Then the computer would be better at recognizing a sign than a human.
The tech is the easy part.
In my experience, Google just thinks those are traffic jams. I've seen Maps 'know' about road construction speed limits, but it isn't usual.
The thing is that most consumer devices with GPS (like phones and even standalone GPS navigators) have a lot of internal "magic" to hide the raw noise in location fixes from the GPS signal.
For example, certain Garmin devices (intended to be used off road) will snap your location to an Interstate if you are going more than 55 mph and heading roughly in the direction of the road (which is evident when you run into traffic and your location keeps switching between the frontage road and expressway--the error distribution of the noise doesn't have mean=0!).
Diving along a free flowing 50 and having it decide it's now a 30 because it saw a sideroad and drop a gear is semi-regular. The second most dangerous thing it does after having a touchscreen.
It also manages to read 45 sometimes but I have literally never seen a 45 sign.
It's true that people aren't often looking for fatal pranks, but you could do more benign like try to get people pulled over by causing them to speed unknowingly.
https://westernsafety.com/nolan-portable-derail-pd-2/
On sale now! Or pick this one for bigger and faster trains:
https://www.aldonco.com/store/c/127-SaberTooth-Portable-Dera...
There are lots of tools, weapons, chemicals, and other things that a person could do that would be bad. It doesn't take much creativity, just a callous disregard for other people. But in contrast to the fearmongering and crime you'll see in the media, consider it a bit of good news that in spite of how incredibly easy it is to intentionally cause harm to someone else, billions and billions of people choose not to do that every single hour of every single day.
Which in turn is because our emotions around people setting out to do that, are calibrated around the fact that it basically doesn't happen outside of war conditions.
https://www.kyivpost.com/russias-war/anti-putin-russian-rebe...
I wonder whether it's related. Probably not but train derailments are weirdly relevant to current world state...
But back to the topic... I don't think anything should be censored and am of opinion freedom of speech just need to be taken wholecloth, good with the bad, but you gotta wonder how much easier it is now.
Not sure whether those systems are also installed in the wilderness though. But it seems kinda likely that anybody thinking "I should derail a train for fun" might not bother driving into the wilderness when there's an alluring, convenient, seemingly unobserved stretch of the railway available nearby.
Edit: another thing that comes to mind is that you'd also have to find a low-visibility part of the railway, even in the wilderness — because otherwise the driver will just notice the obstacle and stop the train.
An improperly stored rail from a maintenance project derailed a NYC subway train in 2017: https://apnews.com/article/a6a01e5928f9478bab0d33f03260870e
Whether or not that's a problem in practice is not clear to me. Among others, taxis, construction vehicles, emergency vehicles, garbage and delivery trucks, municipal busses, school buses, bicycles, motorcycles, and vehicles in funeral processions all play by different rules than the average motorist.
This mostly doesn't cause disasters. Of course they're visibly different for the most part and make up a comparatively small percentage of traffic.
Ride hailing vehicles might be an interesting point of comparison: they're visibly similar to normal vehicles, comparatively common, and play by something resembling taxi rules.
For example, a speed limit sign could include the name of the road it controls, which would help reduce instances of cars suddenly slowing to 35 mph on the freeway when passing a sign on the frontage road.
It might also be useful for cases of (this is US-centric) yellow "advisory" speeds posted for, e.g., sharp curves. The machine-readable aspect might indicate how long the advisory speed applies (next 1000 ft) and why (sharp curve, hidden intersection, etc.)
That way even faking or destroying sign would be ineffective.
Would have to be updated during temporary situations (roadwork etc) tho
In theory you could add an HMAC (or similar) signature to the QR code. It would be bigger, but if cars maintained a DB of state DOT public keys, you could mitigate this somewhat.
Then you’d also have to worry about duplicate codes, but at least they wouldn’t be “fake”. Maybe even add lat/long coordinates to the code… again, more data, more pixels required, but it would make sure the signs are roughly in the right place. Which doesn’t seem all that feasible to require construction crews to put the right sign in the right place.
Logistically this doesn’t seem all that promising.
Given the phone's camera, compass and GPS, validating that the sign has been installed as specified (location, facing direction) is almost trivial.
I wouldn't bet on "no evidence" for the autonomous vehicle. It may record telemetry and video.
For the novel, probably neither of the above is recorded in high enough resolution.
Thinking of subliminal messages inserted into old movies here, just flashing something up for a hundredth of a second, doing it enough that a system detects something... but not enough that video filmed at 30fps really shows it, and that telemetry doesn't really capture it.
All the telemetry would show is "car thought X", and the video would appear to be clean. What isn't known from is "why" car thought something.
Perhaps most fun to think about in a Dan Brown-style NSA capabilities combined with Peter Watts' Blindsight's near-total-imformation perceptual-cognitive shenanigans kind of way.
[1]: https://medium.com/self-driving-cars/adversarial-traffic-sig...
Could have both color and shape. Make red hexagon, yellow square for example. or really any recognizable shape
Aside, well, the video the car recorded...
>Plot for a future novel: Project light onto surfaces from a moving vehicle to make another car behave in a way that kills the occupants. No evidence can be found at the scene as to why the car killed the occupants.
Problem with this is that self-driving cars like teslas will probably have cameras all over them
So we have some cars that rely on visual information for self-driving.
And we have some cars that can project onto the landscape, modifying visual information.
What could go wrong!
I only have a Volvo, in the UK, and it has one of those systems that tell you the last road sign that it has seen. That information then can optionally control warnings, speed limiter, etc. I typically do use the speed limiter, it works well... until I was behind a car that had a 20mph bumper sticker on the back. Then my car kept insisting that 20mph was the speed limit. I was on a motorway.
I also think of that Tesla stop light truck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch7CJEQ2kz0 , and this https://uk.motor1.com/news/449020/video-tesla-model-3-traffi... , and this https://techxplore.com/news/2020-02-road-self-driving-car-hi...
Plot for a future novel: Project light onto surfaces from a moving vehicle to make another car behave in a way that kills the occupants. No evidence can be found at the scene as to why the car killed the occupants.