News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:50PM (#33251285)
> "abstracting all of the hardware in your life"

This is precisely where I think MS failed miserably with Windows Phone. They had an incredible opportunity: Make a smart phone that is a full, natural, joined-at-the-hip extension of your desktop.

They did not. Instead, they made a separate device. This was, from the perspective of desktop integration, 100% indistinguishable from any of the other offerings out there. They were playing "We too" when they should have been playing "Check this out!".

Something as conceptually simple as a docking station that instantly brings your phone into your desktop as a first class integrated app, able to interact with other applications, including browsers, would have been a huge step forward and a massive selling point for Windows Phone. Add to that an open API for developers to be able to integrate desktop Windows Phone services into their applications and MS would have had the makings of an ecosystem that would have just exploded into the business community in a massive way.

Instead they wasted time and money with an offering that did exactly the same things as any other offering while trying to invent a new UI. The strategy was doomed to fail before the first phone was introduced. They tried to build an iPhone with a different UI when the business world would have energetically adopted a deeply integrated extension to desktops in the form of a smart phone.

To this day, I still think I would drop iPhone in a second if MS came out with a well thought out system along the lines I described above. The paradigm shift (or the twist in thinking) is that the phone is given life as an extension to the desktop experience rather than as an afterthought that behaves as a peripheral. It would be like a sci-fi movie where the person grabs an application from the screen, it materializes as a physical device in their hand and they walk away. When they get to the office they push it into their display and it melds into that system instantly. Sci-fi aside, that feeling and utility would be incredibly useful.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by Firmwarrior on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:59PM (#33251410)
> Something as conceptually simple as a docking station that instantly brings your phone into your desktop as a first class integrated app, able to interact with other applications

What the hell are you talking about? What does this actually mean in real terms?

Right now Windows already desperately tries to do exactly what you're saying.[1] Do you want a PalmPilot-style sync app? iPad/Mac-style "Universal Control"?

1: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/sync-across-your-dev...

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:41PM (#33251973)
> What the hell are you talking about?

Care to try again? This time, pretend you know how to have a conversation.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by Firmwarrior on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:05PM (#33255278)
Ah, sorry man. In my defense, you went on this long exposition that assumed implicitly that everyone at Microsoft has no idea what they're doing. I can appreciate that sentiment, but I got really frustrated trying to parse your "conceptually simple" idea.

Anyway, didn't mean to start a flame war, I was just hoping to make sense of what you were trying to say

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:02AM (#33258317)
I think the bit you missed before your reaction is that this comment was about the decisions MS made back then. Not now. Not today. In fact quite a few of the replies to my comment are from a current frame of reference. Even the link to the current Samsung/Windows integration misses the point (all you have to do is read the ridiculously complex installation and setup instructions to understand).

MS, back then, missed a golden opportunity to create a truly useful differentiated product that, in my opinion, would have had a very high probability of success. The bar wasn’t as high as it is today. Slick, seamless integration between phone and desktop would have been an amazing feature. No, that did not mean running CAD on your phone. Again, the context is 2010, not today. I think that was iPhone 3 era. Something as simple as being able to seamlessly make and receive calls, send and receive SMS and do the same with email with either device, desktop or phone, would have been magical back then. Take a call in the car while you arrive at the office, once you get to your desk you put on your headset and the call continues through your computer. You can send text or links from your PC via SMS to the other person. Record the conversation if needed (with legal provisions in place). Etc. Again, don’t think 2022, think 2010.

Everything is conceptually simple. It is easy to talk about ideas, quite another matter to actually implement them and do it well. Concepts are usually simple; reality is difficult.

It isn’t that MS was full of unintelligent people who don’t know what they are doing. Not at all. The history of business is full of stories of intelligent and very capable people completely missing the mark or failing to recognize a shift in their industry. There’s a great book about this very subject: The Innovators Dilemma. In fact, the author makes the argument that some of these bad decisions are the result of good management.

BTW, I used “seamless” to describe something that is intimately integrated to the system. No installation. Think of good USB peripherals that just work.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:24PM (#33269836)
Everything you listed requires integration between the hardware and the software running in lockstep. By 2010, Apple had 4 years worth of experience releasing operating systems that shared features between the phone, computer and the iPad.

Apple has also started designing its own processors by then for the iPad and the iPhone 4.

Even the idea of taking a call from your phone and transferring to your computer using the same headset took a specialized processor and micro operating system on the headset to work on AirPods. Microsoft didn’t have tte hardware expertise then and still doesn’t.

Even today in 2022, the ARM processors that MS uses in their laptops are so bad that you can run x86 Windows programs running Windows ARM in a VM on a Mac faster than a Microsoft laptop.

As far as the Innovators Dilemma, the author was completely wrong about the iPhone.

https://stratechery.com/2013/clayton-christensen-got-wrong/

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:11AM (#33270737)
Everything I listed was more than possible in 2010. I have been developing hardware/software products for 40 years. I have absolutely no doubt about that at all. The company that controlled the OS and hardware (MS) had all the freedom, smarts and capability to make that happen. All they lacked --conjecture on my part-- was the vision.

> As far as the Innovators Dilemma, the author was completely wrong about the iPhone.

Have you actually read the book? His iPhone predictions had nothing whatsoever to do with the core ideas, excellent historical perspective and analysis provided in Innovators Dilemma.

Quoting from the very link you provided (emphasis mine):

"It is Christensen’s second theory of disruption – low-end disruption – that I believe is flawed. Christensen first described this theory in Disruption, Disintegration and the dissipation of differentiability, and expanded on it in The Innovator’s Solution. It is this theory that is at the basis of Christensen’s critique of Apple quoted above."

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @01:36AM (#33271182)
> Everything I listed was more than possible in 2010

Microsoft could have designed a processor like what was in the AirPods in 2010? Five years before Apple?

Besides, by 2010, Apple was already the best in the business at supply chain management and was manufacturing more high end devices than anyone in the world.

What high performance hardware was Microsoft shipping in 2010? The state of the art mobile hardware in 2010 was Apple’s ARM A4 - a 32 bit single core processor that ran from 800Mhz - 1Ghz. It could barely run Safari by 2011 let alone a full office suite.

> Have you actually read the book? His iPhone predictions had nothing whatsoever to do with the core ideas, excellent historical perspective and analysis provided in Innovators Dilemma.

He tried to apply his “low end disruption theory” from the 60s and he was completely wrong about Apple.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:20AM (#33285109)
> Microsoft could have designed a processor like what was in the AirPods in 2010? Five years before Apple?

The features that would have been ground-breaking at the time did not require the kinds of advanced processors we have today. Not even close. This stuff isn't all that complex. Yes, it would have taken time and effort to implement, yet none of it was anywhere close to impossible for 2010.

Perhaps you are not a hardware engineer? Like I said, none of what I mentioned was impossible or challenging in 2010. Hard work? Yes, of course.

> by 2010, Apple was already the best in the business at supply chain management

No, not really. Excellent, without a doubt, of course.

> It could barely run Safari by 2011 let alone a full office suite.

Again, context is important here. What would have been disruptive in 2010 had nothing to do with running a full office suite or CAD on your phone in 2010. I had both an iPhone and Windows Phone back then. MS could have provided what I would call next-generation integration with the desktop using the hardware of the day. More than capable.

It wasn't an issue of 2010 technology not being adequate for the implementation of such integration. It was a matter of vision, direction or both. Someone, for whatever reason, simply did not make that decision. The decision MS seemed to make at the time was to try to go head-to-head with the iPhone with a product that, in my opinion, did not offer an attractive-enough value proposition. As a result, it was doomed to go nowhere almost from inception.

> He tried to apply his “low end disruption theory” from the 60s and he was completely wrong about Apple.

I think you missed my point. This is not part of "Innovators Dilema". The erroneous prediction you correctly noted was part of different work by the same author.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:34AM (#33286925)
> No, not really. Excellent, without a doubt, of course.

By 2010, Apple was shipping 50 million iPhones a year and had just started shipping iPads. Under Tim Cook, Apple had been buying up the majority of flash storage for years between the iPods and the iPhone.

Also, while you “appeal to authority”. It’s not like you can’t find information on the web about how far ahead Apple was already starting to become by 2010. In 2013, they shipped a 64 bit mobile CPU years before every one else.

It’s hard to manufacture hardware at scale especially when you can’t just be a piece assembly like Dell and you have to design everything yourself and get third party hardware manufacturers to cooperate.

> I think you missed my point. This is not part of "Innovators Dilema". The erroneous prediction you correctly noted was part of different work by the same author.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by dang on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:49PM (#33255634)
Please don't respond by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That just makes everything worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:53PM (#33269661)
Well, as you can clearly see, it did not. Sometimes --not always-- the right thing to do is to highlight such things.

I am perfectly satisfied with @Firmwarrior's response, which led to posting an explanation of my position. In other words, we had a conversation. Had things derailed into name calling you'd have a point. I did not appreciate you scolding me, but we are all big boys. I'll live.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by dang on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:19PM (#33269807)
I'm talking about the general case, and it certainly makes everything worse in the general case.

Please just follow the rules in the future. You obviously broke them there.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by dang on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:49PM (#33255638)
> What the hell are you talking about?

If you'd please edit swipes like that out of your posts to HN, we'd appreciate it. Your comment would be just fine without that bit.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by pjmlp on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:51PM (#33252125)
They kept rebooting the development experience, naturally even the more passionate Windows developers gave up.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by BitwiseFool on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:39PM (#33253557)
>"Something as conceptually simple as a docking station that instantly brings your phone into your desktop as a first class integrated app, able to interact with other applications, including browsers, would have been a huge step forward and a massive selling point for Windows Phone."

I feel like the hardware limitations of 2005-2015 would have made this nigh impossible. I know a few ultra-portable devices were trying to do something like this around that time, but even then they were still well above the size of smartphones. Cellular data and bandwidth was also extremely limited at that time as well, so cloud style/thin client file access would also be impractical.

I can understand wanting to make a new OS/UI because the pocket PC experience was quite clunky and those devices did not have widespread adoption. There was also the novelty factor of using touch and gestures instead of a stylus. Anything resembling the windows/desktop paradigm would have been seen as antiquated. I'm sure Steve Jobs would have exploited that as strongly as he possibly could.

All in all, I like the concept you have presented. I just don't think that it would have been viable at the time and I can forgive Microsoft for making the choices they made back then.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by avrionov on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:52PM (#33253751)
> "Instead, they made a separate device. This was, from the perspective of desktop integration, 100% indistinguishable from any of the other offerings out there. "

They made a device which was worse than all of the existing devices. The initial version didn't have TCP /IP support, only HTTP. The app store was full of scams, etc.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:30PM (#33255937)
> Something as conceptually simple as a docking station that instantly brings your phone into your desktop as a first class integrated app, able to interact with other applications, including browsers, would have been a huge step forward and a massive selling point for Windows Phone

What would be amazing about this? I have one subscription to Office365 and I can start working on a document on my Mac and then work on the sabe document on my iPhone, iPad or on the web. I can take calls from my Mac from my iPhone, copy and paste between them, bookmarks are shared, I can send a text message from my Mac, my AirPods seamlessly switch, my iPad works as a second display or I can use my keyboard and mouse to control both.

What would one docked device do for me?

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:09PM (#33264254)
what does it do for the switch?
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:06PM (#33265005)
You mean the AirPods?

I paired my AirPods to my phone and they were automatically paired to my Watch, iPad, Mac, and two AppleTVs.

When I put the AirPods in my ear, whether I am on my Mac, iPad or iPhone, sound is automatically redirected.

If I am on my iPad watching a video, and I take a call or start watching something on my phone, the AirPods automatically switch to my phone and the video pauses on my iPad.

When I walk out the house for a run with just my cellular Apple Watch, I start listening to music on my Watch and it switches.

Switching isn’t automatic for an AppleTV since that would be irritating for a shared device. But it will display a pop up and ask do you want to switch.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:13PM (#33265094)
heh, I meant Nintendo Switch, the console :)

I was responding to the idea that being able to dock a mobile device has no advantages.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:22PM (#33265209)
Well shit I just went into a long explanation for no reason :)
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by P5fRxh5kUvp2th on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:57PM (#33265688)
All good :)

I've always been a huge fan of how integrated Apple products are. I don't own a mac and only a single phone at a time, but even the integration between itunes on windows and that phone is surprisingly good.

I have 1st gen airpods. I've read bad things about the newer gens (malfunctions and the like). any experience with them?

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:16PM (#33265917)
My AirPod Pros 1st gen did get the buzzing problem after they were out of warranty. I just went into the local Apple Store and they replaced them for free.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by robomartin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:48PM (#33269636)
> What would be amazing about this?

I'll cut-and-paste the relevant portion of another comment:

"I think the bit you missed before your reaction is that this comment was about the decisions MS made back then. Not now. Not today. In fact quite a few of the replies to my comment are from a current frame of reference."

That, in the context of that time, would have been amazing.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by hakfoo on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @12:50AM (#33257823)
There's a valid question about how much usage patterns differ on different form factors.

It feels like the last two points you make contradict each other: there's a huge difference between "extension to desktop" and "pick up desktop stuff and go".

Obviously, for a myriad of hardware and UI reasons, we're not doing the latter typically. The people demented enough to want desktop software in their pocket buy a GPD Win or the like.

The real issue is behaviour patterns, though. Give me the performance of my desktop in a six-inch pocketable device with two day battery life, and I'm still going to use it very differently.

Where do many of us spend most of our workdays? In an IDE or office suite. No matter what you do, you're not going to be able to shrink those down and be usable for anything but the most trivial tweaks on a six inch screen with a glass keyboard. We sort of saw this attempted in the early days of Windows CE/Pocket PC with its silly little Portable Office apps. A docking station might make it usable when I get BACK to a desk, but at that point, I may as well just be using the phone as an expensive flash drive for sneakernet.

Okay, maybe gaming? Potentially, if done right. Genshin Impact making 82 bazillion dollars out of a game that scales from phones to desktops is the poster child. But as anyone with a Steam Deck can demonstrate, you have to pick stuff that was designed to work well with the form factor. That undermines the dream of "the entire universe of cool stuff your desktop has to offer".

Media consumption? Even that's different. People may prefer local storage to streaming due to unreliable/slow/expensive mobile data, and the media they consume is often different too. I don't want to binge 90-minute episodes of anything on a phone.

So we've basically tossed out most of the obvious answers for "seamless desktop extension". This means one of two things: 1) We're drilling in the wrong place. The desktop extensions we need are such paradigm shifts nobody has even given us a good demo 2) The things that define the mobile ecosystem currently-- for example, apps that lean heavily on "it has GPS and cameras", lightweight games, low-commitment consumption of media-- shape the market because they're the best use cases we've found for the form factor.

I liked Windows Phone. I still have three of them in my box of bad mobile device decisions (somewhere I think there's a Palm Pre too) What I liked about it was that it seemed to have a clear and cohesive design language, and it was reliably snappy on cheap hardware. We've basically given up on the former, but Android has managed to close the gap somewhat on the latter, probably mostly through surfing on Moore's Law.

Microsoft could have had one other chance, but I think they've already blew it: as privacy is becoming a selling point (see Apple and DuckDuckGo marketing), positioning themselves as "we have a business model that's not 96% ad-dependent, so we're not going to sell out your personal life for a quick nickel" could have made them the trustworthy choice, but they've burnt through any credibility they had on that front in the last few years.