I've come around a bit, after getting asked at an interview: "So, why no apply at Google?". Google doesn't align with my personal values. They contribute a great deal to our industry, they provide good jobs to a large number of people and they have a number of good products, like GCP.
My problem with Google is they reliance on ads. It's not a model I wish to support. It damages they primary product, search (well, I mean, their primary product is ads now), and damages their credibility and overall brand. We haven't been able to trust product like Chrome or Android for years.. That is they choice, but I don't have support it, or help them build these products. Not that I think they'd hire me.
But I don't hate Google, they're just not particular relevant to me anymore. Other search engines provide just as good searches. DuckDuckGo happens to be a little better and have a better interface than Bing or Ecosia, even if they're all "just Bing".
"Currently, the predominant business model for commercial search engines is advertising. The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users. For example, in our prototype search engine one of the top results for cellular phone is "The Effect of Cellular Phone Use Upon Driver Attention", a study which explains in great detail the distractions and risk associated with conversing on a cell phone while driving. This search result came up first because of its high importance as judged by the PageRank algorithm, an approximation of citation importance on the web [Page, 98].
It is clear that a search engine which was taking money for showing cellular phone ads would have difficulty justifying the page that our system returned to its paying advertisers. For this type of reason and historical experience with other media [Bagdikian 83], we expect that advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers."
This thread has made me realize what I don't like about the ad model Google uses (as well as others) beyond the noise.
It totally disconnects the user, such that the user is not actually cared about.
I got that academically but reading the vociferous defense of the fake "how many results you get" figure, I now see that it is inherent. That bit of information benefits no one. It doesn't serve the user. So why keep it? Branding. But its a lie. It's a little lie in terms of who it hurts, but it's common lie. So what else does Google not care about due to the model it uses?
That's just plain false. Perhaps better stated is you're tolerant to the results provided by alternatives.
I tried DDG for a few months and found myself having to re-run my query on Google 60-70% of the time. It was an annoying experience.
I think it's subjective. If 90% of your results are ads, then it's not actually better. What I believe it boils down to is what you search for, and slightly how you search. Personally I'm at a point now that if DDG can't find something, then neither can Google. The difference is that Google will yank out the primary keyword, if it thinks that will yield results, but those are obviously always wrong.
Some things are unsearchable on bother DDG and Google, topics like weightloss, have just been SEO'ed to death and are no longer available online. Others maybe two ads on DDG, but an entire page on Google.
Another better system? Look at the early days of Google, they never would have gotten off the ground without very generous support from academia and specifically their university. What if it had been kept a university-based product?
And yes, it could have reached its current search capacity and still remained a Stanford-based initiative. Stanford has the resources. We might not have gotten any of the other google products out of that, but Google seems to cancel them all anyway, so I don't see a huge difference.
Stanford's endowment is ~30 billion. Google's CapEx is ~20 billion a year and has been for the last 4 years or so. You can weasel about exactly how much of that is attributable to search as opposed to other initiatives, (but even if you look back a decade to when Google was mostly search, it was running a CapEx of ~5 billion/year). So even making pretty favorable estimations, you'd be looking at Stanford being bankrupt around now.
Where I think companies, such as Google or Meta, goes off the deep end, is the amount of money you can realistically extract from advertising, without compromising your product. Both Google and Meta (much to my surprise) are extremely wealthy, but at the cost of what I'd call decency or morale. Both could have fine products and successful business, but somewhat smaller, and be financed by ads.
If you look back that the original Google ads, where they not successful? They certainly seemed to pay the bills back them. My point is: If your company is financed by advertising, you need to accept that there's a limit to your potential growth, if you still want to be view in an overall positive light.
Ditto Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, etc.
Research is part of my job. I routinely find things on Google that I circle back to later to check up on and find that they've disappeared (not things disparaging to anyone that one would be motivated to get off of google, talking about things just disappearing for inexplicable reasons).
For the first time in a decade, during the past year I have started using alternative search engines because the quality of Google results is bad.
Of things which were a top result a year ago but now show on page 20?
What domains are you searching on??? Google explicitly personalized your search results, which means it is intentionally presenting different results with every search.
Google might be your current best option, but that doesn't discredit the poster's view.
I didn't say Google was the best for everyone all of the time, just for me most of the time. I just didn't agree that anyone that uses Google hasn't carefully evaluated the quality of the results: I intentionally made an alternative my default and, despite it being harder for me to use Google now, I still fall back to it more often than not.
And like I said, it's not uncommon to find something on Google one day and have it just gone six months later.
> javascript:(function(){$('.js-search-input').val('!g '+$('.js-search-input').val());$('.js-search-form').submit();})()
I tried Kagi, DDG, Bing and Brave Search. I was surprised that I kept getting good results from Brave. Still using it and generally don’t need to look elsewhere for most searches.
The others were more of a mixed bag.
Agreed. I'm expecting the Brave Index to let me down almost every time I use it, however it does a pretty good job.
I don't find the same results, but I see good results.
Take the last search ("bronze patina thickness"), where I wanted to know how thick a typical bronze patina is. The first brave result is a hardware store in Spokane (not even my state!) that sells door latches. The rest of the page is SEO content about watches.
The first result on Google links a paper and the results excerpt tells me 40-50um, up to 70um with prolonged exposure. The performance still isn't close for me despite the clear decline in Google search quality over the years.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patina
2. https://www.adamsbronze.com/bronze-patinas/
3. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/materials-science/patin...
3a. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S23524...
4. https://www.corrosionpedia.com/important-facts-you-might-not...
5. https://www.accurateimageinc.com/CutMetals/Finish_CutBrnzPat...
Not a bit of it. I go out of my way to use DDG and it's almost always adequate. I said "almost."
I haven't tried the others you mentioned.
Edit: I just signed up for and tried Kagi. Strangely it seems to do well for searches based on my current physical location (despite never explicitly granting it permission to make use of that) but if I qualify my questions with "in America", not so well. But definitely better than DDG/Brave.
One thing I like about Google tho is their Knowledge Graph[0] because I can type keywords like time, temperature or convert in the search box and Google will do this small task for me. I see it as a set of little web apps on top of Google which help us users to automate our tasks.
[0] https://support.google.com/knowledgepanel/answer/9787176?hl=...
Every person doing a search is a data point. Every result they go to is a signal. You can use that information to do a better job of providing relevant hits to good quality websites.
Google is good -> gets more traffic -> gets more signals -> Google gets better faster.
Everyone could do that. But Google gets the most traffic. They have the most popular browser. The most popular phone OS on earth. And they pay for that same advantage from the only other popular phone/tablet OS.
If someone else was the default search on iOS they could improve much faster than they do today and be a bigger threat to Google.
So Google pays.
Even with some small percent of Google's search results, Bing must have a lot of eyes and I suspect it's declined in the fashion of Google - trying to squeeze every dime of monetization out of each result.
The thing is, the Internet has facilitated the creation of a world of unlimited competition where no institution wants or can afford to trade squeezing out maximum profits now for building a better future they could benefit from.
I'm not so sure about that. I curiously had to use Bing to find more information about this. Google kept showing me old news or this exact article.
Is that with Netflix swapped with Microsoft? If that's the case, we might as well change the entire acronym to GAMMA to account for the Facebook -> Meta rename.
"FAANG is an acronym for the five best-performing American tech stocks in the market"
Around 2000, it was Microsoft, Intel, Dell, Cisco
Later, around 2007, it was Apple, RIMM (Research in Motion/Blackberry), Google, Amazon
Source: https://247wallst.com/media/2007/06/06/cramers_new_fou/
Meta
Microsoft
Alphabet
Apple
Amazon
Netflix
I think my cocktail of degoogled Google products + adblock solutions + being that person who doesn't care about privacy has made Google 'fine'.
I avoid using Google products unless they are FOSS. I'm not going to get screwed by "play music" or similar again.
Out of FAAMG, I think I like Google the best. But that doesn't say much.