ambiguous decisions that sidetracked from previous claims.

EOS for SMS is again one of controversial decisions, I mean, we're in a thread started by a person that went above to clarify reasoning behind the press release. And before it was a year of server side repos without any commits, and then the public got a feature no one asked for — MobileCoin integration. And echoes of intent about it are still heard across the table.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by stereoradonc on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:44AM (#33261292)
Completely agree with your assessment.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Tor3 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:53AM (#33259782)
It's definitely in use in Europe, but it depends. I and my wife use SMS extensively, that's simply because we both use very cheap phone plans without a built-in data plan - i.e. no internet unless we have wi-fi (the pro side of that is that the yearly phone expenses is in the (equivalent of) low tens of dollars, not hundreds of dollars). When we're networked we use Line messaging.

My wife's boss communicates with all her employees by SMS (mass SMS - works like group communication, both ways).

AddEdit: Airlines send their notifications and links to boarding passes etc. via SMS. Dentist and doctor appointments, other public office appointments (e.g. my upcoming passport renewal), document notifications (from pension fund insurance companies for example), public warnings ("Toxic fire nearby - close your windows"), and more, are via SMS where I live.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Semaphor on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:02AM (#33259865)
Huh, how cheap is that? I’m almost always in wifi range, so I got the cheapest plan I could find in Germany (4€/month, so 48€/year), and even that still includes 1 GB of data (I do need the data, to sync my shopping list for example, but I’m curious how low one can go :D).
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by max-m on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:13AM (#33260409)
The cheapest (as in 0€/month) plan would probably be a SIM from Netzclub, but that's financed via advertisements. And then there was Congstar's "Prepaid wie ich will" (the 1st generation), which offered a "free messaging option" (1 GB / month, but only 32 kb/s) you could book every month. You just had to keep the SIM alive by topping up your credit by 15€ every 15 months (iirc). The unthrottled data options for this plan were expensive though.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by bebna on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:54AM (#33272256)
I use discotel for years now, it is basically a prepaid with automated recharge from bank invoice on O2/Eplus. Thanks to being a prepaid you always got the option to switch you setup via packets every 30 days or 4 weeks (have to check that again, it was a fixed day amount and not based on calander months anymore).

So if I'm not traveling I stay with the cheapest data option for my occasionally otg stuff and on heavy travel months I choose larger packages, because I found myself using more often, for example as access point to notebook.

I also have an Kaufland (Telekom) Prepaid card, that said it would provide basic, very slow internet, for free so that text messages over chat works, bur I don't know if I got the wrong APN settings, it has problems in my second slot or it only works if you top it up regularly, but that internet and rest never really worked, even the account management over the website doesn't really work for me.

Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by Beldin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:08AM (#33259911)
Definitely not per country: I regularly use SMS from NL.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by coldtea on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @06:10AM (#33259929)
Probably per person than per country.
Re:Tell HN: I asked Signal motivations for SMS removal by zajio1am on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:49AM (#33263041)
> In many European countries, sending SMS was quite expensive, leading to early and very wide adoption of WhatsApp.

Yes, but data tariffs were also expensive, while you can send SMS with regular (no-data) tariff.