News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by realsolipsist on Saturday September 17, 2022 @04:58AM (#32875956)
This is disappointing, and while there might be some unknown factors here, it does seem to follow a concerning trend.

While demonetization isn’t technically censorship, it is discouragement and disincentivizing, which can have a similar effect as censorship without its messiness.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by roenxi on Saturday September 17, 2022 @06:26AM (#32876379)
It goes to a weird microcosm situation where typing in http://not-youtube.com is somewhere between an insurmountable hurdle and an impossible feat. I remember that Fran woman [0] who was on HN a few weeks ago who just wasn't interested in moving off YouTube under thematically similar conditions, she flat out refused to consider Odysee in her video.

If YouTube's advertisers don't want to be funding more arty or niche content, then there needs to be a 2nd platform that caters to arty content and has niche advertisers. This stuff that is getting demonitised all looks pretty interesting, there has to be a market here that YouTube is giving up. Even if maybe it is small.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/c/FranBlanche/videos

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by that_guy_iain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @07:10AM (#32876541)
Honestly, I don't think Google cares per se. They just don't want the hassle of another adpocalypse. The issue comes from advertisers not wanting to be seen promoting certain things. Like if you're advertising insurance you don't want some group of self rightous people to not use your service just because you advertised on YouTube and they showed that video next to a stripper talking about doing coke in the bathroom.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by concinds on Saturday September 17, 2022 @08:29AM (#32876990)
> Honestly, I don't think Google cares per se. They just don't want the hassle of another adpocalypse. The issue comes from advertisers not wanting to be seen promoting certain things.

I think it's important to be very clear on the correct timeline. Tiny activist groups like "Sleeping Giants" put pressure on advertisers, and got a hashtag trending (back when it was easy to get hashtags trending, before Twitter changed it so that they had to manually approve each hashtag before it showed up on the right-hand sidebar). A few advertisers listened, and pulled their ads from YouTube. It was obviously absolutely incredibly insanely obvious that they were bluffing. YouTube is the most-visited site in the world after Google Search. But YouTube folded instead of calling their bluff; now here we are.

This isn't something anybody really wanted. Advertisers did it to look good for a few days on Twitter, in a very low-ad-spend period anyway (didn't cost them anything). They were planning on letting YouTube make a tiny concession, and resuming their ads. YouTube didn't have to fold; they just panicked. They could have given Fortune 500 advertisers the ability to blacklist channels their ads appear on, and it would have gone away. They mismanaged that crisis completely (and it was far from the last).

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by that_guy_iain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @09:56AM (#32877569)
The thing is most companies don't want the extra work in finding who they don't want to be associated with. They would much rather the platform didn't allow the possibility of their ads being shown next to content of a specific type.

YouTube isn't banning the content, they're just saying they can't show ads next to it which honestly, seems like common sense.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by concinds on Saturday September 17, 2022 @11:18AM (#32878204)
> The thing is most companies don't want the extra work in finding who they don't want to be associated with

It's a PR solution; it's not supposed to please engineering, systematizing left-brained people, but to calm down a Twitter mob. YouTube had more than enough market power to simply force advertisers to comply, and advertisers were begging to be given a tiny concession in order to end their boycott while saving face.

This solution would have avoided the adpocalypse entirely.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by that_guy_iain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @11:22AM (#32878235)
> It's a PR solution; it's not supposed to please engineering,

What does the an advertiser having to spend countless hours finding which channels they don't want to be associated with have to do with engineering? Nothing.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by concinds on Saturday September 17, 2022 @11:38AM (#32878368)
Grammar.

"It's not supposed to please engineering-minded people, systematizing people, left-brained people." I'm talking people like you, who indeed don't think like the advertisers who just wanted a braindead controversy to go away; solving it was unnecessary for YouTube or for advertisers.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by that_guy_iain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @12:04PM (#32878612)
Grammar.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by retcore on Saturday September 17, 2022 @09:38AM (#32877453)
I'm fascinated to learn more specifically about this sequence of events. Can you suggest any good sources?

>They could have given Fortune 500 advertisers the ability to blacklist channels their ads appear on

That's just... I don't have words to describe,but the sheer laziness in failing to write what any non expert outsider would probably write down among the first few obvious requirements for a advertising platform, is stunning.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by concinds on Saturday September 17, 2022 @11:29AM (#32878301)
> I'm fascinated to learn more specifically about this sequence of events. Can you suggest any good sources?

I witnessed it in real-time and discussed it with marketer/advertiser friends who have good industry knowledge. I don't know if anyone documented the behind-the-scenes. Note that I may have misremembered the name of the main group behind it (might not have been Sleeping Giants back then).

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by threatofrain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @05:28AM (#32876096)
According to the video, YT is demonetizing all sex-related content. That's likely to be a popular move regardless of whether people understand the full implications of that decision. It's in YT's interest to make money, but they have to balance that desire with perceived threats from legislature or public sentiment.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by defrost on Saturday September 17, 2022 @05:53AM (#32876205)
"sex related content" is broad ill defined brush.

The recent case of the father sending groin region photographs to doctor via google (?) services and being flagged for "inapropriate child content" is one example of where exceptions should be made.

I'm now aware of this channel - I have no issue with its content and feel it should have as much access to income streams as any other vlogger.

There are audiences for all manner of content, surgeons have an interest in "gore" videos that relates to injury, treatment, and things often pixelated out.

Those in the social sciences want to see stories such as these in this channel to better understand issues and impacts of policy.

This is an area that needs better human judgement and oversight, if youtube wants to deter OnlyFansOG style videos then they should do so in a manner that doesn't also swat channels such as this example.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by threatofrain on Saturday September 17, 2022 @05:59AM (#32876231)
YouTube has more reason to be afraid of false positives than false negatives. By refusing to monetize all sex-related content, they now won't make a mistake which the public or government might punish them for. I think the public is far more okay with the idea that YT doesn't fund sex-related content than vice versa, and therein lies the source of risk for YT.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by sureglymop on Saturday September 17, 2022 @06:59AM (#32876492)
But what I don't get is... What's wrong with funding sex-related content? And what legislature is against that? Personally i was just under the impression that YouTube is doing that to keep the content family friendly for their advertisers. Instead of all this, if we all collectively normalized this type of subjectively normal content, it would cease to be a problem. It's also difficult, because what's considered as "sexual" changes over time. It's even a little mind boggling to me that female breasts are still so sexualized but that's a topic for another day.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by Test0129 on Saturday September 17, 2022 @10:25AM (#32877750)
You're reducing this too far. It's simple. Advertisers may have several reasons to not be shown on sex-related content. Regardless of how mundane that content may be. The first and most obvious reason is demographic. People who tend to be sex positive (or whatever the term is now) tend to have certain purchase patterns associated with certain lifestyles, political ideologies, and age groups. They may not sell a product and don't want to pay for ad space. Next, it may be off-brand for them to do so anyway. It might make sense for Trojan to place an ad on a video about the proper use of condoms, but not Cheerios. Third is political neutrality. Since our current society is on a perpetual witchhunt and reduces people and entire companies into the sum of their political views it's often easier to simply take no stance. It's better to not do anything then do something and then tomorrow it's "bad" or wrongthink.

Finally, sex-related content is a hot button issue related to children. One "sex positive" state, California, just passed a law to come up with yet another way to "protect the children". If you demonetize all of the content with broad strokes you can go to the states and say you comply with their rules.

It's far, far more complicated than "collective normalization". One could even argue that could have blowback that we can't measure. Sex-related content extends far beyond a simple female breast or a tutorial on using a condom.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by tinus_hn on Saturday September 17, 2022 @08:12AM (#32876875)
What’s wrong with it is that advertisers, who are YouTube’s customers, don’t want to advertise next to anything that has to do with sex. They will get very angry if YouTube shows their ads next to a video that has to do with sex.

To avoid making their customers angry, YouTube doesn’t show any ads next to videos that have anything to do with sex.

Next, because these videos don’t provide any revenue for YouTube they don’t have a big incentive to keep them online. In fact they do have an incentive to be quick at pulling them down.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by admax88qqq on Saturday September 17, 2022 @08:18AM (#32876906)
> if we all collectively...

Aye there's the rub. Not everyone thinks the way you do.

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by concinds on Saturday September 17, 2022 @07:44AM (#32876713)
This is a self-inflicted problem for YouTube, and with each move they make in this direction, they more indelibly associate themselves with the idea that they endorse each and every ad on their platform, as well as where it's shown. They could have told Sleeping Giants to go fuck themselves back in 2016 and avoided the whole adpocalypse timeline; but now they started and can't stop. People only see it as "YT funding sex-related content" because YouTube repeatedly endorsed that way of reframing and redefining video ad revenues.

Imagine if instead, it was framed as: "YouTube makes money off YouTubers' content; their 45% cut is entirely parasitic, YouTube is price-gouging and rent-seeking due to stronger network effects than any other platform on Earth; and YouTube creators are entitled to keep 100% (or, let's say 90% after hosting and fees) of the revenue they generate, not 55%." (yeah, Google's cut is 45%, not 30%, hah. 30% is practically a gift.)

See how bad that would be for Google? So they go all in on the colorful, bubbly, "we care about you"-teddy-bear, 'Sleeping Giants' train, because they'd rather have progressivism than "Marxism." I just wonder how it's been so effective, and why they garner so much less criticism than the App Store for doing far worse (there's no "video platform duopoly" unlike App Stores, it's just a monopoly).

Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by DoItToMe81 on Saturday September 17, 2022 @05:27AM (#32876089)
I have no idea if it's still the case, but demonetized videos used to appear lower, or not at all, in the search.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by greenthrow on Saturday September 17, 2022 @07:21AM (#32876595)
Demonetization is effectively censorship on Youtube. If your video is demonetized Youtube won't recommend it and will deprioritize it in search results. It's almost a shadowban.
Re:Soft White Underbelly demonetized by YouTube [video] by SpelingBeeChamp on Saturday September 17, 2022 @02:30PM (#32879970)
Full-time YouTuber here. This is unfortunately true.

YouTube's official position is that the monetization status of a video is not a factor in search and discovery, and that is probably true. But according to YouTube, all of the factors that impact advertiser friendliness (read: monetization) are factors in search and discovery.