Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by goatcode on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:08PM
(#32743226)
In nature, it makes no sense for a virus to be both highly transmissible and highly deadly. Any such virus would cease to exist after having run amok in such a way in its hosts. Therefore, any extremely deadly virus should be looked at with similarly extreme criticism, especially if / when it adapts and becomes a better behaving parasite.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by tedivm on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:17PM
(#32743311)
Nature, and evolution, don't follow motive based logic. Random mutations that are temporarily beneficial but are detrimental to the long term do happen.
To put it another way, a cell mutates based off of random chance. It doesn't have desires. We only have to go back as far as 1918 to see an example of a virus that could not have been engineered and was highly transmissible and highly deadly. As you say, in the long term that doesn't work out- the virus in that case mutated to be much more mild- which is why you won't see viruses like that surviving for long. But it still doesn't make sense to assume viruses evolve according to a motivation based logic.
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by Moodles on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:25PM
(#32743401)
Obviously the person you’re responding to doesn’t think covid is conscious and has motivations…
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by goatcode on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @10:24AM
(#32751029)
> temporarily beneficial
This was the crux of my point.
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by tedivm on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:06PM
(#32755019)
Then your point makes no sense.
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by omniglottal on Thursday September 08, 2022 @08:27AM
(#32764508)
Please work on your reading comprehension and stop being rude.
Re:Covid: Summary of lab-origin hypothesis
by HillRat on Thursday September 08, 2022 @09:37AM
(#32765318)
You're assuming that viruses don't have natural reservoirs. For example, viral hemorrhagic fevers, particularly filovirus VHFs, are both highly transmissible and highly deadly -- accounting for their history of rapid, fast-growing, and quickly-diminishing epidemics amongst humans -- but have stable zoonotic reservoirs that allow them to circulate freely across those populations. (Bats' unique immune system, like camelids, makes them a particularly good evolutionary proving ground for viral evolution, so they serve as a reservoir and a source of ongoing viral mutations.)