News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by dmitriid on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:08AM (#33248414)
> Windows was demoted to one section of the company’s Surface announcements held as a precursor to the main event.

We see this with Windows and with MacOS. MacOS's downfall is the more visible one.

The OS is no longer prioritized except where it needs to be somewhat presentable in screenshots. The OS becomes a vehicle to sell company goods. The OS rots to the point that there's no one left at the company with even the most basic competence to create first-party apps for it.

Because the money is elsewhere.

I wonder at which point this neglect makes the OS so unusable that it actively hurts the development of the money-making machines.

Though strangely enough MS would survive this better than Apple.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by pjmlp on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:23AM (#33248708)
Anyone doing Windows desktop development can definitly feel this.

After the mismanagement of WinRT, finally fixed with UWP on Windows 10, instead of improving the .NET Native and C++/CX experience, they created Project Reunion, deprecated .NET Native and C++/CX, replacing them with lesser tooling, pivoted Project Reunion into Windows SDK, and are years away of reaching feature parity with UWP, let alone Forms, WPF, MFC.

The current team seems composed by interns without experience on previous Microsoft frameworks, while the more experienced folks seem to have moved into Azure, Google or Amazon, from their twitter feeds.

Just have some fun going through the WinUI, CsWinRT, C++/WinRT, WinAppSDK, Win2D, and see the endless amount of bug tickets, measured in thousands.

Blazour seems to be the new kid in town, to the point of even trying to push it inside MAUI as pseudo-Electron replacement.

Meanwhile the other business units are focused on Web or Android.

It looks like "Azure OS" is the new Windows.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by cjbgkagh on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:19PM (#33249770)
I noticed the same, I can’t believe inexperience of the developers Microsoft has picked to work on these important frameworks. It appears like a form of self sabotage.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by spaetzleesser on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:31PM (#33251002)
“The current team seems composed by interns without experience on previous Microsoft frameworks, “

That’s my suspicion too. And I believe they did the same thing with Teams and hired some interns who are learning Agile to rapidly deliver “feature”.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by nvrspyx on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:43PM (#33251167)
Windows really is a clusterf*k right now. In addition to the mess of frameworks that you talk about, Windows 11 has been a mess. From the random Bing-related crap getting increasingly prevalent and pervasive around the OS to the TPM fiasco (they originally let you install it on non-supported hardware but are now withholding updates). From the feature regression (e.g., taskbar is now immovable) to the yet-another-redesign that they teased/leaked during Build this year.

At this point, I'd prefer an Azure OS that I could install locally and have the Windows team slowly transition to supporting Wine, improving Linux DEs/Wayland (or even create their own DE), since I believe that they're using some Wayland compositor (mutter?) for gWSL anyways, and contributing to the Linux kernel, which they're already doing to some degree. I genuinely don't know how feasible that is and I'm aware it's wishful thinking, but a person can dream.

Then again, it would probably be to the Linux community's detriment and they'd just do the same scummy Bing/telemetry/dark pattern crap to foster ad revenue.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by CatWChainsaw on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:27PM (#33256306)
The taskbar is now immovable?? When did that happen?
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by nvrspyx on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:58PM (#33256509)
Sorry, I was slightly off. It can only be aligned to the bottom or left now (no right or top alignment). This change was made with Windows 11.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by edandersen on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @02:19AM (#33258400)
Only the taskbar's icons can be aligned to the center or the bottom left of the taskbar at the bottom of the screen. The taskbar cannot be moved to the left, right or top of the screen in Windows 11, a huge regression.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by krinchan on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:52PM (#33256468)
I didn’t even realize that widgets were so under-developed? I legit thought I’d look into writing one today as I suddenly had a use case. Apparently at the moment the only way to write one is Win32 flavored C++ and a bunch of COM Black Magic. One would assume from their marketing that they’d have at least started at .NET. But instead it’s C++ and Someday(TM) PWAs (via Edge I assume) can provide widgets.

That just runs completely counter to all the Dev Experience marketing you get from them. It feels like Widgets were slapped together by the kernel team at the last minute.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by pjmlp on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:54AM (#33259791)
When Longhorn failed, mostly due to WinDev sabotage[0], they doubled down on using COM, hence why since Vista all major Windows APIs are COM based, and if we are lucky there are some .NET bindings as well.

WinRT is basically the evolution of this, going back to the design board as if .NET never happened, hence .NET Native and C++/CX abstracting what is basically COM + IInspectable + .NET metadata instead of TLB + App Identity.

WinRT eventually became UWP, as they improved the developer experience, only to kill .NET Native, replace C++/CX with C++/WinRT (similar dev experience as using ATL), and move that infrastructure on top of standard COM on Win32 side.

So now you have classical COM, and Windows Runtime components are the modern COM.

Meanwhile DevDiv seems to have had enough of this and decided to focus on .NET with cross platform experience, and Web technologies, hence why even Visual Studio is quite lacking on WinUI tooling.

[0] - If they really cared they would have doubled down on it like Android and ChromeOS did, and all those C# 7 - 11 performance improvements would have been done at the time.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by timeimp on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:11AM (#33248458)
The “death blow” for macOS would be when you can develop, compile, test and publish iOS apps without a Mac.

It would become on life support at that case.

Any Apple engineers reading this - an update like Snow Leopard would go a long way!

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by gw99 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:14AM (#33248529)
I doubt it. Most of the Mac users I know came from iOS and aren’t developers. The iOS developer community is a tiny portion of apple users.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by scarface74 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @08:36PM (#33255974)
You really think the majority of Mac users are creating iOS apps?
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by gw99 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:12AM (#33248477)
Do you actually use macOS? It actually works. Unlike most of windows these days. There is near parity across all platforms on all apple apps and functions. I can transition from any device to another one smoothly.

People don’t care about that. They want the computer to go away and actually stop bugging them.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by jacobr1 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:35AM (#33248945)
One of the other complaints you here on HN is that software is changing for sake of change rather than remaining relatively stable once the core feature-set has been built out. Well, MacOS strikes a pretty good balance on that score. They introduce new features, but haven't radically changed anything in a long time ... and that enables people to get work done.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by Hasu on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:24PM (#33249874)
Eh, I use macOS, Windows, and Ubuntu pretty regularly, and they're all pretty much fine. macOS gets in my way the most, but it's not significant trouble.

Other workflows than mine would probably have different results.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by danielrpa on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:31PM (#33250008)
No it doesn't, not for me. I don't work at MSFT and I own both a Windows machine and a Mac M1 for work. Simple things like my gaming mouse and wanting larger fonts on my 1440p monitor don't work without cumbersome hacks through buggy hobby software. My windows computer works flawlessly among other advantages such as a large software library right out of the box.

I respect people who prefer Macs to PCs, but stop speaking about it like it is some universal truth.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by marcodiego on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:16PM (#33250758)
> Simple things like my gaming mouse

If your gaming doesn't work correctly on an OS other than windows, it is probably the manufacturer fault.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by koluna on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:55PM (#33251354)
Ah yes, the good ol' Linux "You're holding it wrong" mantra.

Look, I don't know about you, but I don't have unlimited time to go fiddle with whatever emulation layer is there to make some game from 2017 work well on a modern Mac. Not only that, but Apple has proven, time and time again, that they completely do not care about backwards compatibility, which is crucial for games, so let's not pretend that the "manufacturer" (assuming you're talking about the game developers here) is at fault - nobody has unlimited time to adjust their product on the whims of the folks in Cupertino.

Here's the reality - on Windows, I can still play DOS games. On macOS, with the latest OS release, 90% of my Steam library cannot be used (that were all perfectly fine before the update) because Apple decided to remove support for 32-bit apps. So sticking to Windows for gaming is the logical choice if you want access to the latest and greatest titles and not a selection of a few that are "hacked around".

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by gw99 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:23PM (#33251742)
100% agree with this as a Mac user.

But the mouse, if it doesn't work and it says it does on the box then that is the vendor issue.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by isaacremuant on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:52PM (#33252142)
You're being unfair to Linux if you think Windows doesn't do the same "you're not supposed to do that" every time you step out of a nice path. Or even with the nice path it'll suddenly decide it's time to worsen your experience to improve their marketing or data mining.

There's awesome Linux experiences out there and the Steam deck is starting to show what's possible giving varying levels of control.

We live in exciting times. The more choice, the better.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by pie_flavor on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @04:00PM (#33253023)
On Mac, your apps reliably break. On Windows, they never break. It's not whether there's a right way and a wrong way, it's whether the right way stands at complete odds to how anyone actually wants to use the computer. Sure, Linux has a reasonable experience most of the time - that has nothing to do with Mac, and in fact has very little to do with Linux or its community either; Steam has nearly single-handedly made it work. The same way Windows tries to make it work, and the way Mac notably tries not to.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by koluna on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:07PM (#33256176)
Steam Deck is nice, but let's not kid ourselves that it's anywhere close to what Windows has to offer. Most games in my Steam library still are not Steam Deck compatible, and chances are they never will either because they are too old or because they require new OS components that embed themselves around kernel APIs (separate conversation on whether that is good or bad).

Again - not necessarily saying that the Windows experience is ideal, but it's the absolute best out of the available options.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by technion on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:15PM (#33254776)
As a real side issue, you actually can optionally remove support for 32 bit apps from Windows server.

Guess how much malware suddenly can't execute.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by koluna on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:08PM (#33256184)
On a server, sure.

On a client machine where the bulk of the software I bought is 32-bit and it stops working overnight, that's less acceptable.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by technion on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @09:54PM (#33256484)
Yes it's definitely a "server with dedicated role" scenario.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by trap_goes_hot on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:01PM (#33251446)
In your own way, you are correct, but so are people who have the completely opposite experience. In our industry (biotech manufacturing) we rely Windows for everything. All the apps we use are Windows only. For us, there is no "parity across all platforms".
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by gw99 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @02:35PM (#33251885)
Yeah it's the same in my industry for some parts of it as well.

But that doesn't mean it works. It's literally only there because it is entrenched. A lot of the time it doesn't work and has an extremely large support cost.

Re:Microsoft Full Circle by trap_goes_hot on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:38PM (#33252750)
Sure, that is your view. But that isn't the only viewpoint. We don't seem to have any major issues with our systems, but I'm not an IT expert.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by gw99 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @05:41PM (#33254415)
It's not really just my view. You might be a lucky outlier. I get to sit on a lot of calls with tens of large and small organisations who have serious troubles on a daily basis. I've seen some real horrors out there. Independently everyone just thinks this is the status quo.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by trap_goes_hot on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @06:35PM (#33255008)
Okay, we just have a disagreement. Its no big deal. I appreciate your perspective.
Re:Microsoft Full Circle by dmitriid on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @03:17PM (#33252478)
I've been on MacOS for 15 years now. The iOSification and changes for changes' sake in the past years is evident to everyone. As for incompetence, it's enough to look at the new settings app that they shipped basically unchanged since the clusterfuck during betas and fixing only the most superficial of bugs.