News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by ParksNet on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:47PM (#32915230)
Why use voting machines at all? Just stick to pen and paper.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by fabian2k on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:52PM (#32915310)
They are an entirely unnecessary risk. There are plenty of countries that manage to count elections a lot faster than the US while using only pen and paper. It provides a lot more transparency as observers can actually follow every single step of the entire process and verify everything. A voting machine is a big black box that you have to trust (unless they also have a paper trail, and you actually verify it).
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by retrac on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:01PM (#32915476)
> It provides a lot more transparency as observers can actually follow every single step of the entire process and verify everything.

Simple folk physics gives everyone an understanding of the security of ballot boxes. There's thousands of ballot boxes, each in a different physically-secured location, with various personnel keeping track of them, many of them citizen volunteers and workers, as well as partisan observers. Everyone intuitively understands the security, as well as security flaws, of this system.

All of that is lost with electronic voting. Even with complete confidence/faith in the system, it simply becomes a black box. Press button and the vote total is spit out. Only a few experts understand the system in a way that they could explain how that total was arrived at and why you should have confidence in it. And even fewer would be able to actually verify that the black box does what it says it does and that you should by confident in it. Otherwise it's just a box that spits out a number. And computers make up numbers all the time.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by r00fus on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:55PM (#32915347)
The HAVA [1] legislation was extremely misguided and IMHO designed to create an industry where none was needed to line even more rich pockets.

Ostensibly it was done to support disabled (blind) folks to vote without anyone else seeing their ballot, but has introduced a massive potential for fraud (lack of paper ballots originally) and distrust (can you verify your vote?) in the process. MAGA just took that distrust and weaponized it.

[1] https://www.eac.gov/about_the_eac/help_america_vote_act.aspx

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by einherjae on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:49PM (#32915252)
Misled techno-optimism mostly. A lot easier to secure a pen and paper election, but also a bit slower to count.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by dsr_ on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:56PM (#32915365)
Massachusetts uses hand-marked printed paper forms that are fed into an optical-scanner, with the paper dropping into a lockbox for auditability. The paper is the vote, the scanner just allows you to count faster.

If you're blind or otherwise need assistance marking your form, you can bring along a person of your choosing or you can ask for two officials to help you out.

If you need accessibility and online voting, you're hosed: there's a system and it sucks.

Overall, there's room for improvement but it's better than all of the electronic-first systems.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by elliekelly on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:25PM (#32915856)
For anyone who might need to know: in the US you have an affirmative right under federal law to have someone of your choosing (although IIRC you may not choose your boss/employer) accompany you into the voting booth in order to assist you in casting your ballot. And assistance isn’t limited to people who are blind or have a disability that prevents them from being able to mark a ballot. If you struggle to read or if you struggle to understand how to fill out the ballot you have a right to get assistance.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by duxup on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:57PM (#32915406)
Minnesota uses the scanning ballots too.

Very handy, ballots are tied to each machine for random validation and etc.

I like that system, best of both worlds.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by postalrat on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:51PM (#32915288)
Here we have pen and paper and scanners. To vote you fill in the ballot with pen then stick it in the scanner on way out.

As long as they aren't stuffing more ballots or modifying existing ones it should be easy to do a recount at any time.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by dsr_ on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:58PM (#32915416)
Stuffing should be hard: you get checked off (name and address) when you receive your ballot, and again when you deposit your ballot. Vote totals need to match in both those places and the ballot box.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by MichaelCollins on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:52PM (#32915309)
I think it's not just techno-optimism. Profit motivated media wants faster results to keep people excited on the edge of their seat, eyeballs glued to the advertisements.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by soulofmischief on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:56PM (#32915384)
Anything less than an open source machine with a cryptographically secured, auditable trail from my vote to the final tally is 100% untrustworthy.

There is no reason for an American citizen today to trust the security of pen and paper elections. There never was, but now we have digital tooling.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by mikepurvis on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:52PM (#32915314)
The best of both worlds is hand-marked paper ballots that are then counted by machine.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by brendoelfrendo on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:57PM (#32915409)
There's no reason to need the "best of both worlds." People will doubt the validity of the electronic count anyway, you might as well skip that step and go straight to a hand count.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by einherjae on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:51PM (#32916185)
The more counts the better, let a machine count first to give quick results, but use multiple machines and software solutions, kept fully airgaped. Then count by hand.

A tiny horror story from the last Norwegian election was when some results were delayed due to problems with a scanner. The news story about that machine mentioned that the machine was connected to the internet (shudder), and ran Win XP (facepalm).

The internet should only be used for reporting preliminary numbers, and the counting machines should not be talking directly to the net at all.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by yardie on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:55PM (#32915341)
Not sure about your state but mine uses paper scantron with a scanner/lockbox. If there is a dispute/recount they verify the paper record against the digital record. The results at each poll site are ready 30-60 minutes after polls close. Rarely, if the results aren't ready by 9pm its usually because a long line at 7pm at that polling station.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by elliekelly on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:53PM (#32915327)
You must be too young to remember the 2000 election. Butterfly ballots. Hanging chads. The threshold level of “filled” a Scantron circle must be to qualify as “a vote” vs merely an errant mark.

When one side is determined to scrutinize a large-scale process until it falls apart the process will inevitably breakdown.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by preinheimer on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:17PM (#32915745)
Some possible advantages of voting machines:

- They can provide different accessibility assistance than pen and paper, allowing people to vote on their own. Multi-language support should be easy.

- They can provide UI improvements over paper. Consider situations where the voter needs to select up to 3 candidates out of a list of 12. Or a long ballot with lots of distinct questions.

- Hopefully less lead time for updates to the ballot if someone drops out of the race, is replaced, etc.

The past few times I've voted (Canada) it's been pencil on paper, stuck into a machine that confirmed it could read the ballot, then I left. When it's been a longer ballot for municipal election it's actually felt like a bit of a test. We are voting for: city councillor, mayor, regional representatives, multiple school board trustees from one of two different school boards (but not both).

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by asdff on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:22PM (#32915801)
OTOH you can get a paper ballot in any language an electronic ballot is served, and the UI is the same "fill in the bubble by the name" only its a virtual bubble you tap to fill. Disability wise it seems worse. You need to have access to some way to get to the polling site, the polling site has to be accessible itself for you, you need to be able to read the screen well and have a good finger to touch the buttons. Meanwhile if you are very disabled, you get a paper ballot mailed to you wherever you live, and your nurse/friend/pastor/whoever can help you fill out the ballot and sign off as having helped you fill it out.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by jimbob45 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:59PM (#32915440)
There's one very clear answer as to why we still use electronic voting machines: money[0]. States have to fund their own elections and machines are cheap. When you're choosing between a funding shortfall for schools, firehouses, or elections, it's really no surprise that the elections don't come out the winner.

[0] https://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/electi...

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by mburee on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:50PM (#32915272)
There's a small but significant advantage to some partys when using voting machines, just with touch screen being more likely to malfunction in humid/hot weather, which really is only an issue in poor districts lacking AC.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by citilife on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:56PM (#32915371)
> Why use voting machines at all?

IMO, for the same reason people are concerned about them...

France handles elections via paper and pen and has everything counted within 24 hrs. Somehow the U.S. had trouble even doing it in a week last election.

Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by cwmma on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:02PM (#32915503)
the reason it took a while was mainly absentee ballots
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by richieb on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:52PM (#32915315)
Machines are mostly used to count votes. Ballots are still on paper.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by anecdotal1 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:57PM (#32915400)
Not every state has a paper trail for ballots. It should be required by law, but it's not.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by pavon on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:03PM (#32915513)
That isn't universally true. Many counties in the US have used or still use touchscreen machines with no paper ballot.
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by themitigating on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @11:55PM (#32920683)
People got upset that they were still counting at night or the count changed the next day. How would this help?
Re:Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access'... by howinteresting on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:58PM (#32915433)
It is important to present results as quickly as possible to prevent the sorts of fuckery Trump did. So voting machines with a paper trail and risk-limiting audits (basically randomized audits—the closer the result is the bigger the sample) are ideal