that would have been illegal either way. Really there are two options here: Either they did something questionable and want to deflect (like being racist against white people. I'm not saying this is the case but it is a possibility), or they want to get a pat on the back for not breaking the law.
It's one of those sentences that immediately puts your mind to why it was placed in there: "[..] so we were particularly focused on ensuring our layoffs – while a business necessity today – were carried out without clubbing any seals."
Why would one say that? Why does one explicitly mention this? To what gain?
Either you want brownie-points for something that should be a given, or you want to get ahead of something.
Doing so is illegal and makes little sense to put it in a public announcement. Might as well state that they don't intend to murder anyone.
I read the statement the same as the GP comment.
This school of thought purports to agree that harmful impact supersedes good intent.
They just refuse to recognize the individual as the ultimate minority.
Imagine a company writes, "We avoided laying off Latino men for racist or bigoted reasons." But not Latino women? But not African Americans? What is the message behind limiting this assurance of non-discrimination to a particular group?
I agree that people interpreting this as Twilio announcing that it explicitly discriminated against non-oppressed groups are reading way too deep into it. But it was a pretty dumb thing to put in a layoff note.
It's like saying "I'm not racist" before doing something unrelated.
It should be; but I think it's naive or disingenuous to imply that hiring/layoff decisions are usually fair and unbiased, especially in multiple departments in a large organization.
Given this pattern of messaging, how else can someone conclude that white people are not the primary targets of a layoff of a San Francisco based company? Especially when the statement contains, "layoffs were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens".
FWIW I would be interested to know what the CEO actually meant by that. My assumption is it's more lip service than anything else.
What do you think "layoffs were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens" means?
Like, what concrete actions do you think they took to justify that statement?
Do you think it's purely window-dressing? That they did absolutely nothing different, and just included the statement?
I don't know if it's an authoritative source, but here's one of the top Google results for "what is anti-racisim":
"Anti-racism is also a system – a system in which we create policies, practices, and procedures to promote racial equity."
and
"Anti-racist policy creates systems that center the lived experiences of Black, Indigenous, and People of Color"
and
"We refer to ‘racism’ as an interpersonal display of prejudice toward Black, Indigenous, and People of Color."
Given the above understanding of the term "anti-racist", if I were a betting man, I'd bet that the racial makeup of the laid off employees is not an even sampling of the racial makeup of the company.
What do you think?
(Link to anti-racist information: https://www.nlc.org/article/2020/07/21/what-does-it-mean-to-...)
I would bet that your average "blind" layoff is not an even sampling of the racial makeup of the company. If they did anything at all here it was probably taking some sort of active role in preventing that outcome.
(Meta/off-topic: Someone flagged your comment, so I vouched for it. Viewpoint moderation is dumb and inhibits good conversation.)
> Layoffs like this can have a more pronounced impact on marginalized communities, so we were particularly focused on ensuring our layoffs – while a business necessity today – were carried out through an Anti-Racist/Anti-Oppression lens.
Sounds like they are taking steps to make sure whoever was chosen for layoffs were not chosen for racist reasons.
But so many comments are making the leap to they are targeting white people for layoffs and claiming this layoff is racist against white people.
For example this comment:
> People have lost their damn minds. This is actual institutionalized racism.
and this:
> I consider myself very ‘liberal’ per American standards (pro abortion, pro lgbt rights, pro racial diversity and acceptance), and this to me screams of woke culture gone wild. Looks like anything can be weaponised.
You can find more.