News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by jquery on Friday September 16, 2022 @11:33AM (#32867494)
We don’t just need human moderation, we need due process. These companies control too much of our digital lives and make so much money from us, but have zero regard for us as soon as it’s inconvenient to investigate a case, because that would cut into their insane margins. I was permabanned for Twitter recently merely for getting the attention of some large influencers who disagreed with me (no actual rule was broken, but I received enough reports that my account was nuked).

I appealed multiple times but Twitter’s appeal process is a sham for us little people. I doubt any humans ever looked at my account.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by root_axis on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:28PM (#32868470)
They only control what we voluntarily give them. Social media controls nothing of importance in my life.
Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by BlargMcLarg on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:34PM (#32868587)
Emphasis 'we', not 'my'. These guys are already making shadow profiles out of info given by friends, corporations, etc. Not participating is also causing red flags in certain circles. Withstanding peer pressure is one thing, having your identity made up or flagged out of your control is another.

This is a slippery slope that should be tackled before it gets to that. The only people not affected indirectly, are the people who will die without children or younger cohorts as friends.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by root_axis on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:06PM (#32869854)
> These guys are already making shadow profiles out of info given by friends, corporations, etc.

True, it's a shady practice indeed, but signing up and giving them even more information directly from the source is obviously far worse than the fraction of signals they can extract from your friends.

> Not participating is also causing red flags in certain circles.

There's no accounting for the peculiarities of social groups, you could say the same thing about refusing to smoke weed or drink alcohol, it doesn't mean those vices are vital, and social media is no different.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by BlargMcLarg on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:16PM (#32869992)
I don't think you fully grasp what the slope is sliding to. There are enough token anecdotes of companies doing background checks on social media, and will actively flag individuals for having zero presence. We also have social credit score horror stories.

Your answer doesn't work anymore when lack of participation is considered wrong. We should be blocking that instead of assuming things will just work out forever as long as individuals guard their identity. Again, this goes beyond just standing up against peer pressure.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by root_axis on Friday September 16, 2022 @02:36PM (#32870256)
> There are enough token anecdotes of companies doing background checks on social media, and will actively flag individuals for having zero presence.

I'm sure it happens, but I don't believe that to be a real issue since using the presence of a social media account as a filtering tool for hiring is obviously ridiculous, and as someone who has done a lot of hiring, it's completely absurd to imagine we'd ever turn away a good candidate because their name didn't hit on a social media search, especially because it's very common for people to use nicknames or false names on social media or to completely remove their account from search altogether.

I also don't see the peer pressure thing as an issue. Adults don't meaningfully peer pressure other adults to use social media, nobody cares, and kids will peer pressure for everything from video games to sex and drugs, but it's pretty obvious that being peer pressured to do drugs isn't a valid reason to use drugs.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by BlargMcLarg on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:02PM (#32870587)
I'm not sure why you circle back to peer pressure when we agree it isn't an issue. Are you reading past the comments?

>it's completely absurd to imagine we'd ever turn away a good candidate because their name didn't hit on a social media search,

Understand for a moment many of these people are not developers with well-established CVs. These are normal people working the bottom of the ladder where there are plenty of replacements, and the answer to being irreplaceable is effectively 'start becoming a prodigy, establish a network early or be lucky'. Often too late for them. Even that advice alone is insane for the yet-to-be-born given a virtually global mental health crisis.

Leaving things up to executives behaving in a sane manner has given us multiple global problems to deal with. I wouldn't count on their sanity to prevent another.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by root_axis on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:38PM (#32871003)
> I'm not sure why you circle back to peer pressure when we agree it isn't an issue.

You're the one bringing it up. You've mentioned peer pressure in all of your replies.

> Understand for a moment many of these people are not developers with well-established CVs

It doesn't matter the industry or the CV, the idea that the absence of a social media account factors into hiring decisions in any real way doesn't make sense.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by jasonm23 on Saturday September 17, 2022 @03:46AM (#32875577)
I think there was a remote possibility of it being an issue 6 or 7 years ago. Since then the problems with Social Media. People preferring not to participate, has become such a trend that it is extremely unlikely to be a hiring issue these days.

However, in *some* corners of corporate HR, it's certainly been part of their scoring, at the peak of Facebook's popularity.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by swayvil on Friday September 16, 2022 @05:38PM (#32872320)
You haven't thought about peer pressure enough. It's got depths.

"You must do this thing" evolves into "you must support this thing" and then into "absence of support is equivalent to nonsupport (antisupport... whatever)".

And in social media this evolution is fast.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by redeeman on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:12PM (#32905924)
and this is where people must

1: reach their arms around and feel in the middle of the back 2: arch a bit back and fourth 3: realize they have a spine 4: say "i dont give a shit if you are in facebook or twatter or whatever, I am not. Deal with it."

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by UniverseHacker on Friday September 16, 2022 @05:21PM (#32872146)
I hate social media, and use it as little as possible, but can't figure out how to do what you are saying here in practice without total social isolation in the real world outside of social media.

For example, there are several sports I participate in (physically, in real life) but these are organized on either Instagram or Facebook. I have created accounts solely to access this information (date/time of events). Facebook and Instagram are constantly disabling and blocking my accounts, apparently because my low engagement (zero posts, only "lurking") triggers some sort of bot detector algorithm. I have no recourse, and can't contact anyone at Meta about this.

I've tried getting these communities to inform me outside of facebook/instagram, but it's too big of an ask. These mediums work for everyone else except me, and the people involved lack the tech savvy or interest in trying to find an alternative.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by swayvil on Friday September 16, 2022 @05:31PM (#32872254)
You are being punished for not "engaging" enough. Wow. I mean I imagined. So it really is a thing.

Like that black mirror episode where you aren't allowed to close your eyes when there's a commercial on.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by dotnet00 on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:46PM (#32868780)
Unless you don't interact with anyone, that's a completely untenable position due to network effects. eg My family (spread around the world) uses WhatsApp for communicating with each other, which I'm not much of a fan of but it's pretty much impossible to get them over to another platform given that I don't live anywhere near them anymore to teach them and they have to use it anyway for communicating within their residential community etc.

Sure technically I'm not being coerced into using WhatsApp, but it isn't exactly reasonable to say that if I really cared I would just not talk to my family until they figure out how to use a platform I prefer.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by root_axis on Friday September 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#32869700)
WhatsApp isn't social media, it's a messaging app, but more critically it's based on phone numbers, so WhatsApp really has no control over access to your contacts.

> Unless you don't interact with anyone, that's a completely untenable position due to network effects

It doesn't have to be this way though. Between sms, email, telegram, signal, and discord I have communication channels to every person I actually care about, and it's trivial to bridge additional layers of communication if needed.

> it's pretty much impossible to get them over to another platform

I hear where you're coming from, but in my view this is an intentionally defeatist attitude. We're throwing up our hands and saying "social media owns us and there's nothing we can do, it's just too hard to install another app". In reality, if it's important, it's not that hard. There's no disputing that social media is convenient, but it isn't vital.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by dotnet00 on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:08PM (#32870650)
I am aware that WhatsApp isn't social media, it's just an example of an app I would ideally like to switch away from.

I'm not really sure how it's defeatist when trying even to only get myself off the app would require making things much harder for my relatively tech illiterate parents on the other side of the world with no tech literate relative to lean on to help them out. With Whatsapp they've used it for a few years and can easily get help from any young neighbor in case of issues.

It isn't like I'm not trying. For example, for communicating with some close fairly tech literate friends, we go through a relatively big effort to host and maintain our ideal of a self-hosted Matrix and Misskey node. But there we can manage it due to everyone in the group being able to at least describe the errors they run into.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by illuminerdy on Friday September 16, 2022 @03:07PM (#32870642)
I haven't used Facebook or Twitter in well over a decade.

Nothing is more freeing than not having to put up with entitled, whiny idiots who think they are the moral authority on pretty much everything in the world. Especially since most of them couldn't accurately point to country that isn't America on a map.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by seer-zig on Saturday September 17, 2022 @01:28AM (#32875021)
Yet, it has a huge influence on spreading certain ideologies. The effect does not have to be direct.
Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by __turbobrew__ on Friday September 16, 2022 @11:54PM (#32874626)
These companies control too much of your digital life. I do just fine without having a Facebook, twitter, instagram, gmail, etc…

The only company which truly has me by the balls is Apple. There isn’t much getting around it however because you are either going to get boned by Google or boned by Apple, and contrary to social media accounts I think that cell phones are essential.

Re:Facebook bans Holocaust film for violating race policy by swayvil on Friday September 16, 2022 @05:27PM (#32872220)
It's similar on Reddit and, yes, even HN. The mere fact that you were "flagged" (by one of your peers) means that you are, to a significant degree, flagworthy and thus justifiably treated like a criminal.

Maybe these people doing the flagging are special people who have proven their worth. I dunno.