But, if they did, would that imply that the state ought to provide a free home to anyone who needs it?
Similarly, there's no state requirement to have a smartphone - or even a phone number. I understand that citizens of the USA can qualify for a state-provided phone and number, but I think that's quite rare.
Given that there are a plethora of free email providers, why would the state step in to manipulate this market?
At least the state-registered address is required in many countries.
(Homeless people are still registered. The address might be a homelessness charity, or a whole city district.)
> Similarly, there's no state requirement to have a smartphone - or even a phone number. I understand that citizens of the USA can qualify for a state-provided phone and number, but I think that's quite rare.
True, also -- this is mostly based on my experience in Israel, not the USA, if that was accidentally implied. Here you do have some form of state-registered postal address (and can't remove, only change it), I don't know what homeless people have registered but from a brief check it's ignored if they're homeless. Instead, the city they're staying in handles it.
There's no smartphone requirement, but I'm not sure how they deal with someone who just doesn't have any phone, it's a requirement in a lot of auxiliary services.
> Given that there are a plethora of free email providers, why would the state step in to manipulate this market?
I thought that provisioning it with the relatively-new smart card IDs (i.e. certificate authentication) would allow for better starting security, less hacked accounts and such.
The so called “Obama phones”, not so rare…
They also have low-income landline programs, I believe, along with low-income home internet plans but I think the internet ones are for households with school age children judging by the radio ads I used to hear.
In some few countries & metro areas, people have decided to answer Yes to this question, so it’s not purely rhetorical.
Yes.
1. Have this "official" email only for communication with "state" entities, or some such filtered allow-list. It would be fantastic to have a high-SNR electronic channel for "all the important govt bureaucratic stuff". Folks could always forward mail to a unified inbox if they wish, but regardless they get an effective filtering tool.
2. For non allow-list entities, charge some trivial amount for every incoming mail that goes unread or gets flagged by a user as spam (or some such). I suspect this will quickly change the economics to make most spray-and-pray crap to become unviable.
In essence, as with any communication system, I think the most important design goal is to have high SNR (Signal-to-Noise Ratio) channels which we can suitably label for specific delineated intents. We shouldn't be treating the inbox as a monolith with all pieces of uniform importance (or dictated by the shiny content of emails); we should be able to leverage IT to have the system work in the user's interest -- it's a matter of setting up incentives/responsibilities.
Uptake has been so limited, it‘s essentially useless.
That said, I think might make sense as an address system for signing and verification. It'd be nice if I could just sign into a local municipality or state-level server with a national ID to read notices and do verification, instead of walking to the city hall and twice in a week and uploading drivers_license.jpg to weird e-commerce websites on random occasions.
> presumably formed from an ID number of some sort.
One possible solution is that the address for an individual must be obtained from a directory before sending a mail. Allowing for the possibility of changing it in the future. Access to that information can then be granted/revoked by the individual as they see fit. Something similar to re:claimID.
The mail system as it is is working. It has been for many years. It costs a non-significant amount of money to send mail, so this takes care of the spam problem: spam exists but isn't free so it isn't profitable. There's no need to have PKI or "personal certificates" infrastructure so even 80-year olds can receive and read mail.
I have a mailbox. The government is obligated to send stuff there. If I move, I can redirect my mail. I would hate to have a (new) obligation to check my "government-assigned" email box (protected by "PKI" or "personal certificate"), or face penalties for not doing that — in addition to my obligation to check my mailbox. My parents would never be able to take care of it, so it would fall (again) on me to check their email boxes as well.
Basically, a high SNR channel which can be delineated for specific intent. This can be controlled through allow-lists or whatever.
Even from the state's perspective, this seems like a very cheap solution to what must be a great administrative burden.
So: the same way you have a state-registered mailing address for official mail etc., you would have a state-registered email address, potentially @city-or-state.country-tld.
Of course you could use whatever email you want but rolling it out in the same process of legal ID means changing the default “paper mail” delivery to email, without having to just manually say “yes I want to receive emails instead” to everything.