Also, Microsoft employees work on GPL2-licensed Linux just fine, so something seems off in your story.
stuff that is not Windows Terminal but that lives in the Windows Terminal repo on GitHub gets shipped with Windows.
so, yes, there are very good reasons they can't license Windows Terminal via GPL.
WSL kernel folks get that repo whitelisted.
Also, it's not just WSL people who work on GPL software inside Microsoft. I guess they are magically expected not to subconsciously reproduce any GPL code in their work ever ;)
They're free to look at the approach and simply rewrite it.
They'd have to anyway to fit in with their codebase.
If by "look at the approach" you mean the "look at the code", then no. You're giving a step for your code to be considered a derivative work. If by "look at the approach" you mean someone read the code, made a specification, and then someone else that hasn't looked the code, made a program based on the specification, then yes. But arguably this isn't "simply rewrite".
Those aren't even baseless considerations. ReactOS project had paused development due to concerns that derived (read: rewritten) parts of leaked Windows code may have been used. It took years for ReactOS to show that everything was in fact a clean-room implementation (basically doing what wrote above). If they hadn't, they'll have made themselves open to be sued by Microsoft.
You can not. So what do you do to prepare for a lawsuit which alleges that you've copied GPL code into the Windows codebase? You have technical and legal barriers in place so that those developers can't see GPL code where you can control that, and make them promise that they won't do anything to compromise the license of the Windows code that they work on. Technical and legal (read: contractual) measures to prevent this are the defense that one needs to have in order to defend against a case like this, in court.
So, because you, as a Microsoft attorney, can't guarantee that GPL code won't be reproduced verbatim in any quantity in the Windows codebase, you do what you can to dissuade your developers from looking at GPL code.
please think for 2 seconds on your own and I won't have to ELI5.
I don't mean simply renaming variables or changing a couple of lines.
Algorithms, being purely functional, are not copyrightable in any country that I know of. So a new implementation that uses the same algorithm as the original, but without copying any of its non-functional aspects, is not a derivative work of the original and does not infringe its copyright.
Cleanroom reimplementation is a defense against allegations of copying, because under, for example, US copyright law, access plus substantial similarity is sufficient to show copying. The "He's So Fine" lawsuit is one of the most extreme examples of this doctrine. Cleanroom reimplementations are a defense against copying by eliminating the access element. But copying the functional aspects of a program does not meet the "substantial similarity" bar.
No.
To give a very concrete example: french singer Claude François made the song Comme d'habitude: https://youtu.be/avr5nvY4wxg
It was translated and rewritten a few times but he still is recognized as one of the copyright owners on those covers, e.g. https://youtu.be/qQzdAsjWGPg which are definitely not just a mechanical rewrite of the original score
Well, at least unless you end up as big as Led Zeppelin was before someone catches you, I guess ;)
Are you talking about the Led Zeppelin who get entangled in judicial pursuits for plagiarism every couple years? If it was as clear cut as you say it is it would never reach any judge.
There is even one case where someone was condemned for not copying any specific song but the general style of another musician : Pharrell Williams had to pay 5M to the Marvin Gaye estate because of this
https://rpjlaw.com/blurred-lines-copying-songs-musical-style...
https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2018/07/blurred-lines-b...
Yes, this is extremely shitty but this is the world we live in
Yes, I intentionally mentioned a song "by Page – inspired by Jake Holmes": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dazed_and_Confused_(song)#Led_...
> The Ninth Circuit stated that the appeal was decided “on narrow grounds” and that the “decision does not give license to copyright a musical style or ‘groove.’”
What a pile of bullshit. I wasn't aware of that case.
perhaps you are not familiar with what the GPL requires of its users, and how wildly incompatible that is with what a company like Microsoft does.
Microsoft employees are forbidden from looking at GPL code (as well as other virally licensed code) because they may unwittingly reproduce some GPL code they saw in a large Microsoft codebase.
If that happens, and they are taken to trial over it, and lose, that entire codebase is now GPL. This is enough of a risk to them that MS employees have computers which simply can not view GPL code.
that is also why they would not watch the video; it isn’t about his voice, it is about the code visible on stream. additionally, watching a video of GPL code being written could be perceived as an attempt to circumvent the restrictions on viewing GPL code, and would likely get the viewer into trouble.
you not already knowing this bothers me a lot, given all the things you’ve said in this discussion. you are making a lot of assumptions that are just not true and basing your opinions on the belief that those assumptions are true.
this is very similar to why software at microsoft is as bad as it is generally; a lot of people assuming they know things they don’t know, and producing results which are more flawed than they needed to be.