News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ValentineC on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:20AM (#32799018)
One problem I see with this is that if one's email somehow gets onto a spammer's list, there's likely no way to change their email address, since it's presumably formed from an ID number of some sort.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by ssivark on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:50PM (#32801194)
Changing an email address seems like a solution totally out of proportion to the pesky problem of spam. I can see many ways for the system to work effectively:

1. Have this "official" email only for communication with "state" entities, or some such filtered allow-list. It would be fantastic to have a high-SNR electronic channel for "all the important govt bureaucratic stuff". Folks could always forward mail to a unified inbox if they wish, but regardless they get an effective filtering tool.

2. For non allow-list entities, charge some trivial amount for every incoming mail that goes unread or gets flagged by a user as spam (or some such). I suspect this will quickly change the economics to make most spray-and-pray crap to become unviable.

In essence, as with any communication system, I think the most important design goal is to have high SNR (Signal-to-Noise Ratio) channels which we can suitably label for specific delineated intents. We shouldn't be treating the inbox as a monolith with all pieces of uniform importance (or dictated by the shiny content of emails); we should be able to leverage IT to have the system work in the user's interest -- it's a matter of setting up incentives/responsibilities.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by realityking on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:39AM (#32806784)
Germany has tried setting up a parallel, email-like system where it cost money to send messages to avoid spam. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/De-Mail

Uptake has been so limited, itβ€˜s essentially useless.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by numpad0 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:29PM (#32801006)
Yeah, and harassments are going to be huge problem as well. Full names displayed anywhere unless necessary, is generally a bad idea. It's not going to work - IF taken at full face value without further considerations.

That said, I think might make sense as an address system for signing and verification. It'd be nice if I could just sign into a local municipality or state-level server with a national ID to read notices and do verification, instead of walking to the city hall and twice in a week and uploading drivers_license.jpg to weird e-commerce websites on random occasions.

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by e2le on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:48PM (#32801179)
Ideally it would only be possible to receive mail from the government and a select few entities (bank, electricity provider, etc).

> presumably formed from an ID number of some sort.

One possible solution is that the address for an individual must be obtained from a directory before sending a mail. Allowing for the possibility of changing it in the future. Access to that information can then be granted/revoked by the individual as they see fit. Something similar to re:claimID.

https://www.gnunet.org/en/reclaim/tech.html

Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by smileybarry on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:59AM (#32799256)
Right, I didn't think of that, that practically seals it I guess.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by avivo on Sunday September 11, 2022 @01:01PM (#32801266)
Halfbaked thought: Have it cost half the amount as normal mail to receive email there. Perhaps also gov use is free, and users can whitelist specific domains or subdomains to be free.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by dpkirchner on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:50PM (#32804021)
Better yet, you could allow emails cryptographically signed by chosen entities (*.gov, power company, etc) and reject everything else.
Re:What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years? by Razengan on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:21AM (#32800373)
Fix those problems: Better spam protection, more stringent penalties for spammers.