And this is something we could actually do. The government could take $X billion, get a cost-effective robotic car platform off the ground, start replacing vehicles on a 1-to-1 basis, and outlaw manual driving on public roads inside of 20 years. It would make existing electric vehicle technology perfectly suitable for trips of any length, since you can simply change cars at the charging station and be on your way inside of a minute. Completely feasible.
But alas... Inertia.
I highly recommend reading about Braess' Network Paradox for a great illustration of this.
There is no need to try and dictate the type of fuel, either.
But I'm interested to understand why people think a robotised taxi service would be much cheaper than human-driven taxi service. Is the driver really the highest marginal cost in the system? Does removing a driver really drive costs down that much? I wouldn't have thought so.
Oh, and your desire to ban manual driving is never going to fly. The most you would want is perhaps dedicated driverless roads where you aren't allowed to drive - much like bus lanes are now. That would allow for higher speed possible if computer systems can show they can safely transport occupants (or goods) at speeds higher than human drivers.
The overall cost of the system would be cheaper because you don't need as many cars. A human taxi service has tons of taxis sitting around doing nothing for some amount of time, parked somewhere when not in use, etc. If taxi were just an automated service you would just need enough cars to cover peak usage and you'd have more cheaper options on parking (e.g. parking can be LIFO, no need for each car to have exit access at all times).
>Oh, and your desire to ban manual driving is never going to fly.
I disagree. Once automated cars start gaining traction it will be pretty easy to make commercials of crying mothers talking about how they wish their star football player son had only taken an automated car, coupled with real traffic statistics. In a 100 years people are going to find the fact that we used to manually drive cars insane.
You would need just as many robotic cars as you would current taxis. The demand shape isn't going to change just because you remove the driver. Yes, parking and other things will improve but it's going to be a small improvement, not an order-of-magnitude jump.
They may have been at some point, but that hasn't been the case for some time.
>A total ban on manual driving is just not feasible in a democratic country.
I disagree. Maybe not this generation, but supporting manual driving makes the whole system less stable unless you make a road just for them, which is really expensive.
>You would need just as many robotic cars as you would current taxis.
I don't believe this is the case. I see taxis sitting empty for hours. In that time one taxi could have made several short trips. I'm certain that a computer calculating routes, etc., could manage to get the same work done as is being done now with less resources. That's why we made them, after all.
Absolutely. In Austin, we have car2go, a car sharing program that allows one-way trips. Gas, insurance, maintenance, parking, and any other cost you could think of is included in the price. It costs about six dollars for me to drive downtown from my apartment. A taxi costs $15.
This isn't a perfect comparison since I walk to a car2go, but a self-driving car might need to drive to pick you up. It's pretty close, though.
Another cost the car2go scheme is missing is the taxi licensing scheme, which most local governments use as a cash-cow by restricting supply and charging high recurring fees.
Add the fact that most robotic-trips are not going to be two-way and you're probably getting closer to $10 dollars for that trip, which, undoubtedly is still cheaper than with 'wetware' behind the wheel - but some people seem to be thinking this would be as cheap as mass transit, which to me is just wishful thinking.
But what technologies power the vehicles or enable the roads are secondary. The efficiencies gained by reducing vehicle size will slash costs.
A great many people will commute in a single seat vehicle with 50 horsepower if its a quarter of the cost per mile. Especially if they aren't stuck with it the rest of the time. As long as they can just as easily get larger vehicles for other occasions.
As far as alternatives to conventional roads, we already have them in major cities. Some are elevated and some are underground. Today only mass transit uses them, but I fully expect robotic cabs to destroy mass transit. Even people who don't value convenience will ultimately go for them. So subways and elevated railways, once abandoned by trains, will be converted so they can be used by individual vehicles.
Also, re: many smaller cars... who will purchase/maintain all those? We don't have the infrastructure to support that on many levels.
Personally, I think a system like that in /I, Robot/ is much more likely.
And the infrastructure we have now will continue to operate.
How will such an infrastructure be built and be operated. Its a mystery. But its already been done by private enterprise.
As to why only one slow lane could be used, I don't see why that would be. Perhaps you could explain. We have many lanes operating now and robotic vehicles would simply use the same lanes.
Perhaps PRT has these limitations. Robotic vehicles that operate like the vehicles that operate like the vehicles we already have wouldn't.
Of course, we do not yet have robotic vehicles that can be trusted to operate in rain or other extreme conditions and that can discern their environment well enough to be safe.
But once we, there's no reason to follow the PRT pattern. We'll simply follow the patterns we already have. Only with much more sharing (cabs) and much more efficiency.
But many features of today's automobile are there because of human needs for performance. Optimize for efficiency for a moped-like 3 wheeled vehicle and you may get something completely different.
http://www.niutoday.info/2011/09/14/supermileage-team-proves-nation’s-best-again/
I'm not saying cars will actually be like this, but robotic vehicles won't need mirrors or more than one seat or even a steering wheel. A lot of things are could change.I hope someday an america jammed to the gills with empty, idle hunks of steel looks as bizarre and wasteful as it actual is.
Imagine eliminating most visible parking. A small fraction of the world's vehicle fleet is in use at any given time; the rest of the time it's taking up a parking spot. Remove that and we can have wide sidewalks and bike lanes, parks and new development. Suburbanites get an extra room in their house and a bigger yard.
Buses and light rail become obsolete, but heavy rail transit becomes much more practical, because the door-to-door problem is solved. A virtuous cycle of improved convenience, leading to greater ridership, leading to more trains and shorter headways could result. It makes a lot more sense to ring the bay with a 150 mph train when getting to and from the train is easy. (Then again, it might be easier just to run the taxis at 150 mph on dedicated roads.)
Also, for parking, we can take advantage of LIFO. Today, every single car has to be able to get out independent of the others. With robot cars only the last one of a given type (e.g. van, pickup, sedan).
In reality, most people leave for work at the same time. So they all need a car at the same time. So we need the same number of cars as we have now.
Carpool? Did I hear somebody say carpool? With robotic drivers that works ... exactly as badly as it works now. My three nearest neighbors work in different TOWNS, not only different buildings or neighborhoods.
So I jump on Google Taxi, log in, reserve a car to show up and ... it says "next available taxi arrival, 2 hours before or after desired time". So I either get up at ass-oclock in the morning, or am chronically late for work. </rant>
It's my understanding that a taxi driver isn't the major cost in a taxi fare, and that fuel, capital cost + licence costs are the principal component in a taxi fare.
I doubt this sort of thing would make much of a dent in car sales, at least that wasn't offset by sales of the automated cars.
The biggest category for sales of cars is for people who regularly feature a combination of long & short drives in their life. This is typically not your average city-dweller, despite having larger numbers of people within cities. The average mum+2 kids isn't going to trade the family car in any time soon for this type of service, not when the cost of keeping and running an average family car isn't really that burdensome.
I agree that having a car running privately is a lower per-mile cost, but that discounts the number of 'dead' miles that a for-hire car drives - the private car always takes the person where they want to go, while ordering one up via the internet is going to at a minimum double the per-mile cost, because only half the miles (as an average) will be utilised. The car will also not always be in use because demand will never be that smooth, so the in-demand times have to be priced higher to make up for the quiet times. Then there has to be a higher insurance cost, plus a margin to cater for damage to the cab, booking systems, marketing, etc etc.
It's not that hard to see where a cost goes from the 50c/mile to the ~$4/mile which isn't far under the taxi cost.
Taxi drivers make just over minimum wage in most places. While the taxi (plate) owner does make a decent return if run well, it's not like there are a pile of taxi billionaires around. I'm just not convinced removing the driver is going to change the cost by an order of magnitude.
And the dead miles problem is not a big factor in places like Manhattan where utilization of taxis is high. If this system were pervasive, you could simply maintain a car or two per block.
The biggest issue would be dealing with the peak demand. Fortunately, heavy rail is complementary here, and it's only marginally less convenient when you have quick on-demand service to and from the train station. Demand-based taxi pricing would sort things out.
If you're sharing a car, you're paying a smaller share of the capital costs. Most people don't do that today because it's inconvenient. If cars drove themselves, it'd be convenient.
It's called Zipcar or your local equivalent.
Neither will any robotaxi or robocar system initially. I suppose some will view being run by nerds as an improvement over being run by hipsters.
The fact is that in a modern economy many things are shipped from business to business and from business to individuals. Laziness has nothing to do with it. Everything thats available in local businesses also has to come from somewhere.
Many things must go through many hands before they become available across the street. There's no reason a human being has to chauffeur things from place to place.
Think about it, you need to leave for work at a certain time? Just jump on Google Taxi (I use Google as they're the only company that has working driverless cars that I'm aware of at the moment), log-in using your account (that you either pay per ride, weekly, monthly, yearly, yearly+ etc.), calculate your commute, and reserve a car to show up at your house at that time and place. It takes you to your destination then shoots off to an electric or hydrogen-based fleet of these cars standing by at charging facilities in neighborhoods and cities all over the world. If they became ubiquitous enough you could have as little as a five to fifteen minute wait for a car.
However, I think the auto industry would fight like hell to keep this kind of system off the roads as it would severely dent auto sales. I mean hell, I know I wouldn't want a car if I could just have a subscription to a car. Especially if it wasn't just like Sedans. Imagine being able to rent a truck immediately at a moment's notice, then ride back home in a Sedan, all without having to worry about driving anywhere?
That's a world I would like to live in. Then once populations reached the 5,000+ ppl/km2 we could start building mag lev rails and get more into that kind of public transportation.