One learns how to learn. New material is learned faster and more accurately. One also learns what parts to focus on, and what parts can be dismissed, which helps learn more efficiently.
A thousand times this! School is obsolete by construction if we only learn specific skills, which might not stay relevant for long. Learning how to learn is the truly useful thing that a good school should provide.
I am baffled by all the comments about how children should learn <specific skill someone think is important>. How useful would have been an education where arithmetics would have been focused on how to use slide rules? And yet, that was a practical, critical professional skill for quite some time.
It also gives one an appreciation for calculators. It's like learning to use hand tools before machine tools. Hand tools impart a feel for the material being cut that pays off when using machine tools.
Would you teach kids today to use a slide rule? It seems hard to justify for the benefit in intuition about exponents/logarithms.
Yes, I'd teach kids to use a slide rule. It's not necessary for them to become expert at it, just get comfortable with it.
Why learn exponents? People will never learn compound interest without getting comfortable with exponents. Not learning compound interest will forever financially cripple them. Hell yes, it's worth while.
My accounting class was taught by a former used car salesman. He'd tell me stories about how poor people made very bad choices in financing, and when he'd explain how compound interest worked, they'd assume he was trying to cheat them.
For me personally, knowing math and trig, etc., has provided me a lifetime of payback. Very, very worth it, in dollars and cents.
I don't think you cultivate the kind of intuitive understanding of exponents and logarithms you're describing with a few minutes of casual practice with a slide rule.
My first semester at Caltech had slide rules in the bookstore for $125 (mebbe close to a grand today). By the end of the semester, they were $5, and disappeared by the 2nd. I've never seen a tech revolution hit so hard and so fast.
The trouble with calculators is they impart no feel whatsoever for the math behind it. You get a string of 10 digits that is "The Answer". People get led astray by that all the time, including professionals. It's amazing how these people defend obviously wrong results because the calculator gives "The Answer".
Graphing calculators used to be nice to occasionally use to help build an intuitive sense of the "shape" of a function. Now I often use Desmos for the same thing.
I was a long term sub for 8th grade science a couple years ago. It was fun to use Desmos for linear regression as they collected data points-- to see how each point changed the line of best fit before these students had learned L.R. in any rigorous way themselves. It made students excited to get each next point in our experiment and make predictions about whether they believe the line, etc. (And whether we can safely extrapolate past the data we have...)
In the competitive math series I coach, one of the 3 rounds allows calculator usage. Usually using the calculator is a trap instead of doing something clever, but sometimes the calculator is the best way. I think it's kind of neat that they built it this way, because it requires building the intuition to realize whether you're really facing a problem that is purely calculation.
Over in microeconomics... we draw budget curves, and all the operations on budget curves are a whole lot like operations on production possibility curves, so there's a lot of skill transfer.
We spent 2 class periods on PPCs, and 10 minutes on budget curves. My students better understand how to learn economic concepts, and they have a closely related skill that they can adjust for the new task.
Every lesson, we're accelerating.
Me, I had a good chuckle over that. I kept all my college textbooks except the econ one, which went in the trash.
I would rather be teaching this material with calculus and not just handwaving and saying "the marginal revenue curve is twice as steep as the demand curve!"
But they're going to pass an examination where it's all done algebraically and visually.
[I DO THINK there's some value in taking these algebraic and visual approaches, but there comes a point in the class where they get rather awkward].
I've already told students many times we're going to find the area of shapes on this graph, where I'd actually just subtract the curves and take a definite integral.
And the graphs are a really, really nice visual for the subject matter. Being able to point to consumer surplus, producer surplus, tax revenue, and deadweight loss as regions on the graph means you know how all these curves relate. But then we end up doing all this awkward not-quite-calculus stuff.
Maxima and minima were certainly one issue because that required calculus, however simple a form thereof. I'm not sure even the simplest formulaic version ever got through. But we're taking about totally not getting solving simultaneous algebraic equations and one student told me I needed to explain "graphs" so it was all mostly a hopeless project.
Yup-- College Board's preferred approach here is memorization. You get -this- maxima when MC=MR. You get this -other- maxima when MU=0. You get this -other- one when Ed = -1.
Don't even get me started on "this number is always negative, so we'll just pretend it's positive sometimes-- though when you do a related calculation, make sure you preserve the sign!" (elasticity of demand vs. other elasticities).
MBA programs have changed a lot since I did one. But math was definitely the real killer for a lot of first-years. STEM undergrads had it a lot easier.
I agree, but if they go to my room learning a bunch of rules-of-thumb for maximizing economic functions... and then go down the hall to math class and are learning how to optimize by finding places where the derivative is 0... it's kinda silly.
I also found it gave us a more 'self learner'/ 'figure it out' attitude. Contrasting with a lot of my peers and younger, it seems like 90% of what they ask is just a google away... Also, being able to reason about unknown error messages or system behavior seems to be a challenge for a lot of them.
In between stuff is weird, it’s where people complain about ‘politicizing science’ and ‘being fed up with experts’, etc. It’s where the wavefront of known facts changes too quickly for any kind of mass education to catch up.
Although, especially in high school but to a more limited degree in intro level college courses as well, you still end up memorizing a lot of formulas in a course like physics--one issue being that you probably haven't taken the calculus yet that you need to derive those formulas. Of course, you often end up knowing formulas you use all the time off the top of your head anyway. But you presumably could derive a lot of them if you had to.
The thing that I appreciate most about the teachers and the curriculums taught was that they taught me (I would say us refering to all students, but don't want to presume) was how to learn. I should say, the math/science classes did this. The history/literature classes were all rote memorization BS. I did not like those classes an did not do well in them. However, the other classes where I learned how to learn allowed me to become what has been labeled "a self-learner". I can read subject material a few times, experiment, and then "know" it well enough to function. Practice and continued use makes for much better retention than rote memorization. I used to ask teachers for anything that was still unclear, now it essentially is replaced with SO searches.