News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Friday September 23, 2022 @06:42PM (#32957952)
Is this an engineering challenge or a marksmanship challenge?

Like... Could you just fire the gun, then put the target where the bullet went an fire again and say its mission accomplished because the real goal is just setting up a gun that stable and precise and deterministic?

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by Enginerrrd on Friday September 23, 2022 @06:47PM (#32957993)
Both, combined with quite a bit of luck.

>Like... Could you just fire the gun, then put the target where the bullet went an fire again and say its mission accomplished because the real goal is just setting up a gun that stable and precise and deterministic?

No... slight variations in wind and atmospherics across that distance change too rapidly and significantly to make that viable. (Also, you wouldn't need to, you'd just adjust the windage/elevation on the optics and/or fancy rifle mount.)

Also the when the bullet drops from supersonic to subsonic speed, there is a non-deterministic kick that it receives which dramatically reduces accuracy beyond that distance.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by wing-_-nuts on Friday September 23, 2022 @11:47PM (#32959576)
>Also the when the bullet drops from supersonic to subsonic speed, there is a non-deterministic kick that it receives which dramatically reduces accuracy beyond that distance.

Fun fact, while video games typically depict suppressors as slowing bullets down, and lowering range (presumably with subsonic ammo). A lot of rifles are actually have slightly longer range with a suppressor and standard ammo because it allows the powder to burn more completely with a slightly higher muzzle velocity and therefore it takes longer to hit that subsonic transition

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spiderice on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:29PM (#32958678)
> non-deterministic kick

Actually non-deterministic? Or just difficult-to-deterministic? Genuinely curious.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by kadoban on Friday September 23, 2022 @09:16PM (#32958933)
Very likely deterministic if you knew the _exact_ state of both the bullet and the air, but effectively impossible to know and likely not that easy to model correctly even if you did.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by jakear on Friday September 23, 2022 @09:52PM (#32959086)
So nondeterministic in the same way an electron passing through two slits is.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by kragen on Friday September 23, 2022 @11:24PM (#32959480)
As far as we know, quantum nondeterminism is real nondeterminism, not just nondeterministic because you don't know the exact state of both the electron and the slits.

Presumably the Navier–Stokes chaos of turbulent flow will eventually amplify quantum fluctuations (where two molecules do or don't interact) into macroscopically divergent fluid dynamic behavior, but I don't know if the relevant Lyapunov time is short enough to make a bullet's flight quantum nondeterministic.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by cli on Friday September 23, 2022 @11:46PM (#32959575)
I doubt it. The bullet movement may be chaotic, which means that tiny changes in initial conditions will drastically affect the trajectory, but it is theoretically possible to predict the trajectory. However, it is likely that quantum effects such as the movement of an electron through slits is actually non-deterministic, so we can only predict it in a statistical way even in principle.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by kadoban on Friday September 23, 2022 @10:14PM (#32959189)
I think slightly less non-deterministic than that, because there's at least some way you could know, if you were god.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by verandaguy on Friday September 23, 2022 @10:59PM (#32959378)
Non-deterministic in the extreme literal sense. Our (turbulent) atmosphere is chaotic, and the transsonic shock is a fluid dynamics problem happening in that chaotic environment.

Even with a perfectly still atmosphere it'd probably be fairly difficult to predict.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 24, 2022 @12:39AM (#32959787)
> No... slight variations in wind and atmospherics across that distance change too rapidly and significantly to make that viable.

This doesn't sound right. If it's true, then the same thing -- slight variations over time in wind and atmospherics across a seven kilometer span -- would make the aimed shot nonviable too. The shooter isn't adjusting for air movement between himself and the target -- because that can't be done -- so if he's hitting the target reliably, the air movement can't really matter.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by Enginerrrd on Saturday September 24, 2022 @11:33AM (#32963635)
That's not true at all.

Even at 500-700 yards, wind holds can be significant (as in off target). That changes second by second. I can tell you that even as a decent shooter with a better spotter, when the spotter makes a wind call, the slight 1-2 second delay before I can actually press off the shot can be enough where I need to change the hold slightly from what he said to make a good hit.

Over this distance, there will undoubtedly be some fishtail winds and dead spots that are changing on a per second basis. In this case, I'd expect you have a team of spotters reading the mirage at several distances to target, and one lead spotter that is integrating those into the wind call for the shooter.

There's also some new tech that's aimed at this problem actually where instead of getting a wind read at one distance, it measures the wind over the entire distance and gives you a hold based on that. Very fancy stuff, they may have used that in this case.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thatguy0900 on Saturday September 24, 2022 @01:06AM (#32959868)
He's not hitting the target reliably, it took more than 60 tries, and would take just as many to do again
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Saturday September 24, 2022 @08:03AM (#32961726)
But given the precision required, wouldn't it make more sense to aim the gun where it would hit the target given median atmospheric conditions and then just fire with that exact aim until it does? Like you couldn't possibly dynamically aim to accommodate that.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by Enginerrrd on Thursday September 29, 2022 @05:52PM (#33027779)
>Like you couldn't possibly dynamically aim to accommodate that.

Yes, you can.

Not doing so would result in dramatically reduced accuracy.

That's just windage 101.

The horizontal variation due to even slight wind is massive at this distance and would dwarf all other factors. Failing to adjust for this on a per shot basis would result in dramatically reduced accuracy.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Monday October 03, 2022 @09:45AM (#33067413)
Seems to me you would not be able to adapt your aim to the wind to the level of precision required to hit a small target. You would be much better off trying to identify a working shot for an average wind condition and then trying to time your shot to match that condition.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 24, 2022 @01:10AM (#32959880)
What's supposed to be impressive about "I hit a bullseye by coincidence"?
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by bell-cot on Saturday September 24, 2022 @03:12AM (#32960344)
Impressive that they were able to control things well enough that it only took 69 tries. (Vs. 69,000 or so.)

(Yes, statistical "proof" that it wasn't 10,000-to-1 luck would require far more experimental data. With their setup, that wouldn't be quick or cheap to get.)

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 24, 2022 @05:23AM (#32960983)
> Yes, statistical "proof" that it wasn't 10,000-to-1 luck would require far more experimental data. With their setup, that wouldn't be quick or cheap to get.

Saying that this wouldn't be quick or cheap to get is just an admission that you think it was 10,000-to-1 luck. Why wouldn't it be quick?

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by bell-cot on Saturday September 24, 2022 @06:41AM (#32961318)
Read the article more carefully. Their hugely customized "gun" was only capable of 1 shot every 2 or 3 minutes (to limit heating and thermal expansion ). They had 5 spotters near the target, watching where every individual bullet landed. (Then reporting back to the shooter, so he(?) could make little adjustments.) And it sure looks like an amateur group of "extreme" performance enthusiasts - so who would pay for the collection of a large (say, n=25,000) data set? From a quick web search, just the ammunition (.416 Barrett) would cost ~$400,000. The barrel of their extreme-performance "gun" might need replacing a dozen times or more, and...
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Saturday September 24, 2022 @10:31AM (#32962926)
The probability of a 1 in 10000 event occurring in the first 69 attempts by chance is about 0.7%.

The 1 in 10000 probability seems arbitrary and underestimated in my opinion though. What would that even mean? The probability of hitting the target with random aiming or purposeful aiming from a fresh start? The probability of hitting the target with a perfected aim and relying on random variance? The probability of doing it without the engineered gun?

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:32PM (#32958305)
ok wind aside, if that's true, how is it possible to aim it then? It can't possibly be true that you can precisely adjust your aim to hit a specific target if you can't even hit the same target by not changing your aim?
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by msherry on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:36PM (#32958331)
That's why this is such an impressive achievement!
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by hamburglar on Friday September 23, 2022 @09:57PM (#32959104)
It’s also why they succeeded on the 69th try instead of the 2nd.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 24, 2022 @12:41AM (#32959791)
But that means the approach described above works perfectly. Fire the gun. Place a bullseye over the bullet hole. Then keep firing the gun until you hit the bullseye "again".
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by hamburglar on Saturday September 24, 2022 @05:45PM (#32966808)
Well, if you consider that "perfectly," yes, but it could take all day. The ancestor post seemed to be suggesting that if it was so "stable, precise and deterministic" that you could do this trivially in a couple shots.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 24, 2022 @05:49PM (#32966837)
Considering the guy who made the shot commented "we were amazed we got it in so few shots", taking all day is expected anyway.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by adrianpike on Friday September 23, 2022 @06:52PM (#32958019)
Both - the firearm has to be incredibly precise, but you also have to take into account wind and air density to get that much accuracy, and a big portion of marksmanship is accounting for those. Knowing that you'll have a temperature change over a body of water, and how to adjust for that, for example.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Saturday September 24, 2022 @10:34AM (#32962961)
But I can't imagine you're dynamically adjusting each shot for these changing factors every time. You'll almost certainly be holding the aim fixed once you've figured it out to be approximately correct, and firing against natural variance in the variable conditions.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by twothamendment on Saturday September 24, 2022 @10:15AM (#32962793)
Maybe moving the target to the bullet impact would work - walk the shot to the target or the target to the shot? Both still have many other variables - but there is one good reason why they moved the shot instead of the target.

It would be very difficult to find impact points of the misses - The best they could do was listen for where they hit.

Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Saturday September 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#32962861)
But surely that only refers to the first bundle of shots while trying to guess and check where the gun is aiming? If your ability to tell where the last shot landed was so low on the previous shot, your ability to precisely calibrate and hit a small target on the next shot must be zero.
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by steve918 on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:04PM (#32958107)
"The shooter was 4.4 miles away, a distance so great, the Earth’s rotation came into play."
Re:At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record by spywaregorilla on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:33PM (#32958315)
that effect should be constant for the distance and timespan of two shots.