News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by cj on Sunday September 18, 2022 @07:23PM (#32892417)
There's a hidden setting when configuring geo on campaigns.

By default it's set to "People -interested- in your target location" . You need to change it to "People who are -in- your target location".

This setting is hidden under a toggle, so it's very easy to miss. Definitely a dark pattern and results in a lot of garbage clicks if you overlook that setting.

This is just one of many dark patterns which makes Google Ads effective only for people willing to spend the time tuning and tweaking every single setting.

A big part of the problem is Google themselves - they say always use "broad" keyword matches (and of course it's the default). Broad matches are really not good for most campaigns unless you have an extremely large budget, yet if you read their documentation they heavily encourage it.

While we're at it...

1) Never enable the "auto apply recommendations" setting. If you do, it gives Google free reign to modify your campaigns (this has always resulted in worse performance and more spend in my experience)

2) Never listen to a google ads rep if they call. Once you're spending enough, they'll call you every week trying to convince you to change various settings. 95% of the time their advice is just plain bad. The quality of the advice does increase once you're spending enough and get assigned more senior reps. But even the senior reps are there to get you to spend more money, their job is not to make your campaigns more effective, "ad specialists" are simply sales people in disguise.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by geomark on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:59AM (#32894436)
"Never listen to a google ads rep if they call."

Excellent advice. I was helping manage an Adwords campaign for an online shop, only had search ads turned on, was carefully watching and tweaking ads and managed to get a pretty decent CTR which had a big impact on cost per click.

I was in a different time zone (15 hours ahead) than the company. I went to bed one night and next morning I checked and found that our CTR had gone through the floor, was way less than 1%. And as a result our cost per click had sky rocketed from 10 to 15 cents to several dollars.

Turns out that a Google ads rep had called the office and convinced someone to turn on display ads, which killed our CTR. Our advertising budget was depleted, our Adwords account had received the dreaded low CTR slap which meant it would be very costly/impossible to get CTR back to a reasonable level. We were done with Adwords.

Things may have changed since then. It was years ago and I haven't touched Adwords since.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by andyferris on Monday September 19, 2022 @01:24AM (#32894569)
> which meant it would be very costly/impossible to get CTR back to a reasonable level

Sorry - is there some kind of hysteresis? You can't revert the setting and get back to exactly where you started?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by geomark on Monday September 19, 2022 @01:46AM (#32894689)
Once you have thousands of ad impressions with very few clicks, it takes thousands of new impressions at a very high CTR to get your overall account's CTR back to something reasonable. And now that your cost per click has skyrocketed, even if you can get a high CTR for the new impressions your cost has skyrocketed.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by WastingMyTime89 on Monday September 19, 2022 @02:47AM (#32895079)
That’s a sampling bias. You are confusing how your metrics are affected by the adverse event with how your metrics are now.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by geomark on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:24AM (#32895706)
No confusion. I've been through this with several accounts I helped manage. Once an account has a history of low CTR the CPC goes up. Starting a new campaign doesn't help; the CPC stays high until you can get the CTR back up. And that costs dearly.

But again, that was years ago. Things may have changed.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by gunapologist99 on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:49PM (#32903014)
Unfortunately, things have not changed. You are 100% correct. If anything, things have gotten worse, because now we have even fewer options to manage accounts.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by SiempreViernes on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:57AM (#32896677)
So there's no way to set over which period the metrics are calculated?

Or is it a thing where the client only cares about the default metrics calculated over the full history of an account?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by sokoloff on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:41AM (#32897554)
It’s on Google’s end. “I have inventory (a placement) to sell to an advertiser. I can sell it to X with a CTR of (10% or 1%) and a CPC of $0.50 or to Y with a CTR of 3% and a CPC of $1.”

Whether X’s CTR is 10% (what it used to be) or 1% (what it is now) drives the decision of which ad is better to serve in that inventory slot.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by jpadkins on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:58AM (#32898372)
There are some misconceptions here (i.e. display CTR effects search ads quality score)

Here are some direct from the source help pages that might clear up your understanding of the system. https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/156066 https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6167118

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by gunapologist99 on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:51PM (#32903046)
The GP does not appear to have any misconceptions.

From your first link, "how relevant your ad text is to searches, how likely people are to click your ad, and the quality of their experience once they reach your landing page"

This is all data that's generated based on the overall learning that Adwords does against your site presence. It's why it takes weeks to really get your data settled in, and why if you (or your Google rep) start to mismanage your account, things will rapidly go bad.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by jpadkins on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:49PM (#32916163)
The GP story was based on the premise that opting a campaign into the display network increased CPC on search ad clicks. I know for a fact that it is not possible. I am not at liberty to go through each issue the GP had, so I linked to the best source of truth on this subject.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by geomark on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @08:59PM (#32919764)
The effect of lowered account-wide CTR on CPC is something that has been experienced by a lot of people who have run Adwords campaigns. I saw it discussed a lot on forums about affiliate marketing. They always said, whatever you do, avoid the "account slap" that comes if your CTR plummets. I saw it myself on more than one account.

Maybe it isn't causal? But the correlation is pretty near 100%.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by justinbaker84 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @07:43PM (#32892531)
These are excellent tips. I have been managing Google Ads full time for about 12 years and I run a small agency. I can confirm he is right about all of this.

The challenging thing about this advice is that for most people it feels unnatural to do the opposite of what Google recommends. Usually people need to get ripped off a few times before they accept that fact that Google is no longer a good actor.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by propogandist on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:56PM (#32893769)
Google's reps routinely "take care" of big agency staff and show them a good time while feeding them the same "spend optimization" suggestions.

The agency staff can then claim the campaigns were optimized based on Google's suggestions, which is the perfect smokescreen.

Most big brands that outsource media buying don't have SMEs to audit the media buying they've outsourced, so the result is Google makes a ton of money via their preferred middleman, advertising agencies.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by justinbaker84 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:52PM (#32894101)
You are absolutely right. I worked at a big agency where I managed a team that ran the search ads for a fortune 500 tech company. That was usually how it worked. I tried to communicate up the chain that the dinners and outings on Google's dime are a clear conflict of interest, but nobody wanted to hear it.

By far the most dissapointing thing was that the client often just wanted to go with Google's recomendations or they had even worse ideas. Even when we really tried to look out for the best interests of the client it was like fighting an uphill battle both ways.

Another problem is that anything that isn't direct response is hard to measure so it's tough to make a clear and compelling case. Anybody can chalk up any hare brained idea to brand value and it is tough to push back on that when the client doesn't really care.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by disgruntledphd2 on Monday September 19, 2022 @02:51AM (#32895104)
Like, everyone in the industry shows agency reps a good time. Back a decade ago, FB reps used to get the clients drunk the night before they'd see Google on the principle that they'd remember less.

However it's worth pointing out that Google as an org have absolutely hated ad agencies for many years, in fact being nice to the agencies was a strategy used by FB when I was there.

I'm not disputing your point about optimisations, but the notion that Google like ad agencies is just ludicrous.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by bzmrgonz on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:07PM (#32902517)
I think the problem may be in the "performance compensation" built into their "experts" portfolio.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by Melatonic on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:58PM (#32900915)
Google wants to make more money - of course they may not be giving you the best advice for your company :-)

What I have found works best is to always start playing around with the most restricted type of ads. So restrict by location, test, restrict to the most exact keyword or semi exact (instead of general), do not use common words as much as possible (or quote phrases instead of single words), etc etc.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by kakoni on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:54AM (#32894419)
Wow, thank you for these. And while at it, HN crowd , Any other tips/tricks/settings that would be beneficial for small business owner?
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by fxtentacle on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:54AM (#32896655)
After I got burned with Google and Facebook, I had excellent results with Reddit.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by hashim on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:09AM (#32983299)
You mean advertising on Reddit? What domain are you in?
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by viraptor on Sunday September 18, 2022 @08:53PM (#32893035)
> Definitely a dark pattern and results in a lot of garbage clicks if you overlook that setting.

I really don't get this part. What's Google's interest in pointless clicks? Short term they could get some extra charge for those, but if they don't convert they lose a customer. On the other hand, for quality clicks they could just charge 5x the price and nobody would complain.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by 1024core on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:59PM (#32893790)
> What's Google's interest in pointless clicks? Short term they could get some extra charge for those

Because there are humans in the loop, and "Google" isn't a monolithic all-seeing entity. Sales guys, devs, etc. are rewarded on a quarterly (or yearly) basis, and short-term gains are prioritized over long-term effects ( I mean, how _do_ you measure the fact that, say, after getting 9 months of pointless clicks, the advertiser decided to cut their Adwords budget by 30%?)

So, someone runs an experiment (replace the obvious radio button with a hidden drop-down box, say), the clicks on the advertiser's ads go up, so the experiment increases revenue week-over-week by, say, 3%; and voila, everyone involved gets a pat on the back and a nice phat bonus come the next eval cycle, and maybe a promotion too.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by LaundroMat on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:39AM (#32895431)
> "I mean, how _do_ you measure the fact that, say, after getting 9 months of pointless clicks, the advertiser decided to cut their Adwords budget by 30%?"

Oh man, this is _the_ problem with metrics. We must find a way to measure and demonstrate aversion (instead of conversion).

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by acdha on Sunday September 18, 2022 @09:16PM (#32893164)
> Short term they could get some extra charge for those, but if they don't convert they lose a customer.

They _might_ lose a customer — I suspect that they've determined that enough people either simply don't review their results closely or increase their spending to make it a net profit for them to do this. That would fit with the general pattern of hubris you see in many of their decisions where they've been coasting on their old reputation for at least a decade and don't seem to be fully aware of just how much loyalty they've sacrificed.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by galaxyLogic on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:54AM (#32894417)
Plus they are a near monopoly/duopoly. So if the customer spends for wasted clicks they still get some good clicks as well. Google could optimize it for them better but the customer can not really tell if they could get a better result by some other means.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by pentae on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:32PM (#32893635)
Money. Their interest is Money. They need to offload those garbage clicks that nobody wants to buy to customers who aren't experts at ad buying.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ttty on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:14PM (#32893525)
Let’s say with your optimised settings your ROI is 20%. With Google settings is 15%.

An end user might say 15% is pretty good and don’t touch it.

Google just earned 5% by giving you worst ROI.

If you start comparing with other ad providers you’l you might notice you’re being screwed. But low spenders rarely do proper checks.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ishjoh on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:13PM (#32903283)
this would explain why when i was doing an ad spend for my SAAS even though I limited it to the US all the users came from a different country as confirmed by a third party that tracked where users were from. This is brutal
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by mwexler on Monday September 19, 2022 @11:27AM (#32899664)
I've seen this little "handy feature" bite every company I've ever consulted or worked with.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by _HMCB_ on Sunday September 18, 2022 @08:09PM (#32892739)
Gold advice. Thank you.