They aren't relevant to the problems of making steel or non-ferrous metals or cement or plastics, or to the problems of shipping things around over long distances. Which we cannot avoid, while maintaining a high-tech civilisation.
This does not matter if it's one Potemkin village but it matters on the level of states and can be seen in statistics like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_energy_co... where probably every EU country is much lower than the US, for example.
If you make walk-able, mixed-use neighborhoods there is no guarantee people will use them.
In contrast, I bike over 1000 miles a year and walk several times a week. Yet I am not in a walk-able mixed use neighborhood nor have any interest in living in one.
> If you make walk-able, mixed-use neighborhoods there is no guarantee people will use them.
This isn't supported by the evidence. We see huge increases in the numbers of people walking and cycling when the infrastructure is adjusted to support them.
But is it serving as a car replacement for those people? I'd wager not due to a variety of factors. But I'd be curious if there was evidence it was for any significant percentage of them.
But how car centric different places are varies. Even if you only compare places with similar income levels to each other.
Go democracy!
---
Sorry for the sarcasm. I'm more and more leaning towards libertarianism nowadays.
Taxes are the price of civilization, we just need to be better about using them.
I was hoping that my phrasing made it obvious that I don't believe in the most extreme interpretation of that slogan. But I do believe there's truth in it.
Back to the infrastructure cost problem. I painted an insidious picture. Of course suburbanites are not mustache-twirling villains. They're just asking the government to maintain the infrastructure they use.
The problem is they're not willing to (vote for politicians who make them) pay for the true cost. When the cost is borne by other people, how is this not robbery with majority votes (and thus state power)?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkO-DttA9ew
> ...look at the map of his election victory. This was the suburbs politically dominating the will of old Toronto.
> ...because he advocated for more cars, he had the support of Toronto's suburbs. In other words he fed the addiction.
To quote George Bernard Shaw, "A government which robs Peter to pay Paul can always depend on the support of Paul."
I don't know about that. I'm living in London right now, and I'd hate to have a car. It would mean need a parking space all the time for it, for something I wouldn't use most days because almost everything I need say-to-day is a 10 min walk away, and if it isn't then it's a quick bus or tube ride away.
Hard to believe that we almost got Glasgow style inner city motorways:
https://www.gcat.org.uk/blog/?p=682
NB I lived in the centre of Edinburgh for over 30 years before moving across to Fife and commuting in by train - which is generally a pretty pleasant experience.
Edit: I very rarely drive into Edinburgh - its generally a nightmare.
Just providing it has a huge impact on a lot of "maybe" people and I think practice proofs this is not backwards thought at all. Not guaranteed, but a huge impact on most, nothing is binary as always.
> In contrast, I bike over 1000 miles a year and walk several times a week. Yet I am not in a walk-able mixed use neighborhood nor have any interest in living in one.
So really like to know, why is that. I can only imagine you are living rural, and now wouldn't understand why anyone living in a dense city would want to have it different.
Basically it would not provide much value to me as I'd still use a car all the time.
Plenty of evidence exists in 2022. Book a flight to Paris, Barcelona, Berlin, Milano ,Casablanca, Tunis …
I don’t know Asia or South america but I’m sure you can find some example running in production right now.
It’s just faster with public transportation or biking; or it’s so close that you walk there.
Also: parking is a nightmare that will add 10 to 30 min to your travel time. ( or make it even more expensive)
But your stats are great, I would be curious to find the same for Paris. To check my completely anecdotal assumption.
Edit:
- Paris 0,27 car / inhabitants
- Amsterdam (0,24)
- 0,33 : Bruxelles
- 0.35 : Berlin
- 0,36 : Madrid
- 0,41 :Barcelona
- 0.87 : Phœnix, AZ
You do realize that, statistically, you are a MASSIVE outlier - right?
> If you make walk-able, mixed-use neighborhoods there is no guarantee people will use them.
Statistics disagree here. Look up walking commute rates in walkable neighborhoods vs random suburbs. Look at vehicle ownership rates. Look at gasoline sales per capita, etc, etc.
> I propose that cars were made because people are lazy (or, in reality, have no time in this dual income era we live in - walking takes a lot of time, even if it is very enjoyable).
What's been proven is that people have set limits for how long they are willing to commute. If cars could drive 2x as fast, people who are willing to commute by train would live farther away from work. Ditto for train riders, bikers, or walkers.
The goal is to shrink the distance people who DON'T want to own a car have to live from work by building more housing and making nearby neighborhoods more walkable and bikable.
Many people in cities would rather not drive if the option was realistic.
Many people in America LOVE their cars, and will go to their grave defending car culture. But many people who drive cars do so out of necessity and would rather not.
I visit dense cities all the time and have friends that live in them. Even though they are walk-able, we are always driving across the city to visit that one shop, restaurant or park.
The vast majority of Madrid and Paris and Berlin are walkable. Sure, there are expensive neighborhoods. But most people can afford to live in walkable areas of pretty much everywhere beside London, some Asian outliers, & anywhere in the US.
> People think you can’t throw GPUs at solving an energy shock but in the medium term you really can if those GPUs are used by civil and chemical engineers and not to mine shitcoins.
I suspect 1 is usually missing because the obvious conclusion is that excess (and increasing) production capacities will mean people have more choices regarding their lifestyles. If you want walkable, go for it!
Also I would say passive solar design is only one part (and seemingly becoming less important) of Passivhaus way of building. Why not include all energy efficiency improvements?
1. Walkable, mixed-use neighborhoods
2. Passive solar design.
We have created a world highly dependent on various energy inputs. It has gone a long way towards killing off walking, cycling and vernacular architecture (where passive solar is a historic default).
Those technologies still exist. They can be brought back into more mainstream use.