News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by lr1970 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:27PM (#32841220)
But is it plain illegal. For employment purposes Race is a protected class (at least in USA) and racial discrimination while hiring or firing violates federal law. How would they get away with this?
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by vondur on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:48PM (#32841521)
I'm pretty sure if you are white and laid off, you will have a pretty strong case for a lawsuit. I can't believe someone in legal wouldn't warn the leadership that putting out a press release stating this was a good idea.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:22PM (#32844233)
This is San Francisco. When I worked there (2015-2020), most of my co-workers openly endorsed hiring bias against demographics that aren't considered "diverse". I'd be highly skeptical that a jury would side with a plaintiff alleging anti-white discrimination, no matter how solid the proof. If a community widely thinks activity that is de jure illegal should be allowed then it becomes de facto permitted because even if a company engages in this behavior and gets sued they won't be held liable.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by pyuser583 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:42PM (#32845021)
I worked in SF during the same time period, at a small startup. There would have extreme fury at the idea of hiring/firing based on anything but ability.

Again, this was a small company. Every person mattered. Every talented hire advanced the company, and every talented departure put us at risk.

Even now at the big company I work for, the small team sizes mean each dev either contributes or drains. We even have an informal budget of how much we expect contributors go drain/gain (junior devs can drain for a while, senior devs make up for it, etc).

The sort of “anti-racist” methodology suggests a mindset I don’t quite get.

Every company I know of has an extemee backlog. Product isn’t getting shipped because there aren’t enough devs.

Are people seriously saying it’s ok their company doesn’t ship as much product if it benefits historically oppressed devs?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:52PM (#32845104)
By contrast, I was at two successful unicorns. They were both large (1,000 and 2-3,000 employees). We had the luxury of having significantly more applicants than headcount. I think the mentality is more that the product is already successful, and we have a responsibility to ensure that that oppressed people don't miss out on that success.

The irony is that most "oppressed" people hired at the companies we very well off. I'm Latin myself (a fact I don't advertise in my workplace precisely because of this discrimination) and I had a very privileged upbringing. Same with another Trinidadian engineer I spoke with. So in the end, it was a bunch of privileged white people patting themselves on the back for hiring privileged Latin and Black people.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:37PM (#32845486)
> So in the end, it was a bunch of privileged white people patting themselves on the back for hiring privileged Latin and Black people.

While whites and Asians born into poverty, who struggled all their lives against overwhelming odds, were deprived of these opportunities due to the color of the skin they were born in.

This is ugly, ugly stuff.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by nemo44x on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:35AM (#32847942)
It’s beyond ugly and the irony will be that progressives who are so concerned with how history will judge them will be judged harshly by these positions.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:59AM (#32848105)
That's why the key point for me isn't that it's illegal (though it is): it's immoral, even if it was legal.

Discrimination against blacks in the South was legal. Plenty of people defended racism on these grounds back then: "it's legal, the courts have approved it, and therefore it must be right."

These are not the people progressives are celebrating today. In fact, they'll cancel you for being at all similar to these people. Yet they are just like them.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by gampleman on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:50AM (#32849044)
I think of this as the Left having lost its way (in its own sort-of marxist terms). It's overly obsessed with identity and forgets the much more important discriminant of class. A cynical analysis is that the upper classes are using this as a successful divide and conquer tactic...
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by taolegal on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:20PM (#32857214)
It’s a communist tactic to sow division in society by raising tension along identity lines like race, etc. Of course schools usually cover this part of history as “McCarthyist nonsense.”
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by micromacrofoot on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:27AM (#32897400)
this assumes that you’re making a lesser hire and that a parallel skill level hire of a minority isn’t possible
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by RSieger1 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:56AM (#32851163)
That is jury nullification.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by gitfan86 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:52PM (#32841577)
Legal probably approved the word "lens". And if this ends up in court they will say that "lens" means that we are aware of the impact layoffs have on our society, but does not change who we fire during a layoff, meaning even if we didn't do this through a lens the person suing would have still been let go.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:45PM (#32842359)
If the layoff was done through the lens of racist consideration, and minority races were given preference, then the odds of a white or Asian person getting fired were higher.

That's already illegal. Even if you can somehow prove in court that "white worker X" would still be fired had he been black (already a dicey and likely impossible feat), just the fact that the employer already admitted that this worker was under more risk for getting fired due to his race, a-priory creates a cause of action against the employer.

If I say "I give preference to hiring men over women", and a woman is rejected and then sues, trying to show that I would not have hired her even if she was a man is arguing from a losing position.

The policy itself is racist and illegal.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Natsu on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:22AM (#32847389)
As an aside, the Latin words you wanted are a priori, but you're right that race is a protected category and putting out a statement saying "we made firing decisions based on a protected category" is a bad idea for that reason.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by abduhl on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:10PM (#32841849)
Then the laid off employees should organize as a class action so that "this specific person would have been let go" is no longer an acceptable defense and the question can be focused on whether using a "lens" to fire people based on race is illegal. If they argue that the lens means something else or that they didn't use the lens then Twilio has potentially just filed a materially false statement with the SEC.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by dominotw on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:05PM (#32842634)
> but does not change who we fire during a layoff

what does 'carried out through a lens' mean. Through means it was put through that lens?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by alttab on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:32PM (#32842975)
a lens translates things to a different view. so they either justified it somehow, or it changed the outcome. not a hair I'd want to be splitting in court.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by nonethewiser on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:04AM (#32846879)
Yeah the comment means nothing if it did not impact their decision.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by gitfan86 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:50PM (#32860559)
Exactly my point. White Male CEOs are afraid of an article in a major newspaper showing them being rich next to a picture of a poor minority that they just fired. So they put a PR spin on the firings.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by codefreeordie on Friday September 16, 2022 @08:23PM (#32873664)
Unfortunately, mostly not. Courts have so far been extremely unwilling to consider cases of that sort.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by OJFord on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:19PM (#32844814)
It's so vague and weasel-wordy - if it's genuinely 'anti-racist' then (why mention it‽ and) it doesn't disproportionately affect white people, or anyone (race-based).

I agree the implication seems very much like an intended 'affirmative'/'positive' action role-selection policy though. (I think such things are stupid - whether hiring/firing/anything - and bad for everybody, but I am white, so I try to keep that a 'lightly held' opinion.)

In the UK the law is similar to your description, but large companies also have to publish stats, and the implication seems pretty much like quotas are good/the law, it's hard to imagine anyone/entity being found guilty of (as-written) illegal discrimination on the 'positive' side that tilts you more towards balance, IMO. (IANAL.)

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by akvadrako on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:36PM (#32859319)
Anti-racist doesn't mean against racism. It's more like anti-matter is to matter.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by OJFord on Thursday September 15, 2022 @07:33PM (#32859891)
Anti- does mean 'against' or 'opposing'.

Making it analogous to antimatter only works if you say something like 'a white person is antiracist to a black person'.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by crackercrews on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:47PM (#32841511)
Isn't affirmative action in hiring legal? Seems like this is just the same thing but for layoffs.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:10PM (#32842696)
It is absolutely illegal. It violates the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which:

> outlaws discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964

Yes, that's the same act that makes it illegal to discriminate against racial minorities, women, religions, etc.

Discrimination based on race is illegal, pure and simple. Hiding it under nice names like "affirmative action" does not change this fact.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by mrtranscendence on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:32PM (#32842969)
I don’t think this is right. Affirmative action has been upheld by the courts, and is currently in practice at some private employers (and is mandated for government contractors).
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:38PM (#32843036)
You are wrong. There is one judgement that upholds a form of affirmative action in very narrow circumstances (education) and only in very limited form, and even that is challenged in SCOTUS and likely to be overturned:

https://www.wgbh.org/news/education/2021/07/22/as-supreme-co...

Racist discrimination is an ugly thing, even when you call it pretty names like "affirmative action".

If Affirmative Action was universally legal, than nothing would prevent racist/sexist discrimination as long as you have a nice-sounding excuse for it, and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 would be rendered vacant.

Women outnumber men 1.3:1 in college admissions, so Affirmative Action would let me openly discriminate in favor of men in hiring and promotion, as they are evidently a disadvantaged population compared to women.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by ForHackernews on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:16PM (#32844157)
Men actually do benefit from soft affirmative action in college admissions because of this disparity.

You can look this up for yourself, but here's one source[0]. Men are admitted at a higher rate, with worse grades and test scores, by selective universities that want to make sure they have a "balanced" class of undergraduates.

[0] https://www.ivywise.com/ivywise-knowledgebase/resources/arti...

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:28PM (#32844296)
It depends on the university, engineering-oriented schools admit women at higher rates (over 2x in the case of MIT and Harvey Mudd): https://money.com/colleges-women-higher-acceptance-rate/
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:16PM (#32845314)
Yes, as mentioned above, there is (unfortunately) a controversial ruling (Grutter v. Bollinger) that allows for a form of discrimination in college admissions specifically. This is wrong and should stop. It's an example of SCOTUS judges allowing their political views to to override a clear interpretation of the law.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by exolymph on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:16PM (#32844162)
De jure illegal, sure, but we all know it's de facto required for institutions of a certain size. Laws are only as good as the enforcement.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by fche on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:00PM (#32844630)
praying for an appropriate opinion from the SCOTUS on the asians/harvard case
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by jgil on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:38PM (#32844990)
Affirmative action is not illegal. If you take action to prevent adverse impact to any protected class, that is not discrimination. If a company hires only white men and rejects every Asian candidate they have ever interviewed, or only fires Asian employees, what is your proposed remedy? Status quo?

Check out the section Discrimination v. Affirmative Action [1] and a sample of significant discrimination case outcomes.[3]

[1] https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/cm-607-affirmative-action

[2] https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ofccp/faqs/practical-significan...

[3] https://www.eeoc.gov/initiatives/e-race/significant-eeoc-rac...

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:00PM (#32845168)
A company (Twilio) is executing a mass layoff, and is implying that it will protect certain racial minorities from this layoff. Doing this, they are necessarily discriminating against any employee who does not belong to these racial groups.

If you have employees A and B, both earning $100k/year, and your declining financials require you to save $100k/year, you must fire A or B. If you decide to fire A because s/he is white, even if it was just one factor, then you just fired a worker for their race, and violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

If you manage to implement a policy that benefits a protected class (such as a particular race or sex) without depriving a different protected class, it would not be illegal. This is not the case we are discussing here, of racial considerations affecting hiring or termination decisions.

Regarding the links you posted: It's no secret that the current administration is in favor of racist discrimination. They support Harvard's racist discrimination against Asians:

https://www.usnews.com/news/top-news/articles/2021-12-08/bid...

The law remains the law, and racist discrimination remains just as objectionable, even if the current administration supports it. I personally hope that any employee who was subject to racist discrimination will seek justice in court.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Spivak on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:22PM (#32845358)
Change the framing from “white person was fired” to “black person was retained” and you’re suddenly back into affirmative action territory and the case whether it’s a civil rights violation becomes iffy.

You don’t actually have to avoid depriving a protected class of anything by relative omission. Otherwise affirmative action and diversity programs would be illegal, and until the courts change their mind they’re currently allowed. If you allow your reasoning to be unconstrained there is no way to provide any benefit whatsoever in any form to particular races because that would be necessarily be depriving that benefit to the compliment.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:35PM (#32845463)
> Change the framing from “white person was fired” to “black person was retained” and you’re suddenly back into affirmative action

Change the framing from "a victim was robbed of $1,000" to "a poor person gained $1,000" and the clear crime of armed robbery becomes a positive event!

Fortunately, playing these types of games with language doesn't change the facts, or else there would be no justice; you can always "change the framing" to make any crime sound positive, by emphasizing its positive impacts and ignoring the adverse impacts.

As a matter of law, the SCOTUS unfortunately let their political views override a clear reading of the law in one case (Grutter v. Bollinger), and allowed a very limited form of affirmative action in a very specific context.

Discrimination based on race or sex in hiring and firing is still very much illegal. It's not hard to see why it's both immoral and destructive if we allow it in our society.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Spivak on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:44PM (#32845539)
Your example doesn’t work because you’re just pointing out some positive aspect, it doesn’t make it not robbery. In my case the difference between firing a white person and retaining a black person changes the nature of the act as it’s viewed by the law. What is in the mind of the person carrying out an act that affects different races disproportionately matters. And if we’re we following precedent this would probably be allowed as another narrow case.

So I don’t disagree with your overall point but I also don’t think anyone is going to win a lawsuit over this without a huge case that makes it to scotus because the practice of diversity hires is common and currently tolerated. And “we looked at all our employees and chose who to retain” is isomorphic to regular affirmative action.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by NeverFade on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:57PM (#32845636)
> I don’t disagree with your overall point but I also don’t think anyone is going to win a lawsuit over this without a huge case that makes it to scotus because the practice of diversity hires is common and currently tolerated.

According to this pessimistic viewpoint, there was no point in the civil rights movement of the 1960s that led the to revolutionary Civil Rights Act of 1964.

Black people would look around, and realize that discrimination against them is "common and currently tolerated", especially in the South, and just throw their hands in despair and live with it.

Fortunately, they didn't. And if even a single Twilio employee was fired for his race, I hope he doesn't, either. Not just for his sake, but for our sake as a society.

I don't want to live in a society where people are judged and treated according to the color of their skin.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by polski-g on Thursday September 15, 2022 @02:36PM (#32856491)
Affirmative action in the private sector is 100% illegal.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Spivak on Thursday September 15, 2022 @06:59PM (#32859557)
No it isn’t, in fact private companies are encouraged (and in some cases required) to have an affirmative action policy in place.

The thing you think affirmative action means “hiring less qualified employees because of their race” is illegal. You can’t base your hiring decision on someone’s protected characteristics but you are totally free to base other things on that.

Here are some anti-* takes that are totally legal.

* Someone you’re interviewing is Latino that has only worked on small projects or small features and when asked about it they expressed that they always asked to be given bigger projects but was always turned down. You get the feeling that this was likely due to his race and so you don’t hold it against him.

* You’re interviewing a trans woman who recently quit her job while not having anything lined up. She describes the last few months as suddenly having her workload increase, her code reviews getting more critical, and her pto being denied that never had before. By your estimation it seems like she was quiet fired because of her gender alignment and so you don’t consider it a red flag.

* You have the unfortunate task of needing to drastically cut payroll expenses and finance says it will be around 20% of the workforce. You talk to your senior staff and managers to recommend low performing candidates and collect metrics like cards worked and performance reviews. You’re reviewing a woman selected for termination and notice that she seems to be closing more cards than some of her male teammates which is odd, and when you dig into the PRs they’re fine, she’s seemingly not taking on easier work, and from the comments her teammates seem to love her. So you ask the manager’s manager and find out that she’s very much a girls girl and usually passes on the “boyish” team building activities that always get voted on like doing a work fantasy league and fishing. You think it’s pretty clear what’s going on and pick someone else from that team.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by crackercrews on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:12PM (#32861643)
> You get the feeling that this was likely due to his race and so you don’t hold it against him.

What would cause someone to get this feeling? Does a candidate just have to indicate that he wanted bigger projects but didn't get them? Seems like the exact same thing that would happen to someone who was not ready for bigger projects.

Would you do the same thing for a dev with a strong southern accent who worked at a company with mostly left leaning employees?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Spivak on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:14PM (#32868260)
> Would you do the same thing for a dev with a strong southern accent...

Abso-fucking-lutely. In fact I've actually done something similar, when you work in the somewhat affluent urban blue specs on the political map you will find genuinely talented engineers, usually self-taught too, who grew up in a small town/village and just don't have the usual pedigree of a CS degree from a random college and tech internships. I felt so bad for this one guy we hired, dude was and still is a fucking wizard at networking -- he literally runs his own ISP now as a side hustle but in the interview he didn't even have to say it, it was clear from how defensive he was saying stuff like "I know you would be taking a chance on me", "I would be fine with a probationary period" that he was getting rejected other places. So we had to interview him differently to set him up to show off what he was good at because random whiteboard algo problems wasn't it.

So it's not exactly textbook discrimination, but it is recognizing the systematic disadvantages this guy had as a result of who he is.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by nonethewiser on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:01AM (#32846856)
Lack of enforcement. And the ubiquitousness of racism in hiring and admissions.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by jballer on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:46PM (#32845561)
They're betting that a lawsuit would be so wildly unpopular that people would rather leave the money (and the principle) behind than face social exile.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by RSieger1 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:29AM (#32851617)
Because the chessboard has been moved and all the pieces rearranged.