News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Monday October 13, 2008 @01:38AM (#330804)
"Those kinds of activities (networking, sales, marketing) do not mandate exceptional intelligence, from what I have seen those mostly require innate skill and experience. Many people can network, sell, and market. Not many can code."

I still think this is arguable, you describe what separates star marketers from the rest is "innate skill" in this case innate marketing/sales/networking skill. However, I think I can equally make the case for star marketers. I'll discuss you're argument from the marketing perspective because its the area I'm most familiar with and feel most qualified to speak for.

Marketing isn't just a game of follow these rules and you will be successful, its not just a matter of experience either. If it were, marketing agencies wouldn't be differentiable and campaigns like Absolut wouldn't have cult-like status. Just as there is an so described "innate skill" for programmers I would argue that there is a similar type of "innate skill" that separates the best marketers from the rest. To say that intelligence on the same level as programming isn't mandated for marketing is demeaning to that profession as a whole and represents a misunderstanding of what really goes into a well defined marketing strategy. Admittedly, it may not be as quantitatively measured as programming, but that does not mean it requires less intelligence or is less demanding.

I do agree with your point that creating value is conducive to attracting attention, but by no means is it a limiting factor. There are plenty of historical examples where things of little to no value, when marketed well, rose to great success. (The pet rock, among other things)

I've done a fair amount of both programming and marketing, and while I don't claim to be a "star" at either, I still cringe when people dismiss one or the other categorically as being of little added value. It happens from both sides and most of the time just represents a lack of understanding of the efforts that go into either.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @04:12PM (#331468)
I referred to a combination of innate skill and experience, not one or the other.

I did not say that marketing was a follow the cookbook type endeavor either.

Problem with this point is that, neither one of us in this small debate has any hard data to back up or counter our respective points (does any exist? I personally doubt it) which are highly subjective anyway, mostly based on anecdotal perception.

I stick by my opinion however, and can point to the relative number of programmers versus marketing people in the global workforce as indicative of what I am saying . . . if more people were smart enough to program, as opposed to market, they would . . .

Marketing has its place, but to an admittedly occasionally arrogant geek such as myself (who has come across some incredibly, impossibly dumb marketing types) they are figuratively just the people who stand outside the shop on the sidewalk and try to get people to step inside and look at the wares . . .

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Monday October 13, 2008 @10:10PM (#331853)
"I stick by my opinion however, and can point to the relative number of programmers versus marketing people in the global workforce as indicative of what I am saying . . . if more people were smart enough to program, as opposed to market, they would . . ."

Can you further explain here? Market forces will determine where people go, salaries will rise until people move into those positions. The number of people in given positions is not indicative at all of the skill of the people taking those jobs.

"Marketing has its place, but to an admittedly occasionally arrogant geek such as myself (who has come across some incredibly, impossibly dumb marketing types) they are figuratively just the people who stand outside the shop on the sidewalk and try to get people to step inside and look at the wares . . ."

I agree with you that this is an extremely arrogant viewpoint. I've met many stupid programmers but I don't assume the same of all programmers. I also think you're confusing the roles of sales and marketing but that's beside the point.

Discounting the value of people who aren't like you isn't a very great way to get anywhere in life, especially as an entrepreneur.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Monday October 13, 2008 @10:32PM (#331867)
The numbers speak for themselves. That is obvious.

You are not reading what I write. I did not mention skill, I mentioned intelligence. Those are not the same.

It is quite simple. Look at all occupations. There are more non-intellectually demanding jobs than there are intellectually demanding jobs. There are more dumb people than smart people on the planet. That is obvious.

Speaking of market forces, why are programmers on average paid more than marketing and sales people?

You have met stupid programmers? Interesting. I agree that not all are extremely bright, however, anyone who is truly stupid will not be able to even learn how to program, much less become worthy of the title programmer, whereas, I have seen some nearly illiterate folks working in marketing, and sales, and I realize those two are different, even though I do not bother to differentiate between the two when making reference to them.

"Discounting the value of people who aren't like you isn't a very great way to get anywhere in life, especially as an entrepreneur."

Neat, now you are starting the personal attacks.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @12:25AM (#331928)
"You are not reading what I write. I did not mention skill, I mentioned intelligence. Those are not the same."

Innate skill and intelligence are pretty much the same thing. (Although I would argue that intelligence can grow as a function of effort).

"Speaking of market forces, why are programmers on average paid more than marketing and sales people?"

The pay of programmers vs. marketers is pretty comparable. Check salary.com

"Neat, now you are starting the personal attacks."

No, just responding to your multi-post personal attack against marketers/bizdev with one against arrogance. Its up to you whether to take it personally.

I have more points I could make, but this doesn't seem to be going anywhere useful so I'm done with this discussion.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:04AM (#331953)
Innate skill and intelligence are most definitely NOT, NOT pretty much the same thing. Check an English language dictionary.

salary.com? Please.

I wrote "on average".

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:00AM (#332021)
Ok, fine, lets be precise. First, innate skill is an oxymoron then because "skill" implies that it is learned (see dictionary) and "innate" implies it is not.

As far as "on average" goes, where do you think salary.com/payscale.com get their data, averages of real-world salaries.

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @05:09AM (#332076)
>First, innate skill is an oxymoron then because "skill" implies that >it is learned

Wrong.

>(see dictionary)

Skill n. 2 a) an art, craft, or science, esp. one involving the use of the hands or body b) ABILITY IN SUCH AN ART, CRAFT, OR SCIENCE

ISBN 0-02-860586-1 pg. 1257

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @01:49PM (#332393)
hmmm, well they must have changed their minds then...

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skill%5B2%5D

1 obsolete : cause , reason

2 a: the ability to use one's knowledge effectively and readily in execution or performance b: dexterity or coordination especially in the execution of learned physical tasks

3: a learned power of doing something competently : a developed aptitude or ability <language skills>

(emphasis mine)

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:05PM (#332457)
Oh, I am sure they "changed their minds", when there is no mention of a definition being obsolete or deprecated.

Edit: Stalemate?

Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by jamiequint on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @03:46PM (#332523)
sure, cheers
Re:Reflections of a YC Dropout by mroman on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @04:59PM (#332610)
cheers