News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by erklik on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:02AM (#33063947)
I've commented this before in a different thread. It's time we, developers, truly switched to non-Chromium browsers. It's Firefox. The answer to all this is Firefox.

Firefox is a legitimate alternative, it works for >99% of the world's websites and is an actual alternative i.e. not a fork of Chromium. We need to support Firefox. I've been using it for nearly the last 5 years full-time and have never needed to open Chrome.

Do some Google websites perform worse on Firefox? Sure, but the entire reason that's because people don't use Firefox enough i.e. some websites are worse on Firefox. It's a cycle. People don't use Firefox enough, which is why some websites are not performant on Firefox and so on.

Firefox expanded and became famous because of a large amount of developers telling their families and friends that it's the better browser. Same was the case for Chrome. This needs to happen again.

As a side note, can someone at Mozilla please make it so that I can donate directly to Firefox? Is that not possible for some reason? If I knew that Mozilla wasn't going to spend my money on some stupid new idea, and it would directly to supporting Firefox development, I would defintely pay a subscription each month to Firefox, and feel like a lot of other people would too.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by sofixa on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:27AM (#33064113)
> As a side note, can someone at Mozilla please make it so that I can donate directly to Firefox? Is that not possible for some reason? If I knew that Mozilla wasn't going to spend my money on some stupid new idea, and it would directly to supporting Firefox development, I would defintely pay a subscription each month to Firefox, and feel like a lot of other people would too.

I don't see why so many people are against Mozilla using donations how they see fit. They need to diversify because relying on a single project, a free browser, in a single market segment which is saturated with free browsers, is a massive risk. Firefox's survival mostly hinges on Google's money, which of course Google have a massive interest in (they need a competitor to Chromium). However if that were to change, Firefox is going to struggle even more to keep up.

So, in my opinion, Mozilla need to diversify with alternative projects that could bring in money and reputation, and maybe even through integrations users for their other projects. To be able to do that, they need flexibility on how to spend the donations. To see what could happen if there are strict limits on what funds can be used for, check out Atlanta's MARTA system. They have to split incoming funds evenly between operational and capital expenditures budgets, which results in bullshit like them having the money for shiny new trains but not enough for basic repairs. Mozilla probably don't want to find themselves with tons of money for Firefox, but not enough to keep the lights on in general (legal, office, C-suite, other projects).

So I see where you're coming from, but it's just unrealistic.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by animuchan on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:55AM (#33064297)
I agree in principle, but they tend to diversify into alternative projects that leave bad taste in one's mouth.

Rust being the notable exception of course. Rust is probably what Mozilla will be remembered for when Google pulls the financial support for Firefox.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by sofixa on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:20AM (#33064820)
It's funny you chose Rust, because at face value, ignoring how useful the language is, creating a programming language from scratch for a browser seems a bit overkill and a waste of money/focus.

So you should either trust Mozilla the organisation to spend funds wisely, or not. Forcing them to spend only on Firefox can still result in "waste" from a purist perspective (like a programming language) while at the same time massively constraining them.

And i quite like some of Mozilla's alternative projects. Pocket is cool and genuinely useful. Thunderbird could use some love but is pretty decent.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by animuchan on Thursday October 06, 2022 @03:30AM (#33105498)
Pocket may be cool, but the way they forced it down everyone's collective throat was... bad.

They later bought the company, so now it's a kind-of-Mozilla product inside another Mozilla product, which doesn't sound nearly as egregious as it was at launch: a forced third-party browser extension that couldn't be meaningfully disabled.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by TuringTest on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:33PM (#33069847)
> It's funny you chose Rust, because at face value, ignoring how useful the language is, creating a programming language from scratch for a browser seems a bit overkill and a waste of money/focus.

Rust was the right technical approach for this browser, given the existing technology and the problems they had to solve to update the rendering engine.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by sofixa on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:41PM (#33073407)
It ended up being the right choice, but it's classic yak shaving.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by sprash on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:40AM (#33064195)
> I don't see why so many people are against Mozilla using donations how they see fit.

Because people donating to Mozilla are expecting that those funds are used for the browser and not a string of experiments that fail miserably. People rightfully feel betrayed and stop donating.

> Mozilla need to diversify

Exactly wrong. Mozilla needs to concentrate on the Browser and should cut off all excess expenses and useless experiments. The goal should be to minimize cost and thus reduce the reliance on Google money which should be replaced by pure donation money.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by creesch on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:21AM (#33065557)
> I don't see why so many people are against Mozilla using donations how they see fit. They need to diversify because relying on a single project, a free browser, in a single market segment which is saturated with free browsers, is a massive risk.

It is entirely possible to implement a donation model that does work towards both. Simply allow users to determine what percentage of their donations goes to Firefox but set the max percentage to something like 90%.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by cyber_kinetist on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:18AM (#33064046)
Until Mozilla actually directs its funds in improving the engineering of the browser itself instead of spending it on executives and managers, I'm not going to support them in any financial way.

Relevant link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24563698

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by dymk on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:44AM (#33064218)
The perfect being the enemy of the good, yet again.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by cyber_kinetist on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:51AM (#33064275)
I'm speaking this in a pragmatic rather than idealistic terms. Donations have no use when it doesn't go to developing the browser itself (which, to be honest is the most urgent issue right now. Users are having all sorts of performance and instability issues in major websites and switching to Chrome instead.)
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by LunicLynx on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:02AM (#33064351)
This is not an argument. How do you know that developers of other companies are better compensated? (The money distribution follows your ideals)

Let’s talk about the product.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by hn_go_brrrrr on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:24AM (#33064473)
Sure, let's talk about FF Android removing extension support and only adding it back in a very limited way.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by kd913 on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:02AM (#33066256)
Compared with the alternatives which don't support extensions at all? What is your point?

They did it for technical reasons, and one of the first extensions to be supported was ublock origin.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by hn_go_brrrrr on Monday October 03, 2022 @07:59PM (#33075218)
The alternative was to keep going with the previous version of the app, which even supported installing extensions directly from an xpi. It's nice that they support an adblocker or two, but I need much more out of my browser than that.

"Technical reasons" doesn't really cut it. There are frequently technical reasons involved in making a bad decision. That's not a justification.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by beebeepka on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:59AM (#33064327)
Donating money to millionaires won't fix the problem. Take a look who's been running the show. She's paid to make things worse. Pouring money into her lifestyle won't make FF better

Edit: FFS, guys. I am not against donations to mozilla. I am against sponsoring this person.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by smegsicle on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:49AM (#33064264)
fire mitchell baker

if his family can't accept "80% discount to market" then maybe he'll have better luck heading a corporation that he didn't oversee running itself into the ground

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by beebeepka on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:56AM (#33064306)
It's a woman. One that ought to be fired, out of a canon, into the sun.

She's actively sabotaging the whole thing

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by 2Gkashmiri on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:24AM (#33064474)
i concur. bring out your pitckforks, i am sharpening mine
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Caspy7 on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:51AM (#33064274)
*she
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Fiahil on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:01AM (#33064346)
> it works for >99% of the world's websites

From what I can see, it works with 100% of the world's websites.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by b0afc375b5 on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:24AM (#33064476)
I didn't get stackblitz to work. Or is it perhaps my myriad of extensions preventing it to work?
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Fiahil on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:55AM (#33065783)
It works for me
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by b0afc375b5 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:46AM (#33079040)
Thanks for letting me know. I tried with Private Window but it's giving me "Enable Third-Party Cookies". I'll have to test on a Normal Window with plugins disabled.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by scrame on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:38AM (#33064558)
Tree-style-tabs alone make firefox preferable. though their stupid mobile extension change dampened the ease to recommend it for mobile. (yes, I use nightly, and have a custom package, it's a garbage experience)
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by erklik on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:08AM (#33065470)
Oh god. I love that you said this. Absolutely. I have 3000 tabs open (exageratting but can't be too far off) and Tree Style Tabs saves my life. Along with Tridactyl, using the browser feels far more "powerful" than Chrome ever did to me.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by dataflow on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:59AM (#33064333)
I tried downloading Firefox on my phone and was greeted with... the inability to even set my home page to a URL of my choice? [1] I couldn't believe my eyes. Do they think this kind of thing will increase their market share?

[1] https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/fenix/issues/7551

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by pessimizer on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:01AM (#33066246)
Yup. It's another piece of software that hates its users. Another company where people are having meetings discussing the best methods to prevent their software's users from doing something with their own computers. Protecting users from their own preferences. Antiuser interfaces.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by TuringTest on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:05AM (#33064365)
What are you talking about? You can set several URL links in the home page, the feature is called 'shortcuts'.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by genezeta on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:22AM (#33064462)
Different thing.

They are asking to set [some URL] as the homepage, that is, the equivalent of this setting -available on desktop Fx- https://imgur.com/a/flHTSNe

This makes it so that when you open Firefox initially or when you open a new tab, it loads the chosen URL instead of loading the about:newtab (the page where the shortcuts you mention can be found).

This setting was available in some -old, Fennec- versions but not currently.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by jhanschoo on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:18AM (#33064432)
They mean that when they open a new tab it should immediately load a certain web page.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by TuringTest on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:29PM (#33069768)
Well, that's called a shortcut. You can have that feature by opening a shortcut instead of a tab.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by bambax on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:56AM (#33064679)
Agree 100%. I would also pay for a browser that doesn't implement manifest v3 at all. If FF won't offer a paid version for some reason, why don't other people fork it and do it?
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by aembleton on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:44AM (#33065304)
I've opened Chromium to check websites I'm working on are rendering correctly. Its worth doing as most of your users use a Chrome based browser.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by badrabbit on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:06AM (#33064372)
In the corporate world, firefox doesn't fare well.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by wildrhythms on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:12AM (#33065502)
This + any institutions with a fleet of Chromebooks don't even have the option of using Firefox.
[dead]
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by dsco on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:27AM (#33064110)
Where do you get the information that most web devs aren’t aware of Firefox?
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by random_cynic on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:34AM (#33064157)
From the fact that there are so many government, university and bank websites that simply doesn't work with Firefox or anything other than non-chromium based. In fact, many explicitly say that the user needs to use Chrome for the best experience. You can of course ignore and say that these don't happen in your reality but you only need to take a look at Firefox forums or issues/bug threads to know that they are very real.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by malermeister on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:45AM (#33064227)
I've never driven a Tesla. Doesn't mean I'm unaware of their existence or the roads I build have to be incompatible with them.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by pritambaral on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:53AM (#33064284)
Apples to oranges. Roads are nowhere near as complex as Web APIs.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by malermeister on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:54AM (#33064294)
How about bridges, then?
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by pritambaral on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:06PM (#33086898)
I see your dedication to this topic. While I commend you on it, I don't think you're ready to have a fair discussion on it. This is a topic that, unlike Civil Engineering, has way too much complexity and nuance. We don't like it, and we all wish it were better organised and standardised and simpler and just ... generally not so fraught with frustration. But it is what it is, and it's not like you and I can settle this debate with pithy comparisons to random subfields of Civil Engineering.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Ygg2 on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:11AM (#33064391)
Outside of nuclear rocket assisted brain surgery, nothing really compare to browser complexity.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by malermeister on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:17AM (#33064802)
... and this is why people think of tech folks as arrogant.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by pritambaral on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:15PM (#33087029)
Think of it however you'd like to. You're entitled to your opinion. But we're not saying these things from a place of arrogance.

I'm not claiming we're better that civil engineers, or that our job is harder. Maybe you're reading it that way, but I'm trying to assert that such a comparison cannot be made. It's neither easier nor harder, and it's both. The two endeavours are just not comparable.

Civil engineers work with real, physical, tangible things. Hardware, so to speak. We work with ... software. Soft. Ware. The modes are entirely different, and thus the universe of challenges. I wouldn't compare painting to songwriting, even if they're both art.

But if you go up to a painter and talk to them exclusively using songwriting analogies and when they tell you that doesn't make sense and you plug your fingers into your ears and yell "Arrogant!" in their face ... well, you're entitled to you opinions and apples are still not the same things as oranges.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Ygg2 on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:56AM (#33065006)
Does doing rocket assisted brain surgery sounds arrogant? It's a cry for help.

Software is infinitely more complex to civil engineering (this isn't a good thing). Because it can literally do almost anything.

In civil engineering you have a bridge from point A to point B over a river. Points are on such and such soil. It needs to support X amount of traffic and gets inspection/repair every Y days.

In software you have a bridge, but we also need it to launch a space shuttle, and it needs to work as an air ship. It goes from point A to point B but soil is periodically changed (sometimes it's diamond and sometimes gravel or marshmallow). Oh and river can sometimes turn to molten metal or solid oxygen.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by LunicLynx on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:56AM (#33064311)
I have yet to see such a website. Please provide sources. Thanks
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by random_cynic on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:59AM (#33065023)
Please read again. Thanks
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by p-e-w on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:28AM (#33064122)
> Most modern web developers probably aren't even aware that Firefox exists

Wat?

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by osrec on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:14AM (#33064022)
I would happily use Firefox, however it lacks good developer tools - it's almost impossible to identify JS memory leaks using the FF dev tools.

I also find FF more resource hungry than Chrome (and Chrome is pretty heavy on resources too).

If they start by making the dev tools better than Chrome's, I know I'd switch, or at least start running it in parallel.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by exyi on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:35AM (#33064164)
Then use Chrome only when you are looking for memory leaks. FF's devtools are not worse than Chrome, I'm used to Firefox and I find Chrome devtools hard to use. For example, the CPU profiler is much better, IMHO
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by mastazi on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:42AM (#33064580)
I also prefer FF dev tools, even while FF was not my daily driver, I was still using its dev tools. I hate Chrome dev tools with that giant console window that takes up half of the space (even when you are not in the console tab) and even if you choose to close it, every now and then it will come back because somehow Chrome forgot your setting.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by wildrhythms on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:16AM (#33065521)
Yes, I hate this. It's also mapped to open on Esc when the devtools are focused, so if you're trying to get out of some context habitually with the Esc key it will open then too. That and the What's New tab drive me insane (you can disable What's New for a given profile, but my job involves running dev tools in incognito and guest profiles where it's always enabled).
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by preya2k on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:36AM (#33064538)
Give them a chance. I was under the same impression until a couple of years ago. Now I think Firefox Developer Tools are far superior. But I can only speak for the Inspector/DOM/CSS related stuff. These are just great!
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by osrec on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:50AM (#33064640)
I'll give them another try. I was just frustrated when I used them last.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by avian on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:10AM (#33063993)
Firefox will follow Chrome with this. Over time they always tend to copy Chrome instead of going their own way, as much as their users complain. They similarly already moved away from XUL extensions in the past. I'm sure they will write a heart-breaking story about how supporting Manifest v3 extensions and removing WebRequest blocking is critical for safety and privacy on the web.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by kramerger on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:15AM (#33064025)
Firefox is already supporting v3 while _also_ supporting v2 for adblockers.

Stop these random excuses.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by avian on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:21AM (#33064064)
I use Firefox exclusively, on my computer and on my phone. I am also incresingly frustrated by the direction Mozilla has been going with it and have very little illusions left what their motivations are.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by p-e-w on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:21AM (#33064063)
> Firefox is a legitimate alternative, it works for >99% of the world's websites

Which is useless if your bank shows you an empty page with a message that says they only support Chrome and Edge "for security reasons".

And Mozilla had many, many, many chances to endear themselves to developers. Their actions can best be summarized as they don't give a damn. It took them years to ship basic dev tools with Firefox. Then they wiped out an extension ecosystem that had been growing for more than a decade with the justification that they needed to get rid of technical debt. Meanwhile, Firefox still contains bloatware like Pocket. As for the privacy argument, Mozilla's track record on privacy is mixed at best, considering the many questionable choices they made in this regard in the past.

"The answer to all this" is not Firefox. Not the Firefox made by the Mozilla of 2022, anyway. If the Mozilla of 2004 could somehow be resurrected, perhaps they could turn Firefox into something that would indeed be "the answer to all this". At that point, developers wouldn't need encouragement to switch to Firefox. They'd do so simply because it would obviously be the better browser for them.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by nightski on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:22AM (#33064076)
Wow that's crazy, I've used quite a few bank websites and never had that happen. Been using Firefox as a daily driver since it first released. I think that would make me question my bank more than my browser.
[dead]
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by smegsicle on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:41AM (#33064201)
remember the hacker news guidelines:

> Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by p-e-w on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:27AM (#33064115)
Not just banks, I believe certain government websites in some countries do it as well. /r/Firefox has hundreds of posts showing websites misbehaving in this way.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by yoasif_ on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:46AM (#33064240)
Not really. Source - I am a r/firefox moderator.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by LunicLynx on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:54AM (#33064295)
Please provide sources. Which pages + statements
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Ygg2 on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:17AM (#33064425)
> Then they wiped out an extension ecosystem that had been growing for more than a decade with the justification that they needed to get rid of technical debt.

Do you have any proof that wasn't the case? From what I saw, XUL was invented to define UIs in XML but over time HTML became better than it for defining UIs.

And the great freedom XUL allowed made some optimizations impossible.

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by johnny22 on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:41AM (#33064573)
it wasn't xul that was the problem, but xpcom
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by Ygg2 on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:55AM (#33064674)
Any more details? I definitely get impression killing old addons wasn't just change for change's sake, but I don't know the details behind it?
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by marcthe12 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:01AM (#33065033)
Basically xpcom and XUL can be treated in same way as gnome-shell.

XPCOM was a object model from the 90s and had several legacy issues. On top of that was XUL and XBL were obselete by improvements to web api and was badly mainatined. Like Gnome-shell, xul extentsion were monkey patching firefox internals. So firefox was limited on certain security and performance improvement. By removing old addons, firefox could start replacing the mess of the old subsystems. XBL was removed for example and xul I think still exist but a fraction of the former self. I don't think the can remove xpcom until they can port a 50% of firefox to rust though

Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by dblohm7 on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:00PM (#33074306)
Removing XPCOM is orthogonal to adding rust. In fact, if you search Bugzilla you fill find many references to deCOMtamination, which is about removing unnecessary XPCOM.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by dblohm7 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:59PM (#33074297)
Former Firefox developer: It was both.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by MrPatan on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:48AM (#33064966)
You can use FF for everything except your bank.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by bearmode on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:15AM (#33064790)
You might want to switch banks to one that shows even an ounce of technical understanding.
Re:Feel the power of the Manifest v3 by LunicLynx on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:54AM (#33064290)
Which bank?