News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:31AM (#33204008)
From what I've read Lufthansa never banned AirTags, regardless of what a misinformed customer service person on Twitter may have thought.

They clarified their guidelines to say that active transmitters were not allowed in the hold because they couldn't be put on to flight mode (pretty much correct according to ICAO guidelines), and then after all this blew up later clarified their position by confirming that AirTags do not count (also correct).

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by duxup on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:27AM (#33204824)
>From what I've read Lufthansa never banned AirTags

"Hi David, Lufthansa is banning activated AirTags from luggage as they are classified as dangerous and need to be turned off./Mony"

https://twitter.com/lufthansa/status/1578879849577385984

I think that's pretty explicit. Official policy somewhere else in the company might be different but it's hard to imagine how folks are supposed to know what is up when they say it clearly like that.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#33205577)
> regardless of what a misinformed customer service person on Twitter may have thought

I'd suggest that their published guidelines are probably more reliable than the interpretation of those being communicated for convenience by customer service reps. That's not to say this didn't have an impact, it clearly did, and customers should be able to trust this, but most of the reporting on this has treated it like an active decision to ban a particular device by a large company, rather than a misinterpretation by one individual in response to a question about a specific device.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by prange on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:51PM (#33206001)
What makes you think a customer service rep is operating the official Twitter account for a $40+BN company?
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:56PM (#33206045)
The fact that Twitter is a customer service channel, the tweet was sent with "Qualtrics Social Connect" which describes itself as a customer service tool, the fact that there was a personal sign-off on the tweet which big companies don't tend to do when they're making policy announcements, but that they do tend to do when a customer service rep is replying to a customer question. Plenty of large companies do this sort of support via their official account rather than through a dedicated support account, it generally provides a better customer experience because no one wants to look up an account like "LufthansaSupportEMEA".

I'm not sure what makes you think this is not a customer service interaction?

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by duxup on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:48PM (#33206667)
Not to disagree with your characterization of the tweet or response to the user, but what's the end point then?

"Don't believe our official twitter account if you think customer service is involved?"

I have trouble faulting anyone for believing what was a very clear statement on their official twitter account.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:49PM (#33237259)
There's a difference between the Lufthansa account tweeting out a statement, and a Lufthansa rep, named in the tweet, replying to one user. The reply means that it's hidden from anyone who isn't either following both users (unlikely) or actively seeking it out.

I see this interaction as closer to a customer service phone call where a rep got something wrong, and the only fallout should be that I as one single customer am now misinformed. The amount of checks and balances to ensure that messaging is correct doesn't need too high as it's low risk if one customer is misinformed. Whereas if Lufthansa makes a full statement they should expect all customers to be misinformed, or expect the press to pick it up.

This brings me back to my original point. I don't think the press reported on this well, because this was clearly not an official statement prepared for the press or the audience of all customers, with the level of thinking about it that should go into that sort of thing. It was clearly (to me) an isolated thing. The correct course of action for a journalist would be to confirm with Lufthansa, which appears not to have happened.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by prange on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:58PM (#33208160)
> the fact that Twitter is a customer service channel

This is circular reasoning. Nowhere is it established that Twitter is a customer service channel.

Other parts of your in your first paragraph makes sense, but are also non-obvious and reflects expertise and evidence collecting on your part.

Plenty of large companies do also use Twitter for PR rather than customer service.

Unless clearly stated otherwise, there is no reason for anyone to treat an official Twitter account as anything other than an official statement by a corporation, no different from their official blog, or website.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:45PM (#33237181)
It sounds like you are coming from the position of "prove to me Twitter does customer support", and you're right I went and gathered some evidence for this. If you started from that position though I think you're entirely justified in not realising this was a customer support interaction.

However, in my experience of ~14 years on Twitter, seeing support processes inside companies, and as a consumer, I think most consumers treat any two-way comms channel from a company as customer support regardless of whether the company is providing it. Many even treat review websites as customer support, despite it being wholly inappropriate for that.

Companies do support on Twitter because their customers are treating it like that, not the other way around.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by duxup on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:41PM (#33206595)
I think the "misinterpretation" is completely understandable considering their official outright said they banned them...

This wasn't even an interpretation, they say outright they're banning them.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by tlogan on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:20PM (#33207028)
If they just replied back and said “oh no - mistake: AirTags are allowed” then there will be no story. But they did not. So I called them and their customer support was not able to tell me. So I started believing that they really will not allow AirTags
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by duxup on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:05PM (#33207562)
The progression was really strange.

There were some folks in the media who reached out to PR people at the airline, some got "don't know" others were told "that's not our policy" ... but nobody updated the official twitter account for a while.

I agree 100%, just a mistaken tweet could have been solved with a timely new tweet.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by croes on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:55PM (#33206039)
But why do AirTags not count?
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by danpalmer on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:59PM (#33206096)
The guidelines are targeted at phones and other long range transmission equipment. AirTags use Bluetooth and have a relatively limited range, a very low transmission power, and don't really do much at all until they get pinged by another device.

It's also been fairly well understood for a while now that Bluetooth is not a concern on flights, and it uses an ISM radio frequency which is specifically set aside so as to not interfere with things like planes and other critical communications infrastructure.

Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by anaganisk on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:35PM (#33207887)
Even cellular dont, its more to protect towers in path being DDOsd by 100s of people at a time.
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by Dylan16807 on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:23PM (#33208958)
I've never seen a real citation for this, do you have one?
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by anaganisk on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:27PM (#33209004)
Its an FCC regulation, why would I need to cite it :p But anyway https://www.businessinsider.com/phone-airplane-mode-flight-e...
Re:Lufthansa awkwardly abandons AirTag ban after baffling fa... by Dylan16807 on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:38PM (#33209626)
"protect against radio interference" is extremely vague, I want something better and also evidence someone has made an assessment/update to cell service at least as modern as 3G.

"picking up service from multiple cell towers" seems like a guess if it's solely based on the above words, and also that's a significantly different explanation than you gave above.