News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by KennyBlanken on Thursday October 06, 2022 @06:46AM (#33106682)
...because one of the letters against Stallman stopped accepting signatures at three thousand people, but the "pro" Stallman letter never did. It included sixty open-source organizations were among those three thousand individuals. SUSE, Mozilla, GNOME, Creative Commons, X.org, etc. The point was made. A huge number of people and organizations wanted Stallman gone.

Stallman literally said a sex-trafficked child wasn't a "rape victim", and this isn't the first time he's espoused, on technical mailing lists, that golly, 'age is just a number' when it comes to children having sex with adults. He's an infamous serial sexual harasser - for decades. Threatening to kill himself if women won't date him, hosting barely-clothed "cuddle puddles" on the bare mattress in his office at MIT, and women in his office building stuffing their offices full of house plants because Stallman was known to hate them, and it was the only thing that would make him leave women alone.

When Redhat and others pulled funding, the board was clear they weren't interested in prudent governance of the organization, but solely about petulantly supporting their geek deity. His refusal to step down, and the board's refusal to remove him, irreparably harmed their reputation and finances.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by daptaq on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:00AM (#33106748)
> ...because one of the letters against Stallman stopped accepting signatures at three thousand people, but the "pro" Stallman letter never did.

It was always a hunch, but I suspected that part of the reason they stopped is that they reached a plateau, while the open letter was continuing to rise in popularity.

https://linuxreviews.org/Grass-roots_Richard_Stallman_Suppor...

Regarding the other accusations, my understanding is that they are unfounded or intentional misrepresentations

https://stallmansupport.org/debunking-false-accusations-agai...

I have personally communicated with RMS, even privately, and see a discrepancy between the way he is portrayed and the way he behaves on a regular basis. Of course, I might have just caught his good and kind side, who knows? Either way, my impression remains that those who see him as bad want to see him as bad.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by teddyh on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:00AM (#33107121)
> Regarding the other accusations, my understanding is that they are unfounded or intentional misrepresentations

> https://stallmansupport.org/debunking-false-accusations-agai...

Yes; also here: https://sterling-archermedes.github.io/

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by hutzlibu on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:14AM (#33106818)
"I have personally communicated with RMS, even privately, and see a discrepancy between the way he is portrayed and the way he behaves on a regular basis."

But I suppose you are also male, right?

Well, this would then be equivalent to a TV show in germany some time ago, where 4 white persons all declared, that they don't perceive racism as a problem anymore. Good for them.

And I also never had a problem with racism, but I happen to be white, too. But my partner with a darker skin color can tell a different story.

So when the accusations against RMS are mainly sexism - which are grave, when he is supposed to be a public figure for the free software movement - then it does not tell much, when you personally get along with him well (under the assumption that you are male).

So as far as I know, there are indeed women who do not have a problem with RMS personally - but quite some apparently have. And in my opinion this is a problem and I see it even a bigger problem, that so many in the scene do not see a problem with it.

There is a reason, why the free software movement is largely dominated by men. And I would like more women in tech and not as sex objects.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by raxxorraxor on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:20AM (#33107306)
> I happen to be white, too

Nobody would have guessed, also that you are male too. I really do believe that you have a problem with racism and sexism, but it won't be solved by accusing others.

> So as far as I know [...] quite some apparently have

You should not regurgitate these rumors without further evidence. I can imagine someone like Stallmann being awkward with women and maybe some of the accusations are true. That is certainly no reason to prosecute him like this. Not your job to do so, work on yourself instead. There is enough to do here and then you can lead by example.

> There is a reason, why the free software movement is largely dominated by men

Certainly not a fault of Stallman. Some women also do not like men trying to make their mark everywhere and these easy accusations of sexism or discrimination feel a bit like that. Pretty sure you won't find the "fault" for that in others.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by daptaq on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:30AM (#33106918)
I am male, and I do get what you mean, which is why I wrote "Of course, I might have just caught his good and kind side, who knows?". As a person living in Germany, with a non-German accent, I also understand that not everyone perceives everything. Any person who feels excluded from participating in the Free Software movement is a loss. The more people with more perspectives, the stronger the movement is, which is in everyone's interest.

That being said: I do agree that some of the statements made in the past were tasteless, and I am disappointed that he did so. Yet when reading his own texts like https://stallman.org/articles/necessary-changes.html, I have to either conclude that he agrees but has made mistakes or is himself lying.

Another thing might be that I have only had contact with him via Email. Perhaps he is different in person, that I cannot say.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by sgc on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:34AM (#33107456)
I often remind people that you are only ever duped by those you trust. I have no idea how you could think email exchanges with someone would lend credence one way or another in respect to this type of accusation. It is well-known that even serial murderers are often charming and everyone is surprised when they are caught. How kind, cordial, or charming someone is means nothing in this type of situation.
Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by daptaq on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:04AM (#33107704)
OK, but just because a serial murdered can be charming, doesn't mean that every charming person in a serial murderer. It is true, I can't deduce anything with certainty from my personal and public correspondence, or the messages I see him send to others. But as opposed to the serial murderer, the issue here is the way he communicates and behaves.

I guess you could try this out empirically, by creating a throwaway Email address and sending him a dry, technical question under a female name, and see how he responds.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by sgc on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:30AM (#33107933)
That would be anecdotal, and after the fact when he is trying to be on his best behavior. Also, email and online communication in general is not a good way to judge somebody. for better and worse, People read non-existent tone into things I write endlessly, and you have to just stop caring about the disconnect it is so bad.

To be clear, I have no idea as to the truth of this situation, I am just saying the criteria to judge it must be different than that, especially because creeps do their best to hide their creepiness to the general world.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by DocTomoe on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:51AM (#33107593)
> Any person who feels excluded from participating in the Free Software movement is a loss.

Yes, but not every loss is equal, and in a changing world, growing groups will eventually reach a point where not everyone who wants to play will agree on the same ethics, which will lead to someone feeling unappreciated.

If I had the choice between losing a F/L/OSS contributor who has spend their life writing highly influential software and a F/L/OSS contributor who opened a 200-line-Python script once, half a year ago, I know who I would consider less of a loss.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by daptaq on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:07AM (#33107734)
I want to believe that this is not a necessary conflict, or rather is at best one that can be resolved. The choice still remains difficult, as you don't know the future, so it is preferable to have both on board.
Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by blueflow on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:54AM (#33107062)
Yes, RMS is a problematic person, but i'd prefer him over people who slander their opponents in public. I'm open to replacing RMS, but.. not like that.

Toning down would have helped your cause.

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by mistrial9 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:45AM (#33108070)
the supply of perfect people as candidates for leadership and invention is currently constrained;

the sinless one among you, throw the first stone

Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by antonvs on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:25PM (#33112031)
Is anything he wrote not factual?
Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by blueflow on Friday October 07, 2022 @05:08AM (#33118989)
Yes, pejoratives, which he has several sprinkled in, are a judgement and not factual.
Re:Debian Votes to Include Proprietary Firmware, Amends Soci... by fluoridation on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:44AM (#33108063)
>When Redhat and others pulled funding, the board was clear they weren't interested in prudent governance of the organization, but solely about petulantly supporting their geek deity. His refusal to step down, and the board's refusal to remove him, irreparably harmed their reputation and finances.

Alternatively, they decided they weren't going to be strong-armed into doing something that they saw no need to do.