News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by unknownaccount on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:58PM (#33184107)
Did Alex Jones personally harass any families or he being punished for what independent actors did?
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by JellyBeanThief on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:07PM (#33184243)
He's not on trial for harassment.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by chris_wot on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:38PM (#33184639)
The guy claimed they were all crisis actors.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by HyperSane on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:06PM (#33184225)
They aren't independent actors because they were highly impressionable people whose actions were influenced by Jone's lies.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by unknownaccount on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:09PM (#33184262)
This is what the erosion of personal responsibility and accountability looks like. Alex Jones isnt responsible if stupid impressionable people watch his show and do stupid things. That is absurd and absolutely chilling in regards to free speech. Perhaps it even sets a new precedent that everyone who posts a comment/video/podcast online is now responsible for any illegal actions that any of their viewer commit.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by Retric on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:25PM (#33184482)
Free speech isn’t simply the ability to say anything at anytime.

If you lie under oath don’t expect a free speech argument to work. Similarly if you personally spread damaging lies, free speech doesn’t help etc etc.

Free speech is most protected when when you take a political or religious stance, but the boundaries shrink dramatically when you talk about someone specific especially if they are simply a member of the general public.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by more_corn on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:53PM (#33184812)
I think the closing remark at the last trial was: “Speech is free, but you have to pay for the lies Mr Jones”
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by ericmay on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:25PM (#33184474)
You can see that this isn’t the case with a trivial example, like if your significant other or a family member was killed and I or someone else riled you up and enabled you and lied to you and convinced you to go kill someone else who didn’t kill your family member not only would I be held legally/criminally accountable but we intuitively understand this as morally wrong as a society.

No free speech is harmed here and the First Amendment protects you from the government silencing your speech.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by helf on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:23PM (#33184455)
Oh here we go… rolls eyes

This is not “chilling to free speech”.

Spewing hatred and demonstrably false utter bullshit and stirring up people knowingly is what he has and continues to do. Just like any number of other sociopathic fuckwits out there and through the ages.

“Personal responsibility and accountability “ is exacty what he’s being held accountable for because /his/ actions, /his/ drivel, /his/ psychotic vitriol was /knowingly/, /willingly/, and /joyfully/ used to cause these problems.

Your logic would dictate that no one is ever at fault for causing anything. It’s the dipshits who are dumb enough to go with them who are at fault.

I mean, step back and listen to yourself for a moment.

Unless you are too far gone you MIGHT recognize the absurdity of your views.

I am so fucking tired of human trash like him, Glenn Beck, Joe Rogan, Trump, insert hundreds of other pieces of shit getting to do literally whatever they want because “personal accountability” dictates that what they said was just words and free speech and they aren’t at fault.

Give. Me. A. Fucking. Break.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by unknownaccount on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:32PM (#33184577)
Alex Jones wasnt the mastermind who created this conspiracy theory. The crisis actors conspiracy theory was already popular on the internet a couple days after the incident. There were a lot of people speculating at the time, and some strange discrepencies in the official narrative and footage was able to convince some otherwise very reasonable people that there was a possibility that it was a hoax. So no, it cant be said for certain that he knew it was false. And no, he cant be blamed for covering a popular conspiracy theory on his show when its well known that he performs a conspiracy theory talkshow. This a clear case of punishing a citizen for having the wrong opinion.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by abliefern on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:48PM (#33184748)
Five minutes of research shows that this isn't true and that he knew.

I'm not sure anyone is seriously attributing the conspiracy theory to him, they are attributing to him that he spread it, publicly attacking the families while making money doing so.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by tptacek on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:56PM (#33184867)
I'm pretty sure it's a clear case of punishing a citizen for building a hundred million dollar supplement business on false allegations about the parents of dead children that were made so repeatedly they had to go into hiding, and then boycotting the resulting defamation trial. But tomato, tomahto.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by HyperSane on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:02PM (#33208196)
"Alex Jones wasnt the mastermind who created this conspiracy theory."

But he constantly repeated it using his very loud platform in an effort to make money.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by Rapzid on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:09PM (#33185496)
These are the legal hot takes of our times; on HN no less.

There aren't laws against defamation and libel because it's super meany. It's because the damages people sustain from having lies spread around town about them.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by HyperSane on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:00PM (#33208179)
"Alex Jones isnt responsible if stupid impressionable people watch his show and do stupid things. "

He absolutely is.

"This is what the erosion of personal responsibility and accountability looks like. "

Quite the opposite, Jones is being being made accountable for the harm he caused the parents of the Sandy Hook victims.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by mjfl on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:09PM (#33184996)
That's such bullshit
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by Georgelemental on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:43PM (#33185281)
Ah yes, we should let the government decide that some people are "highly impressionable" and therefore not human beings with agency or rights. That's definitely not a terrifying precedent to set, nothing to see here
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by threatofrain on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:39PM (#33186151)
If I tell you to harass families and you go ahead and do so, both you and I ought to face legal risk. And that's what's happening here. As this is an entirely private tort between private individuals, it is up to the individuals involved to decide which of the many responsible parties they wish to sue.

As it happens, Alex Jones is also enjoying his prerogative to sue others for defamation.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by HyperSane on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:56PM (#33208130)
No, we let the courts decide and they did. Jones isn't being sent to prison, he is just being forced to compensate the people his blatant lying harmed. I bet if Jones had spent the last 10 years constantly saying that you ate babies and this caused people to track you down and harass you then you would want him to stop and compensate you.

The only terrifying precedent is to allow shameless grifters like Alex Jones to lie with complete impunity no matter how much harm his lies cause.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by mostafas on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:07PM (#33184230)
Did Hitler personally kill any Jews? Did Putin personally kill any Ukrainians?

Sorry to invoke Godwin's law so early.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by incrudible on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:19PM (#33184398)
Did Alex Jones order anyone to do anything? Honest question.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by lurgburg on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:11PM (#33185012)
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/stochastic_terrorism

He could have anticipated his actions would lead to these outcomes.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by incrudible on Thursday October 13, 2022 @05:32AM (#33188986)
Seems like a word that needed to be invented to attribute responsibility to someone who isn't actually responsible. Would be a great tool for a totalitarian state to abuse.

There's quite a few passages in the bible (among many books) that, if recited, could be described as "stochastic terrorism". That is, they could "inspire violence". However, I'm sure double standards would be applied rigorously - to make sure it's not a problem for "the right people".

If that's his actual "crime", I don't like the way this is going. What goes around, comes around.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by unknownaccount on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:18PM (#33184385)
No but this still establishes a scary new precedent; that any podcaster/videomaker is now legally responsible for any illegal actions that their viewers commit on their own accord. I can imagine how this will result in people being scared to criticize any leader or person in power because their comment/video might inspire some crazy person to harass them for which they will be found legally responsible.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by helf on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:29PM (#33184534)
Omg no it doesn’t. You know damn well that some random streamer or podcaster isn’t the same as some of these heavy hitters of insanity.

And even ignoring that then YES, YES they should be held accountable if they are knowingly spewing falsehoods and stirring up people and it causes shit like that.

“Free speech” != “I can be a total fuckwad and say whatever so want without any repercussions!”

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by unknownaccount on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:58PM (#33185874)
I dont think different standards should apply to someone just because they have a popular show.

Sue the individuals who actually committed the acts of harassment, not Alex Jones. The people actually responsible for the harassment are getting away with it unscathed here, while a performer is punished. This isnt justice.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by tptacek on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:57PM (#33186620)
It's not a different standard for having a popular show. It's the same standard, scaled by the reach and impact of his show. It's like the difference between plowing into a crowd of people on a dirt bike and plowing into a crowd of people with a semi truck. And, I assure you, Alex Jones is culpable under US law for the harassment these parents endured, just as someone who destroys your professional reputation is culpable from the losses you endure when unrelated people incorrectly refuse to hire you.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by kaba0 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:47PM (#33184740)
It’s like there is this wall between US people’s understanding of free speech and a usual EU residents’. The same way Holocaust denial should be punishable, there are sane rules that must be abided, otherwise only chaos ensues. It won’t take you down an Orwellian dystopia any time soon, if anything, allowing these criminals selling an alternative reality will.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:12PM (#33185031)
>wall between US people’s understanding of free speech and a usual EU residents’

If the split so nicely mirrored political boundaries we wouldn't be having this discussion. We're having this discussion because incompatible ideologies are fighting for control of one country.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by notacoward on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:13PM (#33185520)
American right-wing authoritarians have a weird relationship with the slippery slope fallacy. On the one hand, holding someone accountable for making claims which they admitted they knew were false, leading to demonstrable harm to the victims' families, then failing even to comply with court procedure or instructions, is such a slippery slope that clearly the entire first amendment (which isn't even relevant in this case) at risk. See also: gun laws. On the other hand, draconian anti-abortion laws supposedly aren't a slippery slope at all, even though they have already resulted in thousands of women being denied life-saving medications for completely unrelated medical conditions. It's almost like the they're picking and choosing when to use these arguments (see also: originalism) based on something other than logic or morality.

What's really abhorrent is that people are invoking "freedom" (in this case of speech) to defend someone who is a major player in the movement toward authoritarian control over literally every part of our lives. If I hadn't lost all respect for such people decades ago, I certainly would now.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by joenathanone on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @06:15PM (#33184348)
If you falsely yell 'fire' in an occupied building, you are responsible for the resulting damages.