News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @06:30PM (#330531)
I personally can't fathom why someone would feel the need to start networking before a working product exists.

CEO? Why would you need a CEO when there isn't a company to run either on paper or in actuality?

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by sebastian on Sunday October 12, 2008 @07:03PM (#330551)
I second this opinion. The last position a tech startup needs to worry about filling is a CEO, CMO, etc.

A CEO twittering all day long, hanging out / socializing / spending money at conferences and meetups is NOT going to bring ANY value to the startup at all.

You first need a product!

Once you have a product out of the door, a proven idea and a cash flow you can start worrying about filling up those hi-procrastination roles. Until then worry about finding people who can code, can design, can hack, can do anything that has a measurable outcome.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by alain94040 on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:01PM (#331149)
As much as I wish you were correct, reality says otherwise.

When I was 100% a geek, I would agree with you: the product (code) is everything, who cares about those other minor business annoyances?

Reality: how programmers does it take to implement a good product that people will buy? More than you can afford. How do you afford them? Raise money. Which for you may mean "pitch to dumb rich people", but that's still a CEO's job.

At any time in the project development, a good pitch to the right business partner can turn the company around and greatly improve its prospects. Yes, if you don't do any of those "CEO" things, you may still succeed because you push through an amazing product. But why take the chance? Try to do everything well, the product development, as well as the CEO/pitching part.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mhartl on Sunday October 12, 2008 @06:57PM (#330547)
The best time to build a network is before you need it.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @07:50PM (#330568)
I don't think a network is very crucial to a startup's survival.

I think the value of the technology is.

IMO, where value exists, everything naturally follows, including people/companies that want to network with value.

I found the story to be rather depressing, yet there were a few points that were - to me anyway - glaringly obvious.

Someone focusing on suit type endeavors when that someone is an engineer/geek/hacker/techie/[insert name for us here] is irresponsible in that it amounts to a gross misallocation of resources.

In other words, any double digit IQ'er wearing a suit can network, but not everyone can design and code and troubleshoot, which is what creates value.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:53PM (#330621)
I agree with your point in the very early stages of a company

Networking for the purpose of getting to know people can be useful, but during the early stages of a startup if you are out talking to people your goal should be to understand your target market better. Otherwise, don't worry about networking instead of coding until you need to raise money.

I completely disagree with this point...

"Someone focusing on suit type endeavors when that someone is an engineer/geek/hacker/techie/[insert name for us here] is irresponsible in that it amounts to a gross misallocation of resources."

What do you plan to do if that person doesn't exist? Wait to sell your product until you can hire one? Get another co-founder to go out and raise money? PG talks about Sam Altman pitching phone execs the early days of Loopt to great success, and his background was CS not sales.

"any double digit IQ'er wearing a suit can network, but not everyone can design and code and troubleshoot, which is what creates value."

There are two fallacies here.

First, the fallacy that everyone can network equally well. Some people are incredible at networking, they can network so well that they are a valuable asset to a company for that reason alone. (See Keith Ferazzi) Everyone can "network" but only certain people can make their network pay very well.

Second, that only coding creates value. A great product still doesn't sell itself. What do you think Apple would be without brilliant marketing? You can have the best product in the world technically, but in terms of market value you have nothing if its not sold.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by kogir on Sunday October 12, 2008 @09:39PM (#330651)
"PG talks about Sam Altman pitching phone execs the early days of Loopt to great success, and his background was CS not sales."

Of note is that while pitching execs in the early days he was also doing at least 2x the development work of anyone else. He didn't stop coding until long after we had a fully functional demo application that was good enough to raise our series A.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:42PM (#330712)
If that person does not exist, then one needs to be hired eventually, as it would be better to wait than to have a person not adept at the task doing it wrong.

I am sure that some are better than others at networking, my point was (minus my admittedly harsh figurative description) that high intelligence and knowledge are best applied to something that mandates intelligence, as opposed to something that does not mandate a high level of intelligence and knowledge. Those kinds of activities (networking, sales, marketing) do not mandate exceptional intelligence, from what I have seen those mostly require innate skill and experience. Many people can network, sell, and market. Not many can code.

Now, I mentioned more than coding when I referred to what I believe creates value, however I will respond to your point by saying that 1) creating value is conducive to attracting attention IMO 2) I did not state that there should be no networking/marketing/promotion at all, I wrote that it should not be done before a product is ready, and that it should be done by someone adept at it (usually not a propeller head like me, for example, although I am sure some guys are skilled at those activities as well as tech work)

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Monday October 13, 2008 @01:38AM (#330804)
"Those kinds of activities (networking, sales, marketing) do not mandate exceptional intelligence, from what I have seen those mostly require innate skill and experience. Many people can network, sell, and market. Not many can code."

I still think this is arguable, you describe what separates star marketers from the rest is "innate skill" in this case innate marketing/sales/networking skill. However, I think I can equally make the case for star marketers. I'll discuss you're argument from the marketing perspective because its the area I'm most familiar with and feel most qualified to speak for.

Marketing isn't just a game of follow these rules and you will be successful, its not just a matter of experience either. If it were, marketing agencies wouldn't be differentiable and campaigns like Absolut wouldn't have cult-like status. Just as there is an so described "innate skill" for programmers I would argue that there is a similar type of "innate skill" that separates the best marketers from the rest. To say that intelligence on the same level as programming isn't mandated for marketing is demeaning to that profession as a whole and represents a misunderstanding of what really goes into a well defined marketing strategy. Admittedly, it may not be as quantitatively measured as programming, but that does not mean it requires less intelligence or is less demanding.

I do agree with your point that creating value is conducive to attracting attention, but by no means is it a limiting factor. There are plenty of historical examples where things of little to no value, when marketed well, rose to great success. (The pet rock, among other things)

I've done a fair amount of both programming and marketing, and while I don't claim to be a "star" at either, I still cringe when people dismiss one or the other categorically as being of little added value. It happens from both sides and most of the time just represents a lack of understanding of the efforts that go into either.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @04:12PM (#331468)
I referred to a combination of innate skill and experience, not one or the other.

I did not say that marketing was a follow the cookbook type endeavor either.

Problem with this point is that, neither one of us in this small debate has any hard data to back up or counter our respective points (does any exist? I personally doubt it) which are highly subjective anyway, mostly based on anecdotal perception.

I stick by my opinion however, and can point to the relative number of programmers versus marketing people in the global workforce as indicative of what I am saying . . . if more people were smart enough to program, as opposed to market, they would . . .

Marketing has its place, but to an admittedly occasionally arrogant geek such as myself (who has come across some incredibly, impossibly dumb marketing types) they are figuratively just the people who stand outside the shop on the sidewalk and try to get people to step inside and look at the wares . . .

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Monday October 13, 2008 @10:10PM (#331853)
"I stick by my opinion however, and can point to the relative number of programmers versus marketing people in the global workforce as indicative of what I am saying . . . if more people were smart enough to program, as opposed to market, they would . . ."

Can you further explain here? Market forces will determine where people go, salaries will rise until people move into those positions. The number of people in given positions is not indicative at all of the skill of the people taking those jobs.

"Marketing has its place, but to an admittedly occasionally arrogant geek such as myself (who has come across some incredibly, impossibly dumb marketing types) they are figuratively just the people who stand outside the shop on the sidewalk and try to get people to step inside and look at the wares . . ."

I agree with you that this is an extremely arrogant viewpoint. I've met many stupid programmers but I don't assume the same of all programmers. I also think you're confusing the roles of sales and marketing but that's beside the point.

Discounting the value of people who aren't like you isn't a very great way to get anywhere in life, especially as an entrepreneur.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @10:32PM (#331867)
The numbers speak for themselves. That is obvious.

You are not reading what I write. I did not mention skill, I mentioned intelligence. Those are not the same.

It is quite simple. Look at all occupations. There are more non-intellectually demanding jobs than there are intellectually demanding jobs. There are more dumb people than smart people on the planet. That is obvious.

Speaking of market forces, why are programmers on average paid more than marketing and sales people?

You have met stupid programmers? Interesting. I agree that not all are extremely bright, however, anyone who is truly stupid will not be able to even learn how to program, much less become worthy of the title programmer, whereas, I have seen some nearly illiterate folks working in marketing, and sales, and I realize those two are different, even though I do not bother to differentiate between the two when making reference to them.

"Discounting the value of people who aren't like you isn't a very great way to get anywhere in life, especially as an entrepreneur."

Neat, now you are starting the personal attacks.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @12:25AM (#331928)
"You are not reading what I write. I did not mention skill, I mentioned intelligence. Those are not the same."

Innate skill and intelligence are pretty much the same thing. (Although I would argue that intelligence can grow as a function of effort).

"Speaking of market forces, why are programmers on average paid more than marketing and sales people?"

The pay of programmers vs. marketers is pretty comparable. Check salary.com

"Neat, now you are starting the personal attacks."

No, just responding to your multi-post personal attack against marketers/bizdev with one against arrogance. Its up to you whether to take it personally.

I have more points I could make, but this doesn't seem to be going anywhere useful so I'm done with this discussion.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:04AM (#331953)
Innate skill and intelligence are most definitely NOT, NOT pretty much the same thing. Check an English language dictionary.

salary.com? Please.

I wrote "on average".

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:00AM (#332021)
Ok, fine, lets be precise. First, innate skill is an oxymoron then because "skill" implies that it is learned (see dictionary) and "innate" implies it is not.

As far as "on average" goes, where do you think salary.com/payscale.com get their data, averages of real-world salaries.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @05:09AM (#332076)
>First, innate skill is an oxymoron then because "skill" implies that >it is learned

Wrong.

>(see dictionary)

Skill n. 2 a) an art, craft, or science, esp. one involving the use of the hands or body b) ABILITY IN SUCH AN ART, CRAFT, OR SCIENCE

ISBN 0-02-860586-1 pg. 1257

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:49PM (#332393)
hmmm, well they must have changed their minds then...

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skill%5B2%5D

1 obsolete : cause , reason

2 a: the ability to use one's knowledge effectively and readily in execution or performance b: dexterity or coordination especially in the execution of learned physical tasks

3: a learned power of doing something competently : a developed aptitude or ability <language skills>

(emphasis mine)

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:05PM (#332457)
Oh, I am sure they "changed their minds", when there is no mention of a definition being obsolete or deprecated.

Edit: Stalemate?

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:46PM (#332523)
sure, cheers
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @04:59PM (#332610)
cheers
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by SwellJoe on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:41PM (#330608)
IMO, where value exists, everything naturally follows, including people/companies that want to network with value.

This is overly optimistic about the capacity of your fellow man to recognize value. Sometimes you just have to tell them what the value is, and if you don't have a network, you have no one to tell. Sounds ridiculous to nerds like you and I, I know, but if you spend a little time in the corporate world you'll begin to see how much major purchase decisions are made based on what a trusted individual recommends. A lot of times the "trusted" individual is a vendor with a vested interest in selling something. This actually works better in the long run than you might think, because most people work in the same business for many years, and if one vendor screws them (while seeming very nice), they have time to learn and change to another vendor (probably also someone they've spoken to before).

But, I do think the OP does have some prioritization issues. It always comes back to the product. If you don't have a great product, you don't have a company worth networking for.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:14PM (#330699)
I see your points, and agree. You hit it on the head when you pointed out that it seems obvious to us nerds.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by konsl on Sunday October 12, 2008 @06:48PM (#330539)
Founders should always be networking.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by brianlash on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:14PM (#330600)
Eh... founders should always be talking with different, intelligent people and soaking up ideas. If that's what you mean by networking, fine. But I think the networking tptacek refers to is the type that's organized X times/mo. and for the purpose of professional development. It's those ad hoc events where this group is encouraged to co-mingle with this one.

It has its place, but just as useful at times is getting together with a group of peers you trust and exchanging notes. Having a few beers and talking about what challenges you're having, what breakthroughs you've made...

I think the tradtional idea of networking is overemphasized among a lot of startups (and sometimes dangerously so) because it's an abstraction away from the work that keeps them alive. You've got to make sure you keep a watchful eye on your schedule and don't confuse attending X and Y event for Z productivity.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by tptacek on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:56PM (#330721)
Agree, networking is over-emphasized. We did a lot of networking at the outset, with no particular plan or strategy, and it doesn't feel like time well spent.

Not sure I'm saying "my kind of networking meets X times per month", but I will say this: we organized monthly meetups for the professionals in our market (computer/network security), made it as all-inclusive as we could, and it's been far more valuable to us than the vanity networking we did early on.

Isn't this one of the major recurring criticisms of valley culture? That all those people do is go to parties with the same people every night?

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by brianlash on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:24AM (#330745)
Sorry, I was unclear. What I meant was (at least from waht I gathered from your post) that you're skeptical of vanity networking and that you favor less formal gatherings done in the spirit of meetups.

I'm with you on that.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by tptacek on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:38AM (#330751)
I thought you might have been, but I just wanted to plug the idea of organizing market-specific meetups to network with customers, prospective employees, and partners --- people who can actually help your business --- do this!

SXSW trips not so much.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by justin on Monday October 13, 2008 @08:35PM (#331765)
As someone who has gone through Y Combinator early on, I think networking was actually a bit under emphasized. A lot of networking can be useless if you don't follow up in depth; but our company has gained immeasurably by identifying people who have built and scaled businesses (technically and otherwise) and then got them to sit down for an hour or two and teach us about an area that we're weak on.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by tptacek on Monday October 13, 2008 @08:40PM (#331769)
I would love an example.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by orianmarx on Sunday October 12, 2008 @10:16PM (#330671)
I agree that "professional networking" is often a waste of time, but meeting other startups and potential users and sharing ideas has always been valuable to me. That's what I was trying to say by referring to "connecting" and not just "networking". Maybe there's a better word...
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by fallentimes on Monday October 13, 2008 @11:25AM (#331091)
Making friends.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by Prrometheus on Monday October 13, 2008 @04:12AM (#330877)
>Founders should always be networking.

I don't think Wozniak did much networking. I don't know what would have happened if Jobs got mad at him because he didn't.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by greendestiny on Sunday October 12, 2008 @07:46PM (#330565)
Yeah but would you have startup destroying conflicts over whether or not founders were bringing in investors and advisors before you had a product?

I'm not sure I'd question the commitment of people who were actively building the product either. It sounds like this startup really had some forward momentum with people getting stuff done. I'm not sure the authors expectations were reasonable, and I think he had to work fairly hard to kill this startup.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:02PM (#330579)
I think that courting investors and obtaining advisors is one thing, general networking is another, which is what I am referring to, and by general networking I mean building contacts/telling people about what you are doing/determining who can provide you with what.

I agree with the second part of your comment.

On the other hand, some folks take being pragmatic to an extreme, as in no order/uniformity/quality control/structure/thought into design/effort to identify possible future issues and a general just get whatever done in a hurry and push it out the door attitude . . . which is all just as bad as too much formally define roles/establish this and that and the other/talk about and plan stuff to death/posture around with this and that and the other . . .

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by greendestiny on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:11PM (#330595)
I agree with all of that. I mean the author may have been saved a lot of hassle further down the track with failing quickly, or he might have killed a good potential company - I really can't say even though I put forth an opinion on it.

If you have good people, some funding, a demo and the start of a code base then thats a lot to lose over your expectations on networking and days of the week devoted to the startup. Even if the truth is more networking and fulltime cofounders would have helped.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by orianmarx on Sunday October 12, 2008 @10:57PM (#330693)
You know, maybe I didn't make it clear enough that I thought we had a great thing going right up to the end. But what happened when we landed YC was that a lot of stuff came to the surface that hadn't been addressed well enough before, including a partner's belief that a lot of my effort up to that point had been worthless and he didn't trust me to do any better going forward. That was a pretty rough pill to swallow, especially after being responsible for most of the YC application, leading the three interviews we did to get accepted and building the front end for what we demoed.

I certainly may have killed the startup by emphasizing things that I thought were important, but it doesn't make any sense to think I was actively trying to kill it. My point was that I was blindsided by what happened in the end, so now I've gone back to think about how we got there and, you know, these are some of the conclusions I've drawn and of course they could still be wrong.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by greendestiny on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:24AM (#330744)
I got the impression you thought you had a good thing. I guess my key question would be this: Given everything the startup had going for it, do you think the conflict points (networking, time commitment, and a few others) were sufficiently important to stake the startup on?

On the one hand you could feel in retrospect that the conflict points were important enough that the startup could never have succeeding without the direction you were pushing - so you were lucky it ended swiftly. On the other hand if you think your startup had a good chance of success even if you hadn't won those battles, then you may want to look at your conflict resolution.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by orianmarx on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:41AM (#330754)
No, the conflict points that are being discussed here a lot were not sufficiently important to stake the startup on at the time when we were faced with having to walk away. The real point was that by the time we went to Boston to meet with PG and get some advice, my partner had decided he could no longer trust me or my judgment and wanted to leave, and I felt the same way about him. While I wish that could have been avoided, I don't think anything that could have been done at that point would have changed the ultimate outcome for this team.

After spending a few months thinking "okay, so how did it get to that point, and I didn't even realize it" I wrote my reflections. I still think the startup has a good chance of success, but not with the dynamics that were at play then.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by webwright on Monday October 13, 2008 @01:13AM (#330780)
Not always. There are times to put your head down and build (depending on team composition and what your business is doing, of course)

It totally depends on the product, but from the YC PoV, you have 3 months to build something that dazzles investors. Generally, YC discourages hunting for networking/bizdev/funding deals because you have EXACTLY ONE SHOT to impress a room full of the most important early stage investors on the planet.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by orianmarx on Thursday October 16, 2008 @02:28AM (#334199)
But YC also requires you to be in the same location as the other startups and to attend two dinners each week, plus it encourages visiting the YC partners during "office hours".
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by run4yourlives on Monday October 13, 2008 @05:06PM (#331539)
Founders shouldn't network in place of building.

You can always network after you've got a product, but if you can't do both at once, product comes first.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @07:39PM (#330560)
Personally, that strikes me as a bit too generic for a tech startup. The value of the startup stems from the value of the technology it produces, not the value of the network of contacts one of the founders has built. While networking can be valuable, allocating resources to networking BEFORE there is a working product is a huge mistake.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by incomethax on Sunday October 12, 2008 @09:23PM (#330642)
I can agree from personal experience. Premature networking can kill a startup.

Edit: What I mean by this is networking at the expense of product/technology building.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by orianmarx on Sunday October 12, 2008 @10:02PM (#330664)
Well, that really depends on what you define as value. There are plenty of tech companies out there that created tons of "valuable" code but were not successful because somebody else got the attention or was able to strike one critical deal.

As for allocating resources to networking before there is a working product, check out www.path101.com. I met these guys when they did an open brainstorming session with nothing but a preliminary pitch deck and not a line of code. Being open from very early on enabled them to find angel investors and their first employees, and when it came time to doing an alpha launch they had tons of people that had been eager to try the thing out for months.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:07PM (#330695)
I agree that vaporware has been successfully marketed before, however, that is not my idea of creating value, so I agree that it depends on how one defines value, and I would not want that - marketing non-existent products - to become the meaning of value within the context of a tech startup, that is best left to a marketing/publicity outfit if you ask me. I also think it is wrong to conduct market studies under the guise of a real product offer.

What happens when it turns out that the bullet points with features cannot be implemented, or are simply not the best solution for the users?

I find pg's thoughts on the subject of how problems may end up being redefined as they are being worked on to be very wise advice.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by tlrobinson on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:57PM (#330722)
See the last 1 minute of Tim Bray's FOWA talk: http://events.carsonified.com/fowa/2008/london/highlights/ti...
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Sunday October 12, 2008 @08:58PM (#330625)
There are some great companies built without a product. Often times you can fake sell before a product exists and give a refund to prove that a market exists before development. Otherwise all your product dev can be wasted.

I know successful (>10M revenue) companies who have mocked up a brochure and sold it this way. Their thought was "if they don't bring out a credit card right away you aren't solving a pain, you dont have a product".

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by abl on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:23PM (#330701)
True, Microsoft is an example, Gates went out and bought what would become MS-DOS, AFTER he made the deal with IBM. However, this has to be looked at in context - he had the money to buy it from someone else.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:15AM (#330739)
Right, I remember reading something to that effect once . . . that event sort of proves both opposing opinions doesn't it? Yes, you can make money by selling vaporware, and yes, it is evil and abominable people/companies that do it (which is why I won't do it)
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by abl on Monday October 13, 2008 @10:23AM (#331027)
I wouldn't go as far as labeling it evil - as long as you have the resources and the "follow-through" to make vaporware into a real product. It took a significant amount of resourcefulness to land a deal with IBM, whether it was easy because of prior contacts, or hard-earned from the ground up, is notwithstanding. However, the final product was delivered, and the quality was good is most respects. But Gates' goal was not to build a product from the start, and Orian's goal was, which makes the situation quite different.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @04:05PM (#331459)
I think it is evil because it basically amounts to making a bet with other people's money . . . I realize that "what if" scenarios sound unrealistic at times, however . . . seriously, what if - in that particular case with Gates, for example - the product had turned out to have some major showstopping flaws?

Consumers/users ALWAYS get screwed in those type of scenarios. I don't believe in taking risks with other people's money.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:50AM (#331982)
When I said "fake sell" I was meaning using it to prove a market. The process is as follows:

1. Create mockup/demo/realistic brochure/non-functional physical prototype 2. Go to your target market. Count number of targets 3. Try to sell them the product at the target price 4. Once they hand over their credit card etc, just hand it back. 5. Tell them thanks very much for their support, but this was a test so you can make sure the market wants the product, if they want we can contact them when/if the product is ready. 6. Do your stats. What proportion of the target market you sampled bought the product. Extrapolate to the estimated population to get an idea of how many units you can sell. [rinse and repeat to make your product more attractive to the market]

It's the only way I have ever heard of turning a snake-oil, soothsayer business plan into one that can statistically show the uptake of your product in the market.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @05:12AM (#332078)
My, that's neat, wasting people's time with a marketing survey under the guise of an actual product offer.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @06:41PM (#332731)
Yeah. Your way wastes everyones time as the product isn't right from the start and it's harder to build a great business, as you don't know if you'll ever get paid. Everyone to their own though. I'd rather be sure.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @07:10PM (#332760)
Oh, "my way" involves solving the problem of "how to find out what users want" WITHOUT resorting to shady little tactics.

I refuse to believe that there is no other way of conducting a market study other than resorting to sneaky, dastardly little tactics. Why? because there ARE other ways.

Also, nice strawman, I obviously did not counter with "conduct NO market studies/surveys" - I came back with "that's dishonest and I don't believe in it".

Funny, how I have set up services (granted, not products) that made me money and I did not have to resort to cheap little deceptive tricks.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @09:10PM (#332845)
1. How can you be sure someone wants to pay for something unless they bring out their credit card? I would love to know a better way. 2. Is it unethical to sell a product that isn't right for the market, and promote half truths like most advertising does? Which is better in the long run?

I would rather have a product I can be statistically confident is going to sell because users have wanted to pay for it. There's no debating whether it's right for the market or not.

Thanks for the discussion by the way, this is fun :). If you do have a better way I'd love to know.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:24PM (#333490)
I keep trying to post a reply, and this app simply hangs and then displays a blank screen.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:25PM (#333492)
As I mentioned, finding out what the users want is a worthwhile problem in and of itself. There can be no one true formula, as not all scenarios are the same.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:27PM (#333497)
What has worked for me in the past (for the provision of services) has been a combination of becoming intimately acquainted with a process, and talking to people who carry out this process regularly, both with the intention of identifying where a need can be fulfilled. I am not talking about a bullet list of features to checkmark or cross out, that's junk, users don't LIE about a feature that they say they need and then don't, no, users simply do not know what they truly need a lot of the time, I don't focus on getting them to tell me a feature per se or a highly detailed aspect of the service I aim to provide them with (because what the hell do they know about the work I am doing, they know about the work they do, which is why I go to them) I focus on obtaining information and insight from them. I aim to give people what they need, as opposed to what they want . . . why? because if you just give them what they need, they will thank you for it later when they realize that this is what they needed, if you give them what they want, they will later realize that is not what they needed, but will not blame themselves for it, they will blame you.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:27PM (#333498)
Market surveys and market studies in many ways shapes and forms have been, are, and will continue to be used to great success, the problem with your variation is that it involves deception. You don't bs people and trick them into taking your marketing survey under the guise of a product offer.

I am seriously curious to know how many times you have seen that work. I would think that many people would resent the tactic and retaliate by not purchasing your product, or they would lose their trust in you (and rightly so, you done suckered them once) and therefore respect. It's interesting to note how many thousands of products have been researched, developed, and taken to market to great success, without deception tactics.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @11:55PM (#334119)
As for success, it was introduced to me by a very successful serial technology entrepreneur, investor & advisor with at least one personal 200M exit, and multiple smaller or similar size.

I guess we will agree to disagree on the ethics. I personally don't find it any different than deceptive advertising that is used in the majority of sales channels worldwide, the many deceptive claims of products overstating the benefits, understating negatives etc.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Friday October 17, 2008 @11:06AM (#335656)
I see what you are saying about the widespread consumer deception, it is true, and yes - we can agree to disagree.

I simply refuse to do it because others are, and believe that successful market studies can be carried out without deceptive tactics.

This general attitude and outlook on my behalf actually mostly derives more from sheer pride than from any sort of assumed moral superiority - I simply can't sleep at night if I think that I applied or relied on anything other than my own merit to achieve something, and deceptive/slick tactics make me feel as though I cheated because I was unable to do it the hard way . . . that kind of thing.

I will close by conceding that I may be wrong about this, however, I might also just end up identifying more user needs in a highly accurate manner with my approach, which is conducive to even greater profits.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:28PM (#333503)
I had to break up my reply into several posts in order for this app to be able to handle it.

How dissapointing. I have seen PHP do better than this. This is depressing.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:26PM (#330704)
Well, I don't disagree that things can be done that way, but I do not think it is the right thing to do, for several reasons. Why learn to design/program just to pull a total suit move and sell vaporware/vaporproducts? If that is what you want to do, then just fake sell as you said, and then hire a few coders from India who can put whatever together for peanuts and then call that good (I would not be able to sleep at night ever after however). Also, those kinds of maneuvers are best left to suits - who are good at those kinds of things - instead of tech people, who are normally better at building things as opposed to pulling marketing maneuvers.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by nostrademons on Sunday October 12, 2008 @11:53PM (#330720)
Even if you're a top-notch developer, it still takes an order of magnitude more time to develop an actual product than to put up a product description and a few mockups, and you can still expect 90% of your products to fail. You can easily spend years of development time on products that nobody wants. Why waste all that talent?

I had/have the same aversion to selling things that don't exist that you have. But honestly, I think that the next time I do a startup, I'm going to do it that way. I get really sick of speculatively building things that nobody wants. Why not make sure they want it first and then build it?

Plus, two of my favorite startups - DropBox and RescueTime - both used this approach (though perhaps with a little less dishonesty - they clearly marked it "demo"), and their products are better for it.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:39AM (#331970)
It will be worth your time. Its kind of like Stephen Key's approach, but more for technology/products.

Often times first thing I want to do is jump into code, and it's the last thing you should be doing. Proving the market is critical, and the only way you can prove it exists (for most companies) is to fake sell.

When people tell you, I would buy it if it had this feature, they are often lying. Unless they are willing to pony up their credit card, you haven't solved the problem imho.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @12:11AM (#330737)
I do see your point.

I think that the objective is a market study, for which I believe there are some tried and tested methods, although it occurs to me that in this field those may not apply as so many other things, however if that is the case, then I believe "how to find out what the users want without selling vaporware/other questionable tactics" is a worthwhile problem to tackle in and of itself.

Selling vaporware is to me similar to using users as unwitting beta testers, I don't believe in it, I think we should be upfront like the examples you cited: if it is a beta let people know, if it is vaporware, let people know, if it is a demo, let people know.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by trapper on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:41AM (#331973)
When I say fake sell I mean do the transaction then provide a refund.

In my opinion it's the ethical thing to do, not just for you but for your users. Why bother creating a product if it's never going to get traction in the market? You won't be able to afford to support it well, and it won't develop into a great business unless you get significant revenue. This is more unethical for the users, as you'll have to fold or let is stagnate. Why risk it?

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @05:15AM (#332080)
Time is a valuable resource. Wasting people's time with a marketing survey under the guise of a product offer is not my idea of ethical. I would fly off the frickin' handle if someone wasted my time for me like that, using a deceptive little trick like that.