Because its outside the scope & role of the government?
> I really don't understand how this stuff is still not regulated anywhere
This is a common theme I see in alot of discussions about everything. Do not confuse regulation with enforcement. Any regulation that is not enforced is useless, or it is used selectively (a.k.a "corruption"). Adding more rules wont solve anything.
And plus, we have the rules. Match group, who basically own the entire western world online dating market, should have not been allowed to buy all their competitors in the first place. This is a failure of the regulating bodies to do anything and now the users end up paying the price.
Is it? Governments care very much about what their demographics will be in the future. Governments get involved in trying to modify birth rate. Hooking people up seems like an interesting idea, especially if the government thinks they're going to deal with massively bad demographic shift I the midterm future.
That doesn't align with the fact that there are government funded programmes for things like mental well being, sexual health and education, and even music appreciation.
The government is concerned with whatever the heck we say it is. It's _our_ government.
P.S. No, I don't live in America ;)
This is such a weird take when you think about it. It's like saying "people can just run traffic lights; therefore, adding more traffic lights cannot prevent accidents." Okay, well, preventing people from running traffic lights is just a separate issue that should also be solved if it's a problem. The answer isn't to stop putting up traffic lights! And it doesn't follow that some people not following the rules means rules are worthless. Besides, different governments (and different agencies within governments) have vastly different levels of "teeth". I know it's easy to get jaded seeing all the regulatory capture in the U.S., but that's not the entire world. Even in the U.S. some regulations are rigorously enforced, e.g. FAA regulations.
They are so incompetent that famine/frost/nuclear apocalypse are serious possibilities..
Seriously though, this seems like an area where anti-trust and transparency regulation (service X has a Y rating for producing matches that meet standard Q) could play a useful role.
Because dating apps have distorted courting even if we elect to ignore them.
They alter expectations and make the proverbial sea seem much more filled with fish than it truly is.
And even if this distortion has no impact on us, we can't control whether or not it has had impact on our prospective date(s).
Why would your date willfully overlook a glaring fault of yours, for instance, if they have 999 likes in their pocket from seemingly-flawless suitors?
Hell, even if your date doesn't use dating apps either, then they likely know what's available from friends, relatives, etc.
Users that want relationships want to find someone ASAP and delete the app.
Those two goals are completely incompatible.
We’re not still confusing bypassing encryption by compromising device security with “[undermining] effective cryptosystems” like those articles when everyone was leaving WhatsApp?
In Plato's Republic, he proposed his vision for a utopian city-state. Essentially, citizens would be ranked into castes: bronze/iron for laborers and artisans, silver for soldiers, gold for leaders. When people came of age in this utopia, they would be paired off through what they would be told is a random lottery.
In reality, however, the city's leaders would decide on the couplings ahead of time, pairing like with like. Plato called this the "noble lie", and it neatly demonstrates what any government-run dating system would probably develop into: a systemic eugenics program.
I just want the incentive of making profit removed and provide a decent service that does what it promises. If that service can only be provided at a loss (which seems to be the case) then let the state do it. Nobody would force anyone to use it.
Well-intentioned government mandates have a nasty habit of being used coercively when authoritarian-minded administrations get their turn at the helm.
Publicly-run (= by government) open source script would be most transparent I guess. Otherwise some sort of algorithm would sneak in sooner or later.
In a future where dating apps (and technology in general) becomes the only way to meet potential mates, only those who successfully "engage" with the apps/tech in a way that the company approves of will be allowed to reproduce.
Those that either refuse to engage on principles, or don't "engage" with it the "right" way (let's say by not falling for dark patterns, etc) and end up banned are effectively prevented from reproducing.
Both options can end up dystopian, but I'll take a government-run scheme any day. Not only are governments at least theoretically accountable to their citizens, but they are also as slow as molasses and terrible at tech, so they'd fare much worse at eugenics than a private company.
Blaming online dating sites for mental health problems and mass shooting is a new one. I don't discount the feeling of despair that can occur on dating sites for men. However, the experience of a being woman on a dating app is absolutely harrowing, even if you have incredibly low standards and/or are incredibly desirable.
To put it differently, I'm reading your argument as equivalent to saying that the existence of the USPS (which will deliver to remote rural areas, despite the fact that doing so isn't profitable) is more dystopian than the existence of UPS and FedEx (which will not).
I once was a part of making a Facebook clone for the US military so service men and women wouldn't be on Facebook giving away secrets.
It was garbage and nobody used it but nobody cared because we weren't being paid to get people to use it.
https://www.msf.gov.sg/policies/Marriages/Pages/Finding-a-Pa...
The problem is the population has already been divided and Match exists using predatory practices. You could maybe dethrone it using regulations or an organic campaign.
0 [ https://www.pof.com ]
https://www.msf.gov.sg/policies/Marriages/Pages/Finding-a-Pa...
You could say they can tap into that currently, and that's probably true, but deliberately broadcasting it to them would probably be out of question for many people.
Also, consider what government run IT projects look like. Now mix that with a dating app, perfect recipe for a disaster.
From what I heard it's mostly speed-dating stuff.
EDIT: Aand I got ninja'ed. Twice.
https://www.upi.com/Top_News/World-News/2017/06/27/China-lau...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/comrade-me...
Sounds like a great idea. I nominate NSA as the host organization. You wouldn't even need to bother creating a profile, they will just use all the surveillance data to find you the best matches.
https://crossdysfunctional.tumblr.com/post/109024982557/fund...
I think the fundamental problem is that more men always sign up on these apps than women. That would be true of a government app also. It seems like this ruins the experience for both men and women alike. I am speculating here because we don't really know much about how these apps work since no one releases their user data. But women I have talked to complain about married men, copy-pasted pickup lines, and men treating women like prostitutes. With my own experience men complain about fake accounts, having to do all the effort and getting nothing for it, and for both, meeting people, going on dates, and then after you've become attracted to each other you find out how deeply damaged and incompatible the other person is because they hid all their baggage.
A lot of this just seems like it's exacerbated by the use of an app. I think the apps drive decent people away. This is all speculation.
I somewhat think the whole proposition of online dating was doomed to fail. I don't know if a non profit/government office could fix this leaving aside how politics could affect it.
California kind of accidentally did so a few years. They thought they were simply running a public sex offender registry, but it occurred to some sex offenders it was also a state run directory of people that would be less likely to be put off by their own record and might even have at least one important shared interest to bond over.
The state was not pleased with this.
Popular does not mean effective. Online dating is the most toxic way of dating invented, so why would the governments contribute?
Your first mistake was thinking that culture actually cares about this.
All the options people have are using toxic apps which entire business model is to undermine the self-esteem of young men and scamming them out of their money. And then people wonder where the mental health problems and mass shootings come from.
I really don't understand how this stuff is still not regulated anywhere, it's a dangerous scam.