Re:Queen Elizabeth II has died
by denkmoon on Thursday September 08, 2022 @10:06PM
(#32774454)
Except I do live here, and it's patently ridiculous to say The Commonwealth of Australia is anything but an invention of European settlers. Of which Queen Elizabeth II was the Head of State for 57% of its existence. Which is the context of this comment thread.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Queen Elizabeth II has died
by batiudrami on Thursday September 08, 2022 @10:13PM
(#32774507)
It didn’t say “The Commonwealth it Australia’s existence” it said 57% of Australia’s history which I maintain is fundamentally incorrect.
However, I think there is nothing further to be gained here as we would be arguing semantics.
Common sense would dictate that GP is talking about the country not the continent, as continents typically do not have heads of state :)
While that is true, it's not typically how the phrase "Australia's history" is interpreted.
It's common for "Australia's history" to refer to pre-colonisation in addition to the last couple of hundred years.
This is almost certainly because Australians see the country and the continent as 'the same' for all intents and purposes.