News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why modern software is slow by the_af on Friday September 30, 2022 @12:12AM (#33030834)
Isn't copyright about copying verbatim (or with trivial enough changes that it remains recognizably the same) large enough sections of the protected work?
Re:Why modern software is slow by jcelerier on Friday September 30, 2022 @12:20AM (#33030887)
At least not in my country (France). At the very least changing the pitch, and rhythm and interpretation of a melody is not enough to make it an original work there.

To give a very concrete example: french singer Claude François made the song Comme d'habitude: https://youtu.be/avr5nvY4wxg

It was translated and rewritten a few times but he still is recognized as one of the copyright owners on those covers, e.g. https://youtu.be/qQzdAsjWGPg which are definitely not just a mechanical rewrite of the original score

Re:Why modern software is slow by seba_dos1 on Friday September 30, 2022 @02:41AM (#33031715)
There's a difference between creating a derivative work and analyzing how something is done in order to create something new based on that knowledge. You can make songs in style of Led Zeppelin that sound like they could be written and performed by Led Zeppelin without violating any copyrights (and to be able to do that you obviously need to know some Led Zeppelin songs beforehand), but you can't take "Dazed and Confused", change the guitar solo and part of the lyrics and call it done...

Well, at least unless you end up as big as Led Zeppelin was before someone catches you, I guess ;)

Re:Why modern software is slow by jcelerier on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:56AM (#33034220)
> Well, at least unless you end up as big as Led Zeppelin was before someone catches you, I guess ;)

Are you talking about the Led Zeppelin who get entangled in judicial pursuits for plagiarism every couple years? If it was as clear cut as you say it is it would never reach any judge.

There is even one case where someone was condemned for not copying any specific song but the general style of another musician : Pharrell Williams had to pay 5M to the Marvin Gaye estate because of this

https://rpjlaw.com/blurred-lines-copying-songs-musical-style...

https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2018/07/blurred-lines-b...

Yes, this is extremely shitty but this is the world we live in

Re:Why modern software is slow by seba_dos1 on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:30AM (#33034586)
> Are you talking about the Led Zeppelin who get entangled in judicial pursuits for plagiarism every couple years?

Yes, I intentionally mentioned a song "by Page – inspired by Jake Holmes": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dazed_and_Confused_(song)#Led_...

> The Ninth Circuit stated that the appeal was decided “on narrow grounds” and that the “decision does not give license to copyright a musical style or ‘groove.’”

What a pile of bullshit. I wasn't aware of that case.