this player was at the top of the matchmaking ladder
that (very small) population had a lot of people who wanted to avoid him
he couldn’t get games at his current level, and he couldn’t rise above that level, because there was nothing above that level
Which is a normal part of a competitive multiplayer game, except that people got the option to avoid him (rather than learn to beat him), so many took it!
Like I said I don't care if matchmaking takes longer (usually it's only ~30 sec). The pool of players is utterly massive, and ranking one player down a bit would make a trivial difference.
Yeah, I could wait a couple minutes and not queue up. But that's making it my problem that I had to deal with a toxic/abusive player. I already did my part and reported them, but now I also have to just not play the game for a while to make sure I don't get matched again? Indeed, my suggested solution of lowering their matchmaking "matchability" to me would benefit the community. Not to mention, the effect could be nullified if I am spamming unfounded reports against players constantly.
I kind of just assume that a competitive multiplayer game under active development for the past 15 years would have functionality like I've mentioned above. Maybe it does, and it just hasn't worked well to prevent me from matching up with toxic players multiple games in a row.
Inter-user features are always delicate to balance when it comes to competitive games.
Even for an average player, adding an avoid player feature would ultimately make matchmaking take longer. It necessarily reduces the number of valid matchings of players, so the system will only be slower. My guess is that average queue time is an important metric that management does not want to increase. It’s an especially tough sell because if you really wanted fresh players in your game, you could always not queue for a few minutes and you will almost certainly get all-new teammates.