News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intelligence and radical economic attitudes by somenameforme on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:56PM (#32916242)
There is one issue with your argument here, an increasingly relevant one in contemporary times. You are implying that since one choice can be shown to be provably bad, it must therefore be the case that another is better by default.

But this assumes that there are good choices, and that there are bad choices. Reality, unfortunately, is often not so kind, and instead leaves us to choose only between bad choices and horrible ones. And so emphasizing the flaws of one choice, says very little about the desirability of an alternative.

In some ways I think game theory is most appropriate for chaotic systems. The goal is not to pick the system that works the best, under some ideal set of criteria, but the one that works the least-worst under the most hostile set of criteria.

Re:Intelligence and radical economic attitudes by aeternum on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @03:56PM (#32916947)
It doesn't need to be a purely free market. I'm very much a proponent of free markets but there's also a need for some amount of thoughtful regulation.

Allowing market participants to discharge toxins into the local water supply is not in society's interests but is quite possible in a purely free-market system.

There's now a good amount of evidence that a hybrid system: mostly free-market, with some regulation, and some kind of social safety net is the least-bad choice.

Re:Intelligence and radical economic attitudes by WalterBright on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @05:33PM (#32918098)
> Allowing market participants to discharge toxins into the local water supply is not in society's interests but is quite possible in a purely free-market system.

A pure free market system would not allow people to pollute other peoples' property.

Re:Intelligence and radical economic attitudes by AlexandrB on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @08:09AM (#32923864)
How do you define property rights for air and water? If I own a section of a stream and I dump my garbage into it, am I polluting my property or another's property? What if the consequences were unforeseen (as is often the case with groundwater contamination)?

Edit: moreover how is "the free market" going to defend the property rights of others in these cases? I assume via civil litigation. But what if my victims can't afford prolonged litigation or I decide that the potential cost of a settlement is less than the cost of disposing of pollutants properly?

Re:Intelligence and radical economic attitudes by WalterBright on Wednesday September 21, 2022 @02:18PM (#32929057)
> If I own a section of a stream and I dump my garbage into it, am I polluting my property or another's property?

You're polluting other peoples' property.

> how is "the free market" going to defend the property rights of others in these cases?

That's the proper role of government.

> But what if my victims can't afford prolonged litigation or I decide that the potential cost of a settlement is less than the cost of disposing of pollutants properly?

Such issues are true of any economic system I can think of.