Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data
by shiven on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:32PM
(#3302701)
I guess CIQ just happens to be the outrage-flavor-of-the-week. This looks so much like a public pile-on whenever Facebook screws people over with sneaky settings changes. The classic cycle plays: breaking news, genuine anger, hipster outrage, slow smoldering disinterest, and finally apathy and collective amnesia ... until the next outrage-of-the-week comes along. The Zuck was right: "dumb fucks".
If anyone is really all that outraged, what concrete steps have they taken to make sure this crap gets sorted out?
Oh and BTW, do you have a link confirming the _formal apology_ ? Couldn't find it with a simple DDG search. Maybe my search vector was wrong.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data
by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:49PM
(#3302742)
It's on their website.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data
by bdonlan on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:36AM
(#3302872)
I think the real problem here is there's no visibility in what CIQ is actually sending, and so no way to verify their claims. Additionally, even if they don't intentionally send all that excess data up to their servers, it's still getting logged, and will be sent with crash and ANR reports to _Google_; sending all that kind of personal information to a third-party is not a good thing, either.
CarrierIQ brought some of this on themselves by reacting terribly to a security researcher's claims regarding their software. Trevor Eckhart claimed CIQ was a "rootkit", and they freaked out and threatened to sue him.
Naturally, everyone now assumes that CarrierIQ is evil, since suing security researchers is almost invariably an evil thing to do.
People are paying less attention to the fact that CarrierIQ subsequently issued a formal apology to Trevor (from experience: companies stung by security researchers virtually never do this; they just back off quietly), and that nobody has really refuted CIQ's claims about what their software does.
The "there's this evil big brother company nobody has ever heard of that a security researcher found out and got sued over" narrative is a lot more fun than the banal reality, so that's what we're all going to run with.
It's also a little amusing to see people wigging out over the privacy of their SMS messages. Their SMS messages have no privacy. The carriers see and log all of them. Lord only knows what other tools they have on their network explicitly for the purpose of mining data out of those messages.