News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by typicalrunt on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @12:32PM (#3295854)
Why no angry nerds?

Because nerds are still using their PCs to create mobile and web-based software. The PC may (just may) be dead for the hordes of average consumers out there, but it'll never be dead for those people creating things -- that is, until you can adequately create a mobile or web application on an iPad/iPhone.

Does anyone truly believe that scores of software developers writing financial software for banks are going to trade in their PC to type on an iOS device? Don't bet money on that (at least for the short-term).

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by astine on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:20PM (#3296075)
The complaint that the author makes isn't about consumption vs production devices, it's about curated experiences. Apple can veto your income on the insistence of popular opinion or on a whim, or with no stated reason at all. The author extrapolates that this can lead to an effective restriction of freedom of the press by Apple and other gatekeepers.

This is a real problem and is not alleviated just because you still use a PC to write software.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by onemoreact on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:35PM (#3296156)
Your forgetting about the web. Apple does not veto websites just things in their little walled garden.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by bad_user on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:25PM (#3296447)
Considering how Apple controls the operating system, the app store, the browser and the whole device in general, it wouldn't be technically hard for Apple to censor websites either.

Plus, Apple is restricting the browser on purpose, to make it less useful. Tell me, how can you create an online image editing software, if Apple doesn't allow you to upload files from iPhone's browser?

And what Apple is doing today would have been unthinkable a couple of years ago. Censoring the web is perfectly within their grasp and you should see that, otherwise you're not seeing the forest from the trees.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by onemoreact on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:09PM (#3296659)
The most popular home computers have always been walled gardens where the manufacture got a cut from every peace of software sold. A huge chunk of all consumer software runs on them and there approval could easily make or break a software development house. We just called them 'game consoles' and conveniently forgot that their approval process was far more expensive and difficult than anything Angry Birds needed to bother with.

So, I don't think there is anything all that novel about the iOS approach and I find it hard to think of such things as an erosion of control when consoles predated the PC in most peoples homes and tended to be far more draconian than iOS. Do you even remember how bad phones and their app stores where like pre Apple?

PS: Microsoft had no problem getting skin into this game and started taking their cut well before Apple produced iOS. Despite what the article says.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by turing on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @06:31PM (#3297406)
Game consoles are not PCs. Consoles have never been generative devices. They are appliances.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by vacri on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @04:22PM (#3296960)
Games consoles don't pretend to be anything other than games consoles. They don't try to make it sound like you should service all your computer needs with one.

At least, I've never seen even the faintest hint of a games console implying it could be used to email the boss a copy of the spreadsheet you created on it.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by onemoreact on Thursday December 01, 2011 @10:49AM (#3300116)
Originally the PS3 was advertised as being able to run LINUX on so you can create a spreadsheet on a PS3 and email it to your boss. HDMI = 1920 x 1080 resolution screen + USB keyboard and Mouse + 60GB HDD and it's better then many office computers of that time period. They also advertised some people that built a cheap super computer, and others used them for blue ray players so they where not targeting just the gaming market.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by slowpoke on Thursday December 01, 2011 @06:18PM (#3301888)
Well, and Sony got their deserved payback when they pulled that feature for no valid reason whatsoever.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by bad_user on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:35PM (#3296788)
People mention 'game consoles' a lot, as if that's a good thing.

However, the best games have always been running on PCs first, often with exclusivity. Starcraft, The Sims, World of Warcraft, Half Life, Counter Strike, SimCity, Quake, Diablo 1 & 2 and the list can go on.

I own a Wii as it came free with my Internet subscription. It's gathering dust since last year. The games are simply not addictive. And this feeling I had on PS 2 too - the games feel too dumb and non-engaging, lacking taste. Which is why I never bothered.

Some people like these games consoles. I never did.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by lloeki on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @04:23PM (#3296961)
> However, the best games have always been running on PCs first, often with exclusivity. [list]

Confirmation bias. See Mario, Contra, Chrono Trigger, Sonic, Final Fantasy, Resident Evil, Halo, Alan Wake, Uncharted, Metroid, Heavy Rain, Sega Rally, Gran Turismo, Tekken, Street Fighter, Soul Edge, Forza Motorsport and the list can go on.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by rbanffy on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:32PM (#3296486)
Until a judge orders Apple to blacklist or redirect a list of domains for any legal reason. Yesterday it was because of counterfeit purses. Tomorrow it could be about national security.

We shouldn't make it easy.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by bmohlenhoff on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @04:26PM (#3296972)
Once a federal judge tells you to do something, you pretty much have to do it, no matter who you are.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by pyre on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @05:05PM (#3297112)
The point is that without a gatekeeper, who does that judge order around?
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by astine on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:27PM (#3296458)
The author addresses that as well. By making a change to the only permissible browser on iOS and Apple could block sites they don't like as well. It's fortunate that they don't currently do this but we shouldn't let them get into a position where they can.

edit: grammar, attitude.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by yannickt on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:51PM (#3296244)
True, but if people spend more time in apps than browsing the web, then web apps might be harder to monetize than native apps on mobile devices.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by dextorious on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:22PM (#3296432)
And god forbid if we let users spend more time to the kind of apps they love, instead of forcing them to use the web so we can monetize it better...
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by sliverstorm on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:27PM (#3296456)
Well, I have read some pretty convincing articles discussing the walled garden effect, and I have concluded that inevitably Apple's walls will either come down or they will move to greener (read: more wall-able) pastures. It is only a matter of time, so I do not worry.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by timwiseman on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:23PM (#3296092)
Well said. Now admittedly the people I know tend to be on the "computer oriented" side, so there is a sampling bias, but I have yet to meet anyone that chose to have a tablet instead of a PC.

I know a lot of people that have a tablet in addition to their PC, but that hardly makes the PC dead for them.

When tablets become much more powerful and able to integrate seemlessly with things like additional large monitors, keyboards, and mouses (or whatever eventually really replaces keyboards and mouses) then the PC will likely become a niche product, but then tablets will also have become hard to distinguish from a PC with an added ability to undock one monitor to take it with you.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by bad_user on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:35PM (#3296493)
My wife is not technically inclined. She uses a netbook instead with Windows on it.

I just don't get all this tablet love - I can make my laptop sit on my lap without stressing my hands. The display is big enough that I can do whatever I want on it, like when watching movies, the bigger, the better. I can type ~ 100 WPM on it. I can save a file on my desktop from one app and then open it from another (basic functionality that's just fucked up on the iPad).

The iPhone or the competing Android phones ARE GAME CHANGERS. But the big difference between an iPhone and a tablet is that an iPhone sits in your pocket and goes with you everywhere, even when you're at your local grocery store, buying some milk, even when you're inside a public toilet. A phone is always with you. That's progress.

But a Tablet? It's just a cool-looking but dumb device. It has potential, true. But not until it can do all of the things a laptop can.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by orev on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @02:58PM (#3296596)
I am an extremely technical user (15 yrs Linux admin) and I have both a netbook and an iPad. As soon as I got the iPad I stopped using the netbook. The experience on the iPad is far FAR superior as a consumption device than a netbook. If you are trying to use the tablet for the same things as your laptop, you're using it wrong. It sounds like you don't have a tablet, so you really don't have the credibility to weigh in on it.

Also, I would suspect that your wife would highly prefer a tablet if given the chance to try it out. The netbook experience is truly horrible -- she just might not know that something better is out there.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by bad_user on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:05PM (#3296634)
Consider how she likes playing all the crappy Flash-enabled games she gets her hands on from Facebook, or how she depends on Microsoft Office for work related stuff, I beg to differ.

The netbook experience is indeed horrible, however you can attach a real mouse, a real keyboard and a real monitor to it, or a combination of those, any time you want.

My colleague has an iPad. He doesn't use it. It just sits there on his desk. I played with it and it has potential because of the touch-screen. However, as long as it is a dumbed-down device, it's not useful enough to bother.

Of course, time will prove me wrong if I am.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by gujk on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @11:34PM (#3298346)
You can attach a keyboard and mouse and display to a tablet.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by timwiseman on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:37PM (#3296793)
I have an upper end desktop, a cheap netbook and android phone, a PS3, and a kindle. My family has a shared Ipad and my wife as a reasonably powerful laptop I can borrow sometimes. I use all the others to supplement the desktop, but even together they couldn't replace it.

My desktop is the focus of my digital world. I use it for my programming, for writing papers at school as well as for gaming and media consumption when I am at the house. It does things like run multiple VMs and compile code in a reasonable time that none of the others manage. With its dual monitors and easy ability to handle numerous programs at once, I find it tops the others even for tasks like e-mail and web browsing that the Ipad does handle well. All of those others combined cannot replace what I do with my desktop. Even with her fairly high-end laptop and access to the other tools, my wife often borrows my desktop when she is doing serious writing for her PHD.

The others supplement my desktop for niche tasks. I take my netbook to class to take notes and it is good enough for light programming/paper writing and writing when I am on a trip (and I consider it a small PC, not a PC competitor. Also, I find the netbook quite nice for its good-enough travel computer and in-class-note-taking.). My smartphone is a game changer since it is always with me. The kindle is by far the best device for reading and I now prefer it over physical.

The Ipad though? It mostly has games for the kids since it is simple enough for even my 3 year old to use. I sometimes take it with me to places like the airport or DMV where breaking out my netbook would be a touch awkward and it has a pretty good Go program on it.

In short, I think for people doing serious content creation or serious gaming the PC will live on for the forseeable future.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by jsight on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:04PM (#3296630)
I don't believe that I've seen netbooks with the battery life of tablets. That is (to me) a killer feature.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by cageface on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @06:44PM (#3297450)
Both Apple and Microsoft seem likely to support ARM-based hardware soon so laptops are likely to close the gap here.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by gujk on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @11:33PM (#3298340)
You are overlooking the 50%+ of people who are not mentally competent to handle a modern PC. People who haven't upgraded their Windows to SP1 because they don't want to mess with it, who dedicate 60% of their CPU time and screen real estate to malware, who think Skype keeps uninstalling because they haven't pinned it to the taskbar/dock and the icon vanished after they quit the app.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by freehunter on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:39PM (#3296802)
Use the right tablet. You can't expect to buy a PC then complain that you can't run a MacOS application on it, that would mean you bought the wrong machine.

You need Flash? Various Android devices and the Touchpad both have Flash. You need the screen to face you? Every tablet has a stand you can use. Personally I cross my legs then tuck my tablet behind my knee. You need to type quickly? Almost every real tablet has bluetooth where you can pair a keyboard.

If you need something the iPad doesn't offer, then stop using an iPad and actually find a tablet that offers the functionality you need. They exist. If you need something that no tablet offers, then buy a laptop and stop bitching. Motorcycles coexist with pickup trucks because they're built for different needs.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by jseliger on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:52PM (#3296251)
In addition, I suspect most of the people buying mobile devices still have a PC and will for the foreseeable future—because their PCs and laptops are cheap, as I discuss in detail here: http://jseliger.com/2011/10/09/desktop-pcs-arent-going-anywh... . It's not going to be "or"; it's going to be "and."
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by pvarangot on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:47PM (#3296224)

  > Does anyone truly believe that scores of software
  > developers writing financial software for banks are
  > going to trade in their PC to type on an iOS device?
  > Don't bet money on that (at least for the short-term).
Not to mention most professional cases of photo/video/sound editing, and graphic design for magazines or billboards. Sometimes a laptop screen size is truly an impediment. Fast hard disks also help in this tasks.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by interknot on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:04PM (#3295997)
I mostly agree with you, though I'm concerned that the economies of scale that make PC-style computing affordable will become unsustainable.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by BrainInAJar on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:18PM (#3296712)
" Does anyone truly believe that scores of software developers writing financial software for banks are going to trade in their PC to type on an iOS device? Don't bet money on that (at least for the short-term). "

iPad, wireless keyboard & SSH and I can do all my work more or less the same way I do now

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by freehunter on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @03:33PM (#3296777)
I actually do this right now, but without SSH. I recently started writing my code on an HP Touchpad with a bluetooth keyboard. It started to get difficult to sync my work across multiple computers, especially when there was no network present at a place I wish I could work from. I got a Touchpad, installed Ubuntu on it, and now I can have my entire development studio and all my code wherever I go without needing to worry about getting to my Git repository.

There are times when I cannot test my code on the tablet, but at the very least I can write it wherever then push it back to Git and pull it to my test machine when I get back.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by kevinherron on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @12:46PM (#3295922)
This is exactly what I came here to say. I think there will be a continuous widening of the gap between devices meant for producing and devices meant for consuming. The two can't exist without each other, however, so there's no reason to worry.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by swah on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @12:52PM (#3295943)
But devices for producing only became affordable because they were also for consuming.
Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by LarryMade on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @06:19PM (#3297357)
which several decades previous that was the case for microcomputers...

While now it is a given concept that there will be a consumer level device, but sooner or later a new generation of home-based hackers will work up some new ways to be productive within these walled gardens, those will be exploited into apps and companies will be doing business on them - and then it will have started all over again.

I wouldn't consider it an end but part of a progression.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by recoiledsnake on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @01:47PM (#3296222)
Not just that but also the fact that the devices used for producing are much less likely to be bought in homes if they already have a consumption device.

In the post-PC world, a home(especially in low income homes and the developing world) having iPads are much less likely to have Windows or Mac machines (on which an enterprising kid might install and play with Eclipse, Visual Studio Express or XCode, or even Linux).

This effect will be further amplified when the PC prices rise to lower demand.

Re:The PC is dead. Why no angry nerds? by neutronicus on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @06:17PM (#3297349)
You also can't really get through college with just an iPad. Apparently students are trying, and grousing when they realize that the kinds of software your classes demand that you run doesn't run on the iPad. I'm guessing that the world of academic software will blink second.