News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by braingenious on Friday September 30, 2022 @11:11PM (#33043472)
I always like to poke fun at the “How to deal with being the smartest person in the room/industry/world”-style blog posts that make for common front-page schlock here, but this is a fascinating and relatively rare sub-species of “You ARE the smartest person in the room/industry/world. Anyone that suggests otherwise is ‘considered harmful’”

I love that the extension of this is “making friends considered harmful”, “trusting others considered harmful”, “forming professional relationships considered harmful (unless they’re subservient to your supreme vision, intellect and command)”

This reads like a very angry breakup letter.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by igammarays on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:27AM (#33044143)
False dichotomy. Going out on your own doesn't mean you think you are the smartest person in the room. It's often about freedom. If I decide I want to go biking alone, doesn't mean I think I am the best biker.

I decided to keep going the solo-founder route precisely so that my social circle could be enlarged and enriched. Now I don't have to spend most of my time around tech bros and cofounders whose main interest in business. Instead, I cultivate my social relationships in completely unrelated domains: the arts, community outreach, my physical neighbourhood, religion/philosophy and other hobbies. That gives me both the motivation and the space to think and keep going at the business, because my work fuels something other than itself.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by braingenious on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:42AM (#33044219)
I’m glad that worked out for you professionally and socially, but what exactly are you saying here?

If you had a co-founder you wouldn’t have time for friends that are into art, philosophy, religion, neighborhoods, hobbies?

edit: To clarify, if I had a business partner that cost me that much, I would definitely sever from that relationship. I would consider that a failure of a single relationship rather than waxing poetic about how everybody would cost that much. To do so would be for me to put myself above theoretical individuals because of a single event.

That probably wouldn’t be the sort of error that I would see as reasonable when thinking about anybody I’d maybe do business with…

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by kossTKR on Saturday October 01, 2022 @09:18AM (#33046387)
Interesting, what kind of business are you running that is successful enough to go solo?

I've been thinking about the same thing, but most solo founders or "digital nomads" i've met are actually working in marketing, affiliate or social media, not really coding, or SAAS.

I wonder if it's feasible.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by andy_ppp on Saturday October 01, 2022 @02:41AM (#33044484)
This comment is needlessly harsh on the article. I read this much more as why not consider the opposite view. One of my frustrations with the advice YC and others seem to give is that it is all hearsay and I don’t believe it needs to be that way. Especially for an organisation that prides itself on being scientifically lead there must be a way to show data around most of their claims. The whole point of the scientific method is trying to prevent people from guessing from their perceived experiences because we so easily fool ourselves into believing without the statistical proof to back it up.

This article is also not purely true, I’m certain there are cofounders that work perfectly together and people who are better at selecting them for themselves. I think the stuff about handling high stress situations is very useful and testing that somehow seems like a good idea. I’m not sure how many difficult situations I’ve had with my best friend to be honest, let alone a stranger.

I find it really surprising that a solo cofounder is more likely to succeed. Can anyone refute or confirm this?

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by doctor_eval on Saturday October 01, 2022 @07:55AM (#33045920)
It's got nothing to do with being smartest person in the room.

When your wellbeing gets put into other people's hands it's super stressful, and if they fuck up, or you fuck up, or even if you just argue with them, then it's way, way more stressful than if you're just doing things on your own. The stress leads to a relationship death spiral, and then you end up losing everything. Not having cofounders won't stop you from making mistakes, but it will prevent the relationship/business death spiral.

I've always said that I prefer to make my own mistakes, instead of implementing other people's. I wish I'd listened to my own advice before I brought in co-founders for my previous business; my next caper is going to be 100% solo.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by prirun on Saturday October 01, 2022 @10:06AM (#33046662)
With 2 co-founders, you have to agree on everything. That's hard. 3 co-founders let's you do a majority thing on decisions, but that IMO can easily turn into politics: you do this for me, I'll do that for you, we are better friends so you need to vote with me on this, etc.

Having previously started and exiting a 2-founder 50/50 business, I wouldn't do it again. I might give equity, but even that can be very tricky. See for example the case of Craigslist having a minority shareholder who sold his shares to eBay. The original minority shareholder may not have caused the other shareholders any problems, but having a large competing corporation as a minority shareholder is a whole 'nother thing.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by withinboredom on Sunday October 02, 2022 @05:07AM (#33054270)
Oof. I can’t imagine a 50/50 relationship. My marriage isn’t even 50/50, unless we are getting a divorce. In my marriage we each have “domains” that we are gods of. When it comes to money, she has domain over day-to-day expenses and I have control over making sure bills are paid and taxes are accounted for and we reconcile this fairly regularly.

My point is, there has to be some kind of “tie-breaker” that isn’t biased/random. Whether that is a “fact” that something falls into someone’s “domain” or whether it’s a person. 50/50 just doesn’t seem realistic or a recipe for stress.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by baxtr on Saturday October 01, 2022 @02:39AM (#33044473)
There is a great blog post by Mark Suster on that topic. He basically argues that you should hire your co-founder.

https://bothsidesofthetable.com/the-co-founder-mythology-791...

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by robocat on Saturday October 01, 2022 @03:51AM (#33044837)
And here’s YC arguing the opposite: https://www.ycombinator.com/library/5x-how-to-split-equity-a...

Disclaimer: I am an initial founder with a minority shareholding, and it truely sucks (even though the business is a centipede (very very approximately 1/100 of a unicorn).

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by laserlight on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:42AM (#33045058)
The article unfortunately contradicts itself. If a startup takes 10 years to build, why vest 25% of the shares after just one year? Then, it’s a very cost-effective strategy to leave after a year and let others work for you for the remaining 9 years.

Article also presents a very outdated view: more equity means more motivation. According to two-factor theory [0], equity is not a motivation factor.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-factor_theory

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by robocat on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:58PM (#33050047)
> why vest 25% of the shares after just one year?

I don’t have any experience with the topic of vesting, but I will have a go at explaining how I see it.

Investment risk reduces as the years go on. If you are ever investing your time, make sure you get an appropriate return for your risk. Ownership hardly matters if the company fails. Very complicated for poor company. However for a successful company, you as a founder presumably helped make it successful, so you deserve some ownership share (ownership matters the most when a business is very successful). You rightly point out that ownership amounts are contentious and they virtually always are because everything is a compromise with huge unknowns.

I presume 4 years is just a rule of thumb for VC funded businesses - fast growth is expected and VC investments will dilute ownership and control. For a slower growth self-funded (bootstrapped) business, maybe more years is appropriate, but you definitely don’t want a zero-risk 10th year ownership percentage to be as valuable as the immense-risk first year.

I personally would be more worried about “reverse dilution” provisions. Quote from a comment on the AVC blog: “Based on typical founder vesting provisions, if a founder leaves, [their] unvested shares are forfeited thereby effectively providing reverse dilution to the rest of the shareholders – including the investors who will now own x% + y%.” (not sure if this is true, the use of the word “forfeited” is poor because AFAIK shares are actually compulsorily bought back by the company).

Example.

Let’s say you have technical founder Zak (current job pays $200k), non-technical founder Bob (current job pays $200k), and angel investor Sue with $200k to invest. Business is to prove market in a year with a MVP, and then get VC funding to grow the business. They agree on a valuation of $1 million for their company, sign standard agreements that Zak and Bob vest over 4 years with a 1 year cliff.

Cap table at founding is 40% Zak (common shares), 40% Bob (common shares) and 20% Sue (preferential shares). They use free cookie cutter legal founding documents from a website. Zak and Bob get paid $100k each for the first year by the business.

At the end of year one, they get a VC round, $1 million for 25%.

Cap table is now 25% VC (preferential), 15% Angel Sue (preferential), 30% Zak (common) and 30% Bob (common).

Zak and Bob increase their salary to $200k.

After another year Zak, Sue and the VC decide to kick Bob out (replacing with VC suggested CEO etcetera). The company buys back Bob’s unvested shares (15% of cap table) for 0.00001 cents per share (par value - total cost less than $1), and the company cancels the shares (not putting into treasury - not owning itself recursively!). There is no acceleration for Bob because it is not a sale or IPO.

Cap table is now: 29.4% VC (preferential), 17.6% Angel Sue (preferential), 35.4% Zak (common), 17.6% Bob (common).

Note that Bob’s ownership weirdly went up from 15% to 17.6% - maybe not obvious. Also note that before the one year cliff everyone had a huge financial incentive to sack Bob before Bob’s shares vested.

Also note that Zak and Bob have invested $100k each (opportunity cost from having $100k less pretax salary in the first year), yet they only got common shares and not preferential shares. Their actual investment is around $70k each at post tax marginal rate, so they avoid some tax (depending on capital gains taxes etcetera). And investing “marginal dollars” because the first dollar one earns pays expenses, and the last dollar one earns is disposable income (assuming one can vary one’s income).

The above is a very simple case. I would be interested to see proper write-up of actual situations and how circumstances played out in reality.

Personally I think you want to spend as little time worrying about all the things that could go wrong, or how you could be shafted. You can’t protect yourself against the unlimited ways shit can fuck up. Choose founders and investors that have integrity. Choose founders and investors that have incentives to display integrity to others. Go with default agreements regardless of the obvious massive flaws and imbalances.

Spend your time focusing on building a successful business. Excessive profit can prevent or resolve most problems.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by baxtr on Saturday October 01, 2022 @04:24AM (#33044989)
Interesting. Thanks for sharing. What would you do the next time differently?
Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by robocat on Saturday October 01, 2022 @03:04PM (#33049081)
> What would you do the next time differently?

I am a geek engineer type. If I were coaching a younger me, I would mostly be encouraging learning soft people skills (negotiation, influence, reading others, etcetera). I still tend to get sidetracked on yak shaving (the quest for perfection in a very narrow area, rather than good enough then focus on the next most important thing). I made okay decisions given who I was, so I am not unhappy with myself. I have been improving myself, but not fast enough!

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by Silverback_VII on Saturday October 01, 2022 @05:25AM (#33045240)
I'm seeing what you are doing here, people who criticize are often subconsciously perceived as more intelligent and powerful. But apart from your small power move, let me ask you, since there are some stats in the article, what exactly is wrong about the statement ?

If you have a specific destination in mind it is certainly better to remain the captain. Naivity in dealing with other people has killed many great ideas and therefore some warnings are appropriate.

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by braingenious on Saturday October 01, 2022 @03:25PM (#33049247)
I’m not sure how my clearly-stated poking fun is a “small power move” but are you aware of the irony in your post?

The topic of my post was a benign “I think this article is kind of silly” point. The topic of your response is that criticism is a “power move”? And your impulse is to yourself criticize?

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by bjornsing on Saturday October 01, 2022 @08:31AM (#33046123)
It’s interesting how intense and emotional the criticism of this kind of reasoning tends to be, and your comment is a prime example. It makes me think there is self-interest or some strong ideological basis at its root.

I realize it’s fairly pointless to ask, but why does this feel so threatening to you? Is it “smart person doesn’t need me – can make shitload of money without conforming to my social norms / letting me freeload”? ;)

Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by stingraycharles on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:39AM (#33044204)
While I agree with the sentiment, it does need to be said that trying to find a cofounder can be incredibly difficult, and doing it solo should definitely be a consideration.
Re:Co-Founding Considered Harmful by Aeolun on Saturday October 01, 2022 @01:37AM (#33044191)
I think the idea is that you are the only person (not paid by you) that thinks they’re the smartest person in the room.