In all my life this was never really something I considered important, but the whole pandemic thing gave an entirely new definition to ‘basic education’.
‘I learned all this stuff in high school, why do I have to explain these basic concepts?!’ Was a very common thought.
Indeed. I remember talking to a doctor who worked in the ER when the first wave of COVID (brutal in my country) was brewing. She said that it wouldn't be a big deal, they had like 50% of beds vacant (or something like that) so they would be able to handle it just fine. I said that by looking at the data, I thought they would run out of beds next week. Her expression was dismissive, like "this guy doesn't work in healthcare, hasn't set foot in an ER, what does he know?"
The next week, ERs were overloaded, of course. It was in plain sight from the straight line in log-scale graphs. But for most people (including most doctors) the interpretation was (and still is) "wow, this virus is rough, it comes in sudden waves out of nowhere!". Just because they don't understand exponential growth.
Whether they apply it to the real world is another thing.
I know people that don't think raising the minimum wage basically just causes inflation. They're just wondering why apartments in undesirable areas became 3x more expensive when minimum wage went from $5 to $15.
It probably varies a lot by country, like many things.
The ability to apply learned theory to real life in cross-domain ways is not common and not so easily taught by rote. Teaching calculus to everyone won't solve this.
That's a pretty poor example though as there are many factors that contribute to property prices and there isn't just a mechanical link between wages and house prices.
'Knowing' it but not applying it (and in what is literally a textbook circumstance, no less) is itself a failure of understanding.
School is a place where we indoctrinate all sorts of ideas into students, maybe we could spend a little more time highlighting financial decisions since it is so core to quality of life?
I am willing to bet that most educated people who walk around with gross misapprehensions of rates of change and exponential growth phenomena, have in fact drilled the computations just as well as anyone else.
That's what I know having understood calculus to those who have bits and pieces of the concepts (exponential growth included) but don't have a big picture. If you have the time and ability to learn more, why limit yourself? Why allow yourself to be put at a disadvantage? And worse (not saying you are, it's hard to gauge from your comment) why would you be in favor of stiffing other people from being better?
Even the exponential growth through calculus example is obsessively nitpicky: just draw a few graphs of y=x, y=2x, y=x*x and y=2^X. Most people will grasp the idea, and it's 30 minutes at most.
I think we experienced very different pandemics. I could pick 100 people off the street and I guarantee you 9/10s of them aren't able to do a logarithmic change of base. If you can't do that can you say you grasp exponential growth?
So what is that advantage for everyday people? I see some people are making it a "citizenship requirement" but except for exponent, which is not a part of calculus anyway (OP original point), there seems to be little advantage to it.
And that then leads me to my point above: if your knowledge is shallow, to the point that it limits you, then why clamor to limit yourself or further to limit others?
But we also have national exams for entrance into Uni and no "general ed" requirement because we're expected to have met that minimum requirement in highschool
Compound interest was understood earlier, too, of course. Thousands of years ago, in fact. But not with as clear and simple notation. It was often made illegal.
Symbolic mathematical notation was the breakthrough that most greatly increased the rate of mathematical breakthroughs thereafter.
> > Real understanding of exponential growth helps you understand viscerally why, for instance, you should nip a viral outbreak in the bud, and reducing the spreadrate even slightly (R0) can make a huge impact later on, even if spread isn't totally stopped. This is all just gibberish if not learned in high school.
I think programming/algorithm analysis and things like discrete simulations will give you a more durable notion of basic exponential growth for things like virus outbreaks than high-school calculus which is going to focus on things the derivative of the exponential function being similar to the function and stuff about Euler's number.
Don't think algebra or exponential growth matter? I think these concepts are critical to basic citizenship. Real understanding of exponential growth helps you understand viscerally why, for instance, you should nip a viral outbreak in the bud, and reducing the spreadrate even slightly (R0) can make a huge impact later on, even if spread isn't totally stopped. This is all just gibberish if not learned in high school.
Algebra is used in programming and is basically an introduction to many different programming concepts. Symbolic manipulation of variables, etc, needs to be understood at a basic level to competently program anything, or even use Excel spreadsheets effectively (which almost everyone who ever works a desk job--which is most people--will eventually come in contact with), which is a type of programming.
If you learned 3 semesters of calculus, then you must have learned this in college. If your job is programming-related, then it's pretty relevant for you to understand concepts in calculus like limits, rates of change, total area under a curve, plus having a confident grasp of algebra (which is much of the actual work of calculus).
Blue collar jobs like machinists, homebuilder/carpentry, plumbing, electrician, etc have tons of need for other areas of math that utilize concepts in algebra, pre-calculus, and geometry. As things become more automated, mechatronics and g-code programming are starting to become more relevant in a lot of trades that were previously highly manual. Tuning a PID loop is a fairly normal task for some of these. And you definitely benefit from pre-calc and calculus for things like this, being literally what the I and D stand for.