However, if I come to a Starbucks and I start having a conversation about something in a quiet voice similar to what is allowed of any other person at Starbucks--maybe because I am on a date with another guy--I certainly do not believe that the people who run the Starbucks should decide they will refuse to serve me or allow me to talk about our date with each other because they disagree with us being homosexual.
You are correct that the right to freedom of speech is not the same thing as a right to be heard by the people you want to talk at, regardless of whether they want to hear you or not... but that isn't what is in question here: people are being entirely banned from platforms such that even their explicit followers can't access their content, and messages with certain forms of content that are merely being sent between small groups of people are being "moderated" out of existence.
This ruling only denies the right to censor based on viewpoint, something which I believe Starbucks is also bound by. You can throw a customer out for being obnoxious and threatening. But probably not for sitting at a table and calmly discussing the pros and cons of various abortion laws, sharing opinions Starbucks disagree with.
In California this might be true, I believe political affiliation is a protected class in California. But political affiliation is not a protected class federally, so it should generally be legal for corporations to discriminate against people on the basis of political belief, as long as they don't do that in a way that could be construed as discriminating on the basis of something that is a protected class, like race.
Starbucks is on private property.
> Would it be okay for them to write a manifesto on the chalkboard next to the barista?
The Starbucks chalkboard is privately owned.
>Social Media is the same. Privately owned and can set their own standards.
No it isn't. Anyone can log into Twitter and Facebook and see tweets and posts. They're public squares that are closely related to a mall rather than a private Starbucks location.
> The internet has plenty of space for people to post their opinions on their own servers.
Up until other big tech companies like CloudFlare decide they don't want to be associated with you and stop offering you ddos protection.
> They are annoyed because if you take away social media, you make it harder for them to get an audience.
Exactly! And that's why Twitter, Facebook, and Google should be treated as public squares. It's not fair that one group can access a public resource that others cannot.
The reason it is (not just seems) different is because of the scope. A message on a chalkboard cannot reach millions of people (without the internet), but it can on a website.
That by itself distorts the public/private argument, but we as a society aren’t sure how or to what extent yet.
These lawsuits are the second step (the first step was arguing about it in public) of figuring that out.
I honestly don't think it distorts the public/private argument, any more than MacDonald's serving billions of customers distorts the question of whether it's a private corporation or whether its scale transforms it into a public service.
But the inevitable endgame of this is going to be the government regulating all speech on the internet, and most of the internet no longer allowing any kind of user content, and I don't think the free speech absolutists so willing to throw the baby of free speech out with the bathwater of consequence are going to like it.
But all websites? To my knowledge, the only websites people agree on this are Facebook and Twitter. So probably probably not all websites, but that's one of the things that need to be worked out. When does a site reach a scale where it can no longer be treated solely as a private entity? What should happen then? How should we identify those sites? Then what?
There are tons of people who agree with you, tons who don't, and tons in between. But the majority seem to be on the side that things can't stay the way they’ve been. The effects on society over the last 20 years are not good. I haven't seen much disagreement on that. No one can agree on what to do about it though.
McDonald's is an interesting example because there are debates happening there too, but making people fat doesn't have cause the same visceral reaction as interfering with elections.
Which government? This is a global issue. It's going to be a long painful process of screwing up then trying to fix it.
But no one is saying that, because of their scale and cultural influence, they have to be privatized and considered infrastructure.
>Which government?
I mean this is obviously an attempt by the US government to control speech on US web platforms, based on US politics since the election of the last President. The rest of the world seems to have settled the question of whether websites are allowed to moderate content, and it was a settled question in the US until a bit after 2016.
Yes this is US specific, but they’re far from the only ones planning to do something about it. I disagree that this is settled anywhere. We’re still trying to understand what’s been happening.
Yes. When a few corporations dominate anything, they cannot be considered 'private' entities that can do whatever they want anymore. They are infrastructure, and they have to oblige by the democratic rules and regulations like how any large infrastructure company does.
Free speech is no different. After consolidating a majority of the social space and literally gaining the power to set the public discourse, no company can be let to do whatever they want with that power. That would invalidate any concept of free press. Not that current 'free' press is any different and that it does not need a major regulatory crackdown. But it has to start somewhere, and starting from the companies who literally ousted the traditional press from the helm of public discourse should be a good place to start.
>Not that current 'free' press is any different and that it does not need a major regulatory crackdown. But it has to start somewhere (...)
And so the mask slips and the agenda reveals itself. This is not about freedom, it's about control, and this is only the beginning. I wonder where it will end?
Yeah, its not about freedom. Who told you that it was. Society exists only because there is a commonly accepted framework for making a society and keeping it. You cant just do anything you want. Try sh*tting on the road in front of your neighbor's house tomorrow. Try doing it naked. Look how freedom is limited.
That you internalized existing rules and restrictions does not make you any more 'free'.
The difference is that your site has some small non-zero chance of reaching millions in the future, while Twitter, Facebook etc are reaching millions or billions right now. The law doesn't have to work on your potential to reach millions of views, just like how taxes don't work by assuming you might become a trillionaire overnight.
Could you wake up tomorrow to your social media platform having grown to millions of users, yes. Is it a realistic situation that should roadblock regulation? no.
Social media does, in my view, publish the content they host. It's not like the telephone, where you establish a direct connection to your audience and the mediator gets out of the way. When you post something to social media, there are three separate steps that happen:
1. You send the content to the SM company.
2. The SM company does some kind of processing on the content.
3. The SM company publishes that content (or not) somewhere on their site.
These things happen pretty much instantaneously, but they are still happening. Posting to Social Media is more like writing a Letter to the Editor of the newspaper. They receive the letter, decide whether to include it in the paper, then include it in the paper.
What you permit, you promote.
Don't you consider it publishing when they express editorial control over what topics are allowed on their platform, without transparency or accountability of what the forbidden topics are at any given point of time? They also modify the user generated content and add labels and "fact checks" which are prominently displayed.
That's like walking into a Starbucks and reading the chalkboard. Everybody who can enter can read it.
Factual it's faster and easier to enter a Starbucks than creating an FB account.
And like we all know if FB decides to ban your account you can nothing do about it.
Doesn't sound like a public place to me
So Starbucks is now a public place?
I don't think so.
"In the mid 90s Starbucks incorporated this philosophy into its retail design and business strategy: “We want our stores to be the third place' "
https://www.mjvinnovation.com/blog/third-place-and-the-starb...
Now consider the same for Facebook.
Okay, so the mall is a better analogy. But it still doesn't mean I can do anything I want at a mall. If I run in there and start shouting slogans at passers-by, I am going to be removed by mall security "for my viewpoint" because it's bad for business. And no, there isn't a list at the mall saying precisely what kinds of crazy behavior you're not allowed to bring in.
It's hard for me to see how Twitter isn't the same.
Just reading a book on malls, in America, they are mostly privately owned and are absolutely famous for rigid policing.
"Starbucks is on private property." So are servers where data is stored
Fine. Nationalize them, remove all advertising, open up all the source code and infrastructure, and let open cyberwarfare commence.
As someone who opposes free speech, would you be ok with Facebook allowing you to mute speech you do not like? The argument against "free speech absolutism" has more to do with one person wanting to exert power to silence another, and they are depending on social media to do that.
Whether private companies should not be able to discriminate speech based on content is still up to debate, but don’t compare this to shouting.
This is the sealion's argument, that you have to be willing to engage with them at all times in all contexts. It implicitly denies freedom of association. For example, if I am running doomermetalchats.com do I have to tolerate K-pop fanatics with their relentless positivity and sunny optimism?
The doomers and the stans can be talking right alongside each other and never see each other; effectively, the doomer 'site' only exists virtually, as a mutually visible consensus among a subset of the network.
There are a few different motivations for social communication, both cooperative and antagonistic. People often want to be able to communicate freely with their peers and exclude non-members of their peer group (socially, algorithmically, or by fiat), but sometimes also to be able to push into and perhaps take over network territory of rival groups or that they consider should be common.
as it is now, virtual private property doesn't have parity with laws governing physical private property.
Starbucks is a privately owned location and has the right to enforce behavioral standards or kick people out. Social Media is the same. Privately owned and can set their own standards.
The internet has plenty of space for people to post their opinions on their own servers. They are annoyed because if you take away social media, you make it harder for them to get an audience.