News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by an1sotropy on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:23PM (#32826409)
In response to Sen Grassley wrapping up questions about how Twitter executives wanted to address employee concerns about accepting ad money from Chinese companies, possibly with Chinese govt links (even while Twitter is banned in China):

28:25 [Mudge] "We're already in bed, it would be problematic if we lost that revenue stream, so figure out a way to make people comfortable with it."

That isn't really surprising, but it's still bad.

It's also worrying that some Americans complain about "big [US] government" to justify the very limited size and power of the FTC to regulate US big tech, while somehow overlooking the threat from the big Chinese government, its awful human rights record, and its track record of working to gain access into US companies.

It's really easy to criticize these senators for not being tech ignorant, but this is the only govt we have, and it's the only one that can empower the FTC to do more.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by dereg on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:42PM (#32826713)
He also testifies that the CTO, Parag, suggested that Russia be allowed to moderate the content on the platform because they are a “democratic country”. Really, really, really terrible optics.

It seems like Parag was a terrible exec, is losing his job, and the market knows it. Twitter’s stock is the only social media platform whose stock is up today.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by hammock on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:48PM (#32827795)
Democratic /= free
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by lwansbrough on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:34PM (#32828442)
Democratic =/= democratic
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by vorpalhex on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:31PM (#32829816)
They aren't Democratic. Putin is basically a monarch at this point. Even the Duma is gutted.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by badrabbit on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @06:44PM (#32831135)
"Basically" means in your opinion. Even north korea is democratic. The US picking between two parties is not so democratic either. Putin maybe a quasi dictator but their government isn't just one guy, are all the ministers in their legislature dictators too? Even with dprk of course they all vote for kim but what about other elections they have?

My question is who cares? They are a sovreign nation and the form of government they have is an internal matter. Their leaders and government are recognized by the world (even America) as legitimate rulers of their country

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by dredmorbius on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:56PM (#32832796)
This is literally a talking point and argument that Twitter's executive management made, according to Mudge's testimony.

In Sen. Klobuchar's questioning, Mudge quotes a conversation he'd had with Parag Agrawal regarding a request by Vladimir Putin to censor and surveil Russian Twitter users: "we don't really have the ability and tools to do things correctly, this is a lot of work, it's not really driving our main executive incentive goals, is there a way that we can simply punt? And since they have elections, doesn't this make them a democracy?"

That specific Q&A exchange begins at 1:00:15.

The immediate prior exchange with Sen. See is also telling. "I'm reminded of one conversation with an executive, when I said, 'I am confident we have a foreign agent', and their response was 'Well, since we already have one, what does it matter if we have more? Let's keep growing the office.'"

For those who haven't listened to the testimony, I strongly recommend doing so --- it's informative, level-headed, and reasonably fast-paced.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by badrabbit on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:13AM (#32834832)
I didn't watch the whole thing but I agree with Twitter's CEOs comments but more importantly why is this an issue Twitter is deciding? If the government of Russia is not recognized by the US or if Twitter should not obey certain Russian laws/orders or cease business there then the very functional and legitimate (sarcasm) democratically elected government of the US can declare sanctions to that effect. Whether you agree with putin or not Russia is in a state of war and you are expecting twitter to not censor things?? Do you think the US government does not do the same thing or did everyone forget Snowden's leaks? So much half-baked hypocrisy around this whole sentiment.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:19PM (#32844820)
In the context of multiple other statements by Mudge, the pattern is one of Twitter repeatedly expressing indifference to concerns, consequences, and summoning of political will and corporate capital to address any such concerns.

Your focus seems preternaturally narrow and short. Much as that of Twitter's executive staff.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by badrabbit on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:35AM (#32852688)
I have desire to defend twitter exec's track record. Of course what I said is narrow because the subject is specific in this thread. I don't get how people like you insult your own intelligence by insinuating that for twitter's CEO to be correct on one matter means everything they do is acceptable.

Is this an age and maturity thing? I can see how someone under early twenties can be this immature where either you hate twitter execs or you are completely in love with them. Be rational and reasonable, if you would like to disagree or counter any of my points feel free but I have no interest in paricipating in a "cancel" fight.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by dredmorbius on Friday September 16, 2022 @12:48AM (#32862209)
I'm flattered by your presumption. It, as well as numerous previous assessments of yours, seem quite poorly formed based on my own experience and knowledge.

I generally try to run adversarial assessment even on my own most cherished views or takes, as well as charitable interpretation of those of othsers. Both can lead to interesting places, much more so than the opposite strategies. More practices I recommend.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by vorpalhex on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:12PM (#32831326)
We care because having some unhinged old man with no checks on his power is bad.

As you may be aware, said senile old man just invaded a neighboring country. The same issue we have with DPRK.

Last time we did the "mind our own business" the jerk of the moment took most of Europe and killed several million people. Putin is doing his best to exterminate the Ukrainians now.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by badrabbit on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:06AM (#32834791)
But you don't live in thise countries and they are sovreign, you do not get to project your ways on others as if they are superior. A bunch of uneducated ignorant people voting for the loudest asshole isn't a perfect or better way either. America and the wesr enjoy a nice economy and military so things are ok there are many countries where democracies devolve into civil wars and dictatorships or worse because people aren't happy and the loudest scariest dude wins in a democracy. The whole point of sovreignity is that the people of that countey self-determine without outside influence. Now, if your country recognizes some component of a foreign state as the legitimate ruler then by all means but both dprk and russia are ruled by american recognized rulers so by what law or reason outside of social media rage do you justify your outrage?

Regardless of the ruler or government invading another country means more countries that have an interest in the invaded country can get involved because sovreignity was violates. In case of hitler the moment he invaded another country it was everyone's concern just like putin but before that it was only the german people who had a say in who leads them. If I remember right even hitler was voted in and his socialist party won election because they were loud and scary.

Twitter is a company that operates under US laws not under the laws of random public outrage. If you want your government to sanction doing business in russia or declare war on it by all means call your rep or discuss that until then it is perfectly acceptable for twitter to operate in Russia which means obeying their laws.

By your logic, what if a UK company refuses to block illegal content in the US. They are both democracies so the UK co should obey laws? But if the US became a dictatorship then it should break laws? What is this nonsense, you expect companies to break laws because you don't like the government of a foreign country?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by schnable on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:32PM (#32826551)
> It's also worrying that some Americans complain about "big [US] government" to justify the very limited size and power of the FTC to regulate US big tech, while somehow overlooking the threat from the big Chinese government, its awful human rights record, and its track record of working to gain access into US companies.

How is a bigger/more powerful FTC an antidote to the bad behavior of the Chinese government, or a defense against them?

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by an1sotropy on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:59PM (#32826998)
I'm not sure. Threats from the Chinese govt include US national security, and the privacy and human rights of all Twitter users. FTC itself may not be the regulatory body to address those, but don't you think it is nonetheless a legitimate interest of the US govt to regulate, if Twitter is a US company?

The hearing also shed light on how European regulation (France in particular, I think), was recognized within Twitter as something to take seriously, as opposed to how US regulation would result in, at worst, one-time fines.

Another revelation https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32566507 is that India had an agent working within Twitter. I don't know if that's a Dept of Labor regulation violation, but my general concern is that if you celebrate limits in US govt regulation, you may be celebrating having low vision of the harmful activities of foreign governments.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by vinay_ys on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:12PM (#32830235)
> India had an agent working within Twitter

Without proof, this is pure propaganda. India is a sovereign democracy with its own laws and regulations. India required all media platforms acting as intermediaries to have three permanent job roles with proper governance structure – a Chief Compliance Officer, a Resident Grievance Officer and a Nodal Contact Person – these job roles are expected to have specific responsibilities w.r.t dealing with consumer complaints. You can read the official government brief here – https://static.pib.gov.in/WriteReadData/specificdocs/documen...

Twitter would have interviewed and hired competent people of their choice into these roles. If any motivated government/corporate wants to infiltrate twitter, I doubt they would go about it by engaging in high-profile court battles and democratic parliamentary processes to do it.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by yazzku on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:07PM (#32829573)
The US government is also harmful outside of the US. Your comments here and above seem to have a tone of "US good, China bad". To be clear, this and the general issue of regulating American online spaces isn't about good vs evil, but about furthering one government's agenda or another's.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by ethanbond on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:37PM (#32826624)
Not that I necessarily believe in this, but you could imagine e.g. FTC or FCC requiring content-neutrality. In that world, China's asks for censorship go up against US's asks for no censorship. In this current world, China's asks for censorship go up against... employees' personal appetite for losing money (and potentially their jobs) in exchange for a non-China dominated information space?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by kornhole on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:19PM (#32832958)
He is trying to bring it home to them and getting them excited about hearing that China, Russia, and anybody else knows where they are at all times, what they follow and so on. If I had to choose a government to surveil and manipulate me, it would not be my own US government and corporations. Of course I don't let any of them do it.
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by codyb on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:37PM (#32826631)
Maybe they could enforce rules notifying users where their ads were coming from?
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by rrix2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:54PM (#32828685)
I still don't understand the attack-vector how buying targeted advertisements can be used to unmask particular individuals (the example in mudge's testimony: democracy-desiring Chinese citizens posting on twitter illegally).

can someone explain this to me?

if the users are accessing twitter + any ad clicks through a GFW-bypassing VPN, and china can target an advertisement to a single user, then they can figure out that that user uses a VPN if they click on the advertisement? how do they unmask the VPN IP address? my understanding is that VPN providers (should! i hope!) internally transit the traffic so that the exit node isn't the same as the IP address the GFW would see users connect to, so i'm not sure how they could correlate that traffic to a "real" IP/identity.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by netsharc on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:45PM (#32829304)
A possible scenario is: Chinese govt creates a honeypot site talking about e.g. Xinjiang, put Twitter ads pointing to it. Honeypot site has a tracking pixel from something like nothing-to-see-here.cn that sets a cookie on the user's browser (something like "visited=honeypot-site-about-xinjiang"). User disconnects from VPN, browses "normal" Chinese sites from their home IP, another Chinese site has another tracking pixel from nothing-to-see-here.cn, the user's browser connects to that site and sends the above cookie and gives away the user's home IP.

Yeah it's poor opsec, but quite possible. The cookie can even store what pages and how long the user spent on the honeypot site. Or the cookie can just be an identifier, and the honeypot site can send which pages were visited (and at what time) to the nothing-to-see-here.cn, which builds a visitor's profile for the reeducation police.

Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by rrix2 on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:40PM (#32829919)
Thanks, I had dis-counted 3rd party cookies for some reason. Luckily the tide here is changing with firefox ETP, Safari cookie isolation, etc, but you're right that a lot of the world still has cross-domain cookies to contend with. Yikes!
Re:Mudge Twitter whistleblower testimony [video] by freewizard on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @01:34PM (#32827558)
It seems not a twitter specific problem, every company selling click ads (=every tech and media company) has same problem.

Not sure congress or FTC can do much. Ban click ads? Ban Chinese advertiser? Ban links to Chinese-owned websites? Ban BGP to China?