News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by djb_hackernews on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:19PM (#3302530)
They are hiring an "Extreme Analytics Architect", to work on datasets measured in petabytes[1]. Would be interested to know what they consider extraneous.

[1] http://www.carrieriq.com/company/careers.htm#ExtAnalyticsArc...

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by jrockway on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:06PM (#3302502)
This explanation is very interesting. I'd like to be able to share with my carrier when a call is dropped and when a web page doesn't load, but I don't want that being done automatically. Make a list for me, and I'll send it along to the carrier once a month after making sure there's nothing I want kept a secret there. Also, I should be getting paid to do this, because my job as a customer is not to make some big company's product better.

It's a nice try to include software to do this in the background with no way to opt out, but with the cat out of the bag, the carriers are going to have to figure something else out. (I use Cyanogen Mod so I doubt this affects me at all. But it's annoying to discover that the reason behind closed bootloaders and firmwares is to spy on me behind my back without permission. Good thing they employ shitty developers to write that code!)

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by flyt on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:35PM (#3302422)
The key question for them is "Why can't users disable Carrier IQ on their device, and why does it run if the cellular antenna is disabled?"
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:02PM (#3302491)
Two plausible answers:

(a) Because the carriers don't want you to, if only because it would increase support costs to have to walk users through turning it back on, but probably mostly because normal people don't really care about the stuff CIQ is intended to do.

(b) Because the feature for disabling CIQ with cell service disabled makes zero money for any party involved and therefore has slipped every MRD given to its engineering team.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by jimrandomh on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:23PM (#3302677)
> why does it run if the cellular antenna is disabled?

That's easy; they can't reliably tell between disabled cellular service and broken cellular service, and the carriers really want to know about the latter. Well, they probably could figure out whether service is supposed to be disabled, but the mechanisms that control whether service is enabled are, themselves, one of the things that CarrierIQ would be used to detect problems with.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by salimane on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:17PM (#3302378)
you ignore extraneous user data?!??! what!?!?! why do you get it in the first place if you're only interested in a subset? bunch of lying rootkit developers
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by ghshephard on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:43PM (#3302443)
From the article:

"If during a support call a technician asks a customer to enter a short code, CIQ will be listening for it; when it’s entered, CIQ will relay the appropriate diagnostic information to the carrier. Any keystrokes beyond that are ignored."

Their explanation then, for monitoring keystrokes, is that they are waiting for a diagnostic code to be entered by the user. Presumably this can be done from anywhere within the phone, on any platform, without regards to running applications.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by latch on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:46PM (#3302449)
How do you capture a subset of data without capturing it all (and discarding what doesn't match)? If you are doing a find in a document, don't you scan through the entire document and discard whatever isn't what you want? It sounds like that's the explanation they are trying to give.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by salimane on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:28PM (#3302554)
the thing is, given the context, you can do this without looking at everything the user is doing, you can basically wait for the trigger (error, call drop...) to happen before trying to submit error reports. that's the way it's done in software applications
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by latch on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:56PM (#3302760)
Just to be clear, I'm not saying they are right, I'm just trying to look at this objectively. If you read what they said, I don't think your solution works:

"During a support call a technician asks a customer to enter a short code, CIQ will be listening for it"

Without knowing a ton more, maybe there's a _much_ better way to do this..like having the user explicitly launch a program rather than having something always running and always listening. No argument there. But if you're thinking they should abstract away some "code_entered" event, ultimately something lower-level is going to be listening to each keypress and looking at sequences to raise those events.

Some of this stuff happens at a lower level than a lot of us might be use to programming nowadays. I'm not sure that there's necessarily a pretty error event they can hook into. Something about all of this reminds me of using stuf like Spy++ on Windows and you see just how much raw data is available at the lowest levels

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by derefr on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:41PM (#3302436)
A topical metaphor: sometimes, to get a toy, you have to buy the whole happy meal.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by hboon on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:44PM (#3302590)
But here, you are forced to eat it too.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by warmfuzzykitten on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:27PM (#3302690)
Well, of course, they only gather information requested by the carriers, and we all trust the carriers. What could go wrong?
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by georgieporgie on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:50PM (#3302460)
Based on what I've read, none of the investigations actually looked at what data was reported back.

My money is on Carrier IQ providing a valuable service in a somewhat sub-optimal way with regards to privacy, and carriers probably doing a really shoddy job of integrating it into the phones they distribute.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:58PM (#3302481)
I'm more or less convinced that you're right about this.

CarrierIQ brought some of this on themselves by reacting terribly to a security researcher's claims regarding their software. Trevor Eckhart claimed CIQ was a "rootkit", and they freaked out and threatened to sue him.

Naturally, everyone now assumes that CarrierIQ is evil, since suing security researchers is almost invariably an evil thing to do.

People are paying less attention to the fact that CarrierIQ subsequently issued a formal apology to Trevor (from experience: companies stung by security researchers virtually never do this; they just back off quietly), and that nobody has really refuted CIQ's claims about what their software does.

The "there's this evil big brother company nobody has ever heard of that a security researcher found out and got sued over" narrative is a lot more fun than the banal reality, so that's what we're all going to run with.

It's also a little amusing to see people wigging out over the privacy of their SMS messages. Their SMS messages have no privacy. The carriers see and log all of them. Lord only knows what other tools they have on their network explicitly for the purpose of mining data out of those messages.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by shiven on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:32PM (#3302701)
I guess CIQ just happens to be the outrage-flavor-of-the-week. This looks so much like a public pile-on whenever Facebook screws people over with sneaky settings changes. The classic cycle plays: breaking news, genuine anger, hipster outrage, slow smoldering disinterest, and finally apathy and collective amnesia ... until the next outrage-of-the-week comes along. The Zuck was right: "dumb fucks".

If anyone is really all that outraged, what concrete steps have they taken to make sure this crap gets sorted out?

Oh and BTW, do you have a link confirming the _formal apology_ ? Couldn't find it with a simple DDG search. Maybe my search vector was wrong.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by TeMPOraL on Friday December 02, 2011 @02:51AM (#3303155)
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:49PM (#3302742)
It's on their website.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by bdonlan on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:36AM (#3302872)
I think the real problem here is there's no visibility in what CIQ is actually sending, and so no way to verify their claims. Additionally, even if they don't intentionally send all that excess data up to their servers, it's still getting logged, and will be sent with crash and ANR reports to _Google_; sending all that kind of personal information to a third-party is not a good thing, either.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by ghshephard on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:54PM (#3302473)
I don't think any claims were made that data was being reported back. The mere fact that this third-party utility is monitoring keystrokes, SMS data, Web URLs is what has everyone concerned. If it's discovered that the data is being stored _locally_ on the phone - that would turn out to be a scandal.

I suspect laws would be broken if any of this data was actually being reported _off_ of the device.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:00PM (#3302485)
That seems like a really unfair argument. Discussion about CIQ has been rife with people talking about CIQ collecting and reporting keystrokes. The supposition has clearly been that CIQ or the carriers are centrally logging private data.

Given that the carriers already have all your SMS data and phone usage history, I think you're probably wrong on the legal front, too.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by codezero on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:32PM (#3302564)
That's all well and good, but if I don't want to participate in their services, I shouldn't have to, no matter how accountable and trustworthy they are.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by georgieporgie on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:48AM (#3302894)
I agree with you in principle, but I also feel for the company.

As I understand it, they are logging information relevant to communication quality, and using that to improve the network. If you give people the opportunity to opt-out of providing data, many of them will, which means you have much less data to analyze in order to improve services.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by 101001010101 on Thursday December 01, 2011 @09:33PM (#3302413)
It would be interesting to see their agreements with the carriers.

Presumably the carriers could request any data, not simply diagnostics.

It certainly sounds like CIQ is prepared to deliver whatever a carrier might ask for: CIQ's rootkit can capture everything.

Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by tptacek on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:04PM (#3302493)
At (grave) risk of being repetitive: if you don't trust your carrier with your personal information, you shouldn't be using Android phones on their network. CIQ or not, carriers have vastly more information about most people to work with than e.g. Google.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by 101001010101 on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:27PM (#3302688)
At least you have an agreement with your carrier. Alas, you have none with CIQ. Even though you're using their software.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by dedward on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:19PM (#3302528)
All agreements and contracts aside, a legal court order to help with an investigation is unlikely to be ignored.
Re:Carrier IQ Speaks Out: We ignore extraneous user Data by 101001010101 on Thursday December 01, 2011 @11:33PM (#3302713)
And I'd guess they still charge a fee for that, too. :)