News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by renewiltord on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:18AM (#32746633)
This really sucks. I don't mean to diminish it. But

> Since he was traveling and was relying on @Citibank, he was screwed.

Does anyone actually do this? I don't know anyone who'd rely on a bank. You just have like 2 or 3 credit cards. Pre-war, one of my friends was actually in Russia and lost their wallet, and Visa (yes, Visa, not the bank) actually hand-delivered him the card. Blew my mind.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by maxbond on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:38AM (#32748111)
The modern world is just full of dumb traps like this, and I personally doubt I know the half of them.

Don't rely on gmail/Google Drive, they might arbitrarily block you with no recourse. (This one I've known about for years, but have yet to find the time to properly address.)

Don't rely on a single bank, they might arbitrarily block you with no recourse. (This one was news to me.)

Et cetera.

The thing is, addressing each of these means first knowing about it, then deciding to act, then actually investing the energy. All of this requires technical proficiency and time that people may simply not have. What I want to know is, why have we built so many footguns, and how can we start disarming them? Why is technology moving us to a Kafka story instead of a Star Trek story?

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by leppr on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:19AM (#32748757)
> Why is technology moving us to a Kafka story instead of a Star Trek story?

That's a problem which has nothing to do with technology itself. Technology makes providing support cheaper, so if the only changing variable was adding more technology, we would be getting better support, not worst.

The problem is cultural individualism. People give too much power to centralized entities, and don't respect the paramount importance of free market competition in accountability. A typical argument is that technology causes this centralization, but it's simply not true. For each service, there almost always exists both centralized options, and decentralized open-source ones. It's on users to go above the individualistic perspective and chose the option that's right not only for their own individual needs, but also for their community.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by maxbond on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:51AM (#32749396)
I agree that the technology is capable of creating many sorts of worlds, and that it's a series of choices that has lead us to this one and not a better one. But I disagree that it is possible for individuals to simply change their behavior and create that world using their collective purchasing power. This arrangement works well for the companies and investors that create the options consumers may choose from, and they have and continue to offer the set of options that match their preferences. To take the example of Google, and they are not unique here simply particularly egregious, it is apparent that they are completely unwilling to offer a human-powered support facility that is able to make complex decisions and accommodate unique situations. Eg, I imagine we've all seen stories on HN about Chrome extension developers being kicked off the app store and being stuck in an infinite chat loop with an AI, as they struggled to reach the _single_ human being[1] who may be able to help them.

That's not something we can fix by making different choices in the browser marketplace, which increasingly is just Chrome wearing different wigs. Even if we solved it in the case of browsers, this is a systemic issue across not only companies, but industries. Fixing this would mean something more fundamental than individuals changing their preferences to prioritize nonhostile software. It would require society at large agreeing to change it's priorities so that good options could be presented to them in the first place.

> A typical argument is that technology causes this centralization, but it's simply not true.

I think when people say this, "technology" is best understood as "the technology industry" or "technology, the social phenomenon" rather than "technology, the artifacts of engineering." I don't entirely agree that technology is amoral (not that you claimed this), but I think that's true enough for a first approximation. But when people say "technology causes centralization" (or "technology causes X" generally) they mean, "technology, as it is implemented in our society, given that it doesn't exist in a vacuum," and that has moral dimensions for sure.

[1] https://twitter.com/DotProto/status/1261155320740499456

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by leppr on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:04AM (#32750012)
Then we should use a less general word than "technology", because it becomes hard to reason about the problem and gives arguments to luddites who don't make the distinction. "Big tech" is short enough to be used in conversations.

> But I disagree that it is possible for individuals to simply change their behavior and create that world using their collective purchasing power. This arrangement works well for the companies and investors that create the options consumers may choose from, and they have and continue to offer the set of options that match their preferences.

With proper cultural norms, it will definitely be possible to change the current corporate technology landscape to be more user-friendly. Individual consumption habits have a huge impact, that's why the advertising industry is so big after all. Of course the necessary cultural change won't happen without a collective pain and awareness of the problem. I would say we might be half-way there in the pain dimension, and awareness of the benefits of open-source is growing everyday (what with the explosion of AI artwork thanks to the Stable Diffusion open-source release).

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by maxbond on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:45AM (#32750541)
I think we agree like 80% of the way, but that our disagreement is that I believe a political action is necessary to bring about the culture shift we're discussing, whereas you seem to believe that consumers can demand it in the marketplace. But I do agree that this movement is a nascent potential that seems to be developing and that it may well be realized.

I think there's an widely held conception, which comes from orthodox economics, that consumers demand something and then businesses respond to give them what they want. But I think that's wrong in a subtle but important way; it neglects the ability of business interests to shape what consumers demand.

For instance, I believe Facebook's pivot to Meta was precipitated by Apple's privacy update which limited FB's ability to conduct surveillance on iPhone. Presumably they feel it's an existential liability to rely on their competitor's platforms, because should a privacy-focused arms race break out between Apple and Google, it could destroy FB's ability to monetize their service. So they looked at the resources at their disposal, came up with a path forward which would result in the outcome they desired, and set about trying to convince the public they wanted a metaverse. This is a particularly ham-fisted effort, which makes it a good illustration, but I believe this is a more subtle element of many products. The key element here is that Facebook decided what product would best serve their interests, and tried to synthesize a demand, rather than responding to an organic demand for a metaverse.

This is why I don't think it's sufficient for consumers to simply change their behavior. Consumers cannot put options on the table; they can only express interests and hope they are fulfilled. Additionally business interests can collude much more easily than consumers, as there are fewer of them and their interests are better aligned. Consumers can demand nonhostile products, but at best they'll get differently-hostile products which address some of their concerns while innovating bold new ways to undermine the consumer. Something like, we've stopped shipping DRM with games because we know you don't like it, but we've also moved to a games-as-a-service model where you can't play without connecting to our servers, so we've actually ended up with even more control over your ability to play. It's sort of like a chess game where black has two rows of pawns. The only winning move is to change what game you're playing.

> Then we should use a less general word than "technology".

When it comes to language, I'm a descriptivist. I neither agree nor disagree that this is a bad word choice, my only claim is about what people mean. A framing you may appreciate more is, swapping "technology" for "the social institution of technology" (I think "Big Tech" isn't quite right to swap in, as it excludes, say, technology used by the government or intelligence agencies) is the steel man of the argument, and we ought to consider the merits of the stronger version of the argument and avoid arguing about the semantics of words.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by ThinBold on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:33AM (#32747173)
I (and I assume many do) buy flight tickets with a credit card so at least one bank knows you are traveling. Never have I had any problem when traveling. But there is one time I wanted to wire myself from Bank1 to Bank2, got blocked, called to unblock, and got blocked again immediately after I attempt the same transaction. Have to goto a Bank1 branch and brainstorm what to do and they ended up giving me a "bank check" (what's that???) only for me to walk to a Bank2 branch to deposit.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by Hextinium on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:32AM (#32747615)
For small but significant amounts (less than like 10k) it is significantly simpler to just get a bankers check for moving money between accounts between banks. Walk into one branch, get a check, go to the other branch, money moved! Definitely not ideal if you are doing it frequently but if you are closing an account it's very simple.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by paganel on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:33AM (#32747625)
> Does anyone actually do this? I don't know anyone who'd rely on a bank. You just have like 2 or 3 credit cards.

I only have one debit card available, I'm from Europe. That's why whenever I travel I also carry cash with me.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by Psychlist on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:40AM (#32747235)
You know 18 year olds with two or three credit cards? That seems like a different risk to me.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by renewiltord on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:44AM (#32747264)
Hmm, I must have missed that. Makes sense to have fewer then. Though when I was traveling as a young 'un, my parents gave me straight cash which I carried appropriately secreted away.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by jesterson on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:34AM (#32747635)
> I don't know anyone who'd rely on a bank

Imagine suddenly all your bank accounts are blocked. Do you have a plan for this?

> . Pre-war, one of my friends was actually in Russia and lost their wallet, and Visa (yes, Visa, not the bank) actually hand-delivered him the card.

Little known, but it's actually standard feature for CC starting from some class. Used it twice - once bank blocked CC and I figured it in airport, another time I lost the CC.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by raverbashing on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:59AM (#32747368)
He apparently was travelling inside the US, which makes the story even more absurd
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by jeroenhd on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:19AM (#32748759)
I have a debit card and a credit card. The credit card is for American companies and for backups during holidays. I do everything using my single debit card, including getting money out of foreign ATMs. My credit card comes from the same company I hold a debit card with so if the bank screws me over, I'm screwed.

Yet, I do not fear getting screwed over. Every time I hear about the ways American banks will screw over their customers I'm thankful I do not live in the USA.

The American banking system is corrupted and horribly outdated to the point where consumers need to practice defensive financing (and things like tactical debt gathering to accumulate a credit score with a shady financial megacorporation), but that's not necessary in every country. With the right people-oriented regulations and incentives, banks can be better.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by smcl on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:44AM (#32746800)
I don't have a credit card, which is pretty typical here, so I always travel with just cash and debit cards (I have a couple of accounts). But if what you describe is standard - i.e. you get very good service in an emergency - a credit card does sound like a good idea
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by Semaphor on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:21AM (#32747995)
I have a credit card for bonuses and certain benefits like when renting a car, but as it’s AMEX I need my debit card with me anyway as the acceptance rate is about 70% (of places even taking non-girocard cards) here in Germany. As I automatically pay it off every month and enter all transactions in YNAB, it has no drawbacks.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by brewdad on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:26AM (#32747115)
As an American, 2 credit cards should be the bare minimum. I carry 4 that I use regularly and a 5th that sits as a "break glass in case of emergency". They all get paid off every month, so it costs me nothing.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by ithinkso on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:54AM (#32747334)
Nowadays I can't imagine travelling without Wise (former transferwise) card. I think Revolut also gives you cards but I have not used them personally. I'm using my bank just to pre-pay Wise account when needed
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by kergonath on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:57AM (#32747821)
> I think Revolut also gives you cards but I have not used them personally.

Yes. I use Revolut for that exact purpose.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by Mashimo on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:13AM (#32747937)
I only have one bank with one card. Until now I never had the need for more.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by Tempest1981 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:48AM (#32748574)
Kids usually can't even get 1 credit card in the US. Any tips?
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by xiphias2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:12AM (#32746999)
I don't travel anywhere without Bitcoin. It saved me many times when banks created arbitrary problems. (I use travala.com and cheapair.com)
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by smcl on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:50AM (#32747776)
In what situations has Bitcoin saved you, and where (country, city)? The reason I ask is because I cannot recall seeing any shops which would accept bitcoin, and the last ATM that bought BTC for cash I knew of in my locale disappeared a little while ago.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by xiphias2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:18AM (#32747976)
I usually travel with $10000 cash with me and use Bitcoin to pay for hotels and flights. Shops accept USD at a lot of places around the world.

I travel for half year every winter to south / central america from Europe, and there have been cases when my bank cancelled my credit card because of technical problems with contactless payments even though I didn't need contactless.

Another time Revolut just blocked my access to their app for a few days until I could prove where I got the money from.

Another time a bank blocked my card because I was travelling and they thought it's a fraud.

Depending on banks for long travels far from my home is scary, so I make sure I always have enough BTC and cash to survive.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by 988747 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:46AM (#32748160)
> Another time a bank blocked my card because I was travelling and they thought it's a fraud.

I was traveling recently and when trying to pay for a hotel room the transaction was declined. I needed to call my bank to explain that I am traveling, so they tuned down their anti-fraud alerts. Thankfully, one phone call was all it took to resolve this.

However, this block was only triggered because the transaction in question was relatively high amount ($1500), the very same card would still work perfectly for small transactions.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by smcl on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:06AM (#32748703)
You're brave to have $10k in cash on you!
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by blisterpeanuts on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:37AM (#32748104)
That’s a lot of cash to travel with.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by 988747 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:50AM (#32748188)
Yep, I would never carry this much on me. In most countries you need to declare such amount when crossing the border, and explain why you have it. And of course in the US any cop on the street can just take it from you, with no recourse.

I would carry 500-1000 USD at most.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by lambertsimnel on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:38AM (#32748498)
Exactly. Airports in the European Union have signs warning passengers about such rules for carrying large sums of cash.

When carrying €10,000 or more into or out of the European Union, you must complete a cash declaration. In practice, I'd feel uncomfortable carrying more than I'd be happy to count while hurrying for a plane, especially if the value were close to the limit and in a currency other than Euros. (Other currencies are explicitly included in the EU rules, which makes sense, not least because some EU member states use other currencies instead of Euros.) I don't know whether you can complete a cash declaration in case the exchange rate changes such that the value of your cash crosses the threshold, but if you can't then maybe carrying cash close to the limit would attract a lot of attention from customs or airport security (because it might look like you're violating the rules until the cash had been counted and the interest rate checked).

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by xiphias2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:54AM (#32748611)
,,When carrying €10,000 or more''

This is not true, you can carry 10000 EUR without declaration, you just neet to declare if you carry more (I look at the regulation and of course eurusd before I start my travel for winter).

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by lambertsimnel on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:07AM (#32748707)
I stand corrected. Weirdly, the European Union website (which I didn't read carefully enough earlier) contradicts itself on that point:

"Entering or leaving the EU after 3 June 2021 with cash or certain valuable items worth over EUR 10 000? ... "all travellers entering or leaving EU territory are already obliged to complete a cash declaration when carrying EUR 10 000 or more"

https://taxation-customs.ec.europa.eu/customs-4/prohibitions...

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by weberer on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:30AM (#32748440)
There is recourse. The USA has due process.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by 988747 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:39AM (#32748504)
One thing about civil asset forfeiture is that it is an action against the property, not the person. So, the cash itself is a "suspect" not you. You can't even file a complaint, because you are not a party to the whole case.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by xiphias2 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:06AM (#32748294)
Sure, I use fake suncream holder to hold the cash, and it's the limit that doesn't need to be declared on the border. I'm of course not the average traveler, most people stay in long term stays who go for long travels.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by leppr on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:25AM (#32748792)
While traveling through Europe this summer, I noticed many small currency exchange shops process cryptocurrencies. What surprised me most is that many shops handled a wide selection of what I would call shitcoins, not just BTC and ETH.
Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by winternett on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:39AM (#32747229)
Great trying to spend it after a value plummet I tell you what!

Everything is terrible. The US dollar is on par with the EURO though.

Re:Citibank may lock bank accounts for 45 days if breach sus... by renewiltord on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:45AM (#32747267)
Fascinating! Thanks for sharing that.