News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by bpodgursky on Thursday September 22, 2022 @07:53AM (#32937607)
Google pulling out of China instead of catering to censorship was a principled move, but fairly obviously did not lead to more freedom of speech in China. It helped kickstart a domestic, government-obedient tech industry.

I don't know what the right move here is. Nobody who thinks there's an obvious right answer is worth listening to.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by shadowgovt on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:14AM (#32937785)
FWIW, Google said they pulled out of China for principled reasons but they did it practically for self-preservation.

Google got hacked by inside actors planted in their physical offices by the Chinese government. It's one of the very few times that Gmail's security was compromised. At the time, Google did not have the security countermeasures in place to protect against such an attack so they responded by severing the physical ties so such an attack could not be repeated. Once the BeyondCorp initiative had completed and they had the technology necessary to firewall pieces of their infrastructure where users had admin rights from other pieces of their infrastructure where users had admin rights, they reopened business in China because the risk model had changed.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by plantain on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:25AM (#32937895)
>Google got hacked by inside actors planted in their physical offices by the Chinese government.

This just isn't true? It was an IE 0-day.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by shadowgovt on Thursday September 22, 2022 @09:00AM (#32938213)
That was one of the tools used. The attackers got access to the Gmail backing store.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by plantain on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:56AM (#32948538)
That's the tool they used to get in, then they went sideways from the corporate network and eventually into Gmail. I was on the team that cleaned it up...
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by shadowgovt on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:59AM (#32950715)
Correct. The issue was that at the time, simple access to the intranet allowed for such turboing of credentials.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by surfpel on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:02AM (#32937676)
Culture moves both ways.

I would rather American companies not get so comfortable with blatant censorship. While we do still have some degree of censorship (and a whole lot pf privacy violation), it’s still generally seen as a taboo and not as a moral or necessary thing.

Once the social standards change however, the goalpost moves and it becomes harder to maintain the same freedoms we had before.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by criley2 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:08AM (#32937728)
I would rather the American people elect a government that will protect their rights through laws.

Meta will not violate American law. As citizens, our most effective tool is our government of the people.

The idea that we rely on culture or corporate benevolence to maintain our freedoms, and not our representatives and laws... it's insane, to the say the least. I'd prefer to elect the people to protect my freedoms, not hope a for-profit advertising company will do so automatically.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by surfpel on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:38AM (#32938017)
You've given platitudes with an overall misunderstanding of both the parent comment as well as a the functioning of the real world.

> I would rather the American people elect a government that will protect their rights through laws.

I would also like a world where problems don't exist, but that doesn't change the real world. It's a naive take. The world is complicated.

> Meta will not violate American law.

This is both demonstrably false and borderline meaningless.

False because they have and will, unless you're suggesting Meta/Facebook has NEVER broken a law. It's just a question of whether they got charged/sued for it.

It's meaningless because laws can be highly interpretable, unenforceable, impractical... and the playing field is constantly changing, so there's always a new opportunity for new types of violations.

That isn't to say laws are meaningless, obviously they are extremely necessary and must be enforced, but the public response to those ambiguous situations is what would help determine the next set of laws/norms.

> The idea that we rely on culture or corporate benevolence to maintain our freedoms...

Parent comment doesn't suggest this. "Corporate culture" has little to do with it. American culture is what would change, has changed, and is changing. When the tooling is developed to carry out efficient, sweeping censorship, it will be used. With more use, we become more comfortable with it and even see it as a necessary evil. Currently there is public outrage when a tech company censors information. How long will this remain interesting enough to draw our attention? TSA in airports after 9/11 is a good example of this.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by criley2 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:06AM (#32938918)
What an absurd, condescending and pointless reply.

Example:

>> I would rather the American people elect a government that will protect their rights through laws.

>I would also like a world where problems don't exist, but that doesn't change the real world. It's a naive take. The world is complicated.

What in the hell kind of reply is this? How dare you. (On the day that the EU fined Google 4 billion Euros, largest in history, demonstrating laws and governments of people, no less). Your nonsensically dismissive reply is immature and entirely unfit for this community. Take this tripe back to reddit.

Shame on you for how you behaved here.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by surfpel on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:16AM (#32940051)
I want to fully reply to this but there is too much to dismantle and it would be unenlightening to do so.

All I will say is that in being offended by a rather benign comment, you have yourself committed what you accuse me of.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by criley2 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:37AM (#32940425)
I have no interest in any further communication with a child, please find another thread to troll.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by wahnfrieden on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:17AM (#32937818)
It’s also viable to fight for neither capital or state dominance. You have a lot of confidence in the rule of law applying to power and liberal society
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by peyton on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:28AM (#32937922)
Yeah, wow, laws aren’t code that runs on people instead of silicon.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by ideamotor on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:41AM (#32938039)
Important point. To reiterate, the culture of companies change.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by surfpel on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:55AM (#32938165)
Culture in general changes. A company is not an island. Employees move around, tech moves around. Society at large gets comfortable with censorship when its use spreads.

We're all looking for ways to censor spammers or belligerents from internet forums. It could easily start there and spread to other areas.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by zmgsabst on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:14AM (#32939034)
That already happened, eg, COVID policies on social media and YouTube.

We had a breakdown in our consensus mechanism — because the government partnered with corporations to censor rather than allow public debate.

The nation is still bitterly divided.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by norwalkbear on Thursday September 22, 2022 @05:49PM (#32945061)
America is divided more than, Iran maybe a glimpse into our immediate future.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by bpodgursky on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:08AM (#32937725)
Should American companies pull out of Germany instead of banning Nazi propaganda? The UK instead of removing court-ordered offensive speech?

I mean, maybe, but since the US has the least-restricted speech of basically any nation, you are de-facto asking for a nationally partitioned internet. That's a big change.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by 988747 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:14AM (#32937786)
The problem is: if you want to ban Nazi propaganda you have to develop tools to do it. Once you have tools in place you can use it to ban anything you do not like, not just Nazi propaganda.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by pjc50 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @09:26AM (#32938476)
You also have to develop tools to block spam, child porn, and (in practice on almost all social networks) legal porn that there is nevertheless considerable censorious pressure on.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by fragmede on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:10PM (#32941769)
Or just copyrighted material. Try posting the new Disney movie or streaming the latest UFC fight for free and see what happens. The tools for censorship are there, they just don't count if it's to protect a corporation's assets, for some reason.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by surfpel on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:17AM (#32937820)
Precisely. This is what it means for a company to get 'comfortable' with something. It means that given enough demand they have developed the tools necessary to do that aforementioned thing and those tools now can become accessible to any jurisdiction, even those who didn't ask for it.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by olddustytrail on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:58AM (#32940780)
> Should American companies pull out of Germany instead of banning Nazi propaganda?

That would be a little ironic since it was the US who pushed for such laws in post-war Germany in the first place.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by snehk on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:20AM (#32937849)
> It helped kickstart a domestic, government-obedient tech industry.

How long do you think US companies could operate in the US if they weren't government-obedient? Or any company in any country for that matter.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by _jal on Thursday September 22, 2022 @09:22AM (#32938426)
If you want to call Google's act "principled", you need to explain Project Dragonfly.

It is and always has been the intersection of realpolitik and greed.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by Bakary on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:16AM (#32937797)
Those are two very bold claims: that Google pulled out of China for purely ideological reasons, and that the Chinese tech industry would have otherwise failed if they had stayed. We are dealing with hypotheticals here, so it's not like we can back up our propositions with actual evidence. But both ideas just seem deeply unlikely based on what we know of both Google and Chinese tech.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by njdvndsjkvn on Thursday September 22, 2022 @09:36AM (#32938576)
not sure why this is downvoted. Chinese companies can definitely make their own search engine. And in fact search engines are not so big in china anyway; everything is an app, and questions are answered on Zhihu. Google's time in China was up anyway and they knew it. It was good PR for them to leave with a bang. Does anyone really thing the CCP would allow Google to collect data on every Chinese person as they do in the US? And without data collection ads become much less profitable (see: facebook). This would also set a precedent of barring Google from data collection which would spread elsewhere. Now its just seen as a domestic Chinese thing only.
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by desindol on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:02AM (#32937674)
It's a bit of a pickle if someone really finds the right answer and you don't listen to it isn't it?
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by bpodgursky on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:06AM (#32937705)
I have no problem with people talking through the tradeoffs and listening. There's tautologically a least-worst option we should find.

But if the answer is trite snark that summarizes evil vs obvious good, they haven't done that work, and I won't listen, no.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by anvic on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:09AM (#32937734)
The right move is letting countries govern themselves in whatever way they see fit and leaving them alone.

Or would you like to have Iran or Pakistan or whatever intervening in the domestic issues of the West?

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by howaboutnope on Thursday September 22, 2022 @08:40AM (#32938031)
This includes not wanting to support or do business with people who look the other way as people get slaughtered. I'm not in Iran, I'm dealing solely with things that enter my ken and therefore become subject to my judgement.

I can't go to a museum, admire the bravery of, say, Sophie Scholl, and then go "ah yes, but at the end of the day it's not really anyone's business", and you cannot both have the dignity of a person who accepts the responsibility they have just by virtue of being human and shut yourself off.

At the end of the day, it's just a rationalization for kicking away the ladder. You don't care what happens to them as long as it doesn't happen to you or people you love. That is what it is, and all it is.

Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by norwalkbear on Thursday September 22, 2022 @05:52PM (#32945099)
People really do think their nations culture should be imposed everywhere. In reality it doesn't work. See Americas bitter defeat in Afghanistan. Which is now more Islamic and antiwestern than it's ever been
Re:As unrest grows, Iran restricts access to Instagram, What... by bpodgursky on Thursday September 22, 2022 @07:25PM (#32945945)
> more Islamic and antiwestern

It's a massive regression from 2002 - 2021, but this is not true. The Taliban has moderated somewhat from 2000 (somewhat), and frankly would be very happy to make tactical deals with the west to help counter ISIS.