News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:05PM (#32739963)
30 years late to the party, and in a format that is inaccessible to anyone just casually browsing the web but needs to be built using 40+ year old build systems, hosted on a server that apparently cannot handle the "gentle" influx of HN readers...

Sounds just like any other GNU project ;-)

I mean I seriously admire RMS's endurance and persistence, and I'm looking forward to this manual, I'm sure it'll be great, but is this really what GCC needs most? A new language manual?

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jolmg on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:36PM (#32741226)
> 30 years late to the party.

Why 30 years late? Their earlier manual[1] already covers the C language as standardized 20 years ago with C99. This new one makes mention of at least C11. If it doesn't include features of a later standard, it's at most like 10 years late if you can expect anyone to write a publication like this in a single year.

> in a format that is inaccessible to anyone just casually browsing the web but needs to be built using 40+ year old build systems

Nothing wrong with software being old. It's stable and reliable. Also, I'm not sure the format has any competition, taking into account feature parity.

[1] https://www.gnu.org/software/gnu-c-manual/gnu-c-manual.html

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by tjr on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:39PM (#32742192)
So one remark with respect to being late to the party and writing a publication like this in a single year... I was the main author on that [1] link there. Richard contacted me ten years ago (in January 2012, as I recall) about his new forthcoming book. I ended up helping him with the new book, but I figured that with this new one coming out, no reason to do much more with the one I had written.

So indeed, it never got past coverage of C99 and other GCC extensions circa C99. I honestly did not expect that it was going to be ten years before his new book was finished, or I might would have put more work into the one that I started.

Oh well! The new one is finally out. :-)

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by stjohnswarts on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:05PM (#32745914)
It's funny how people can't appreciate free things. It's one thing to provide constructive criticism and another to scoff.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by majewsky on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @10:52AM (#32751421)
This manual is not as "free" as it could be: For the vast majority of its target audience, it requires effort to get it into a readable format. I would consider a HTML rendition of the same TexInfo files more free (for a certain definition of "free" at least).
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:07PM (#32742551)
> This new one makes mention of at least C11

Indeed, I haven't spotted these on my first glance over the document. So yeah, it's probably only 10-15 years late when it comes out. I'm still amazed that RMS is taking C11 into account, I would have guessed he prefered C99

> Nothing wrong with software being old. It's stable and reliable.

I'm sure you're having fun driving your old Ford Country Squire, watching television on an old RCA TV set and using a rotary phone to call friends and family ;-)

Of course you are right in that there is nothing inherently wrong with using old software. And yes, it might be more stable than the shiniest newest tech. But there are middle grounds that exist as well that get you nifty features or quality-of-life improvements, and don't intimidate newcomers that much than having to first find out what that CVS is that GNU is still using in some areas ;-)

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jolmg on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:27PM (#32742760)
> I'm sure you're having fun driving your old Ford Country Squire, watching television on an old RCA TV set and using a rotary phone to call friends and family ;-)

I said software. Have you stopped using 30 year old Linux, Python, Photoshop, etc.? They're not that much newer than Texinfo. Or do you think they should be discarded when they hit 40? MS Excel is about the same age as Texinfo. I guess Excel is obsolete now.

You don't need to make a whole new product to introduce improvements in software like you do with hardware.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @03:43AM (#32747717)
Improvements happen in discrete steps, for hardware the same as for software.

If you build a new car by taking an existing one and swapping out the engine, is it still the same car? What if you also swap the body. And the drive train?

The same is true for software. In Linux, almost everything has been swapped out"from what it was 30 years before. Device drivers, Memory manager, you name it. Is it still the same old Linux? Probably not. Just because the name didn't change doesn't mean it's the same product.

However, take a look at what changes have been done in GNU Make in recent years. Other than a few bugfixes there was nothing of substance. GNU TexInfo? the same. This is what I mean by "old". I get the whole "never change a running system" thing, or "when it works exactly like it should, why change it"... But this is a surefire way to make sure your software is lost and abandoned when the last 2 developers working on it quit.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jolmg on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @04:40PM (#32756495)
> However, take a look at what changes have been done in GNU Make in recent years. Other than a few bugfixes there was nothing of substance. GNU TexInfo? the same. This is what I mean by "old".

There's a clear scope. It makes sense to only have bugfixes, specially since it's FOSS.

> I get the whole [...] "when it works exactly like it should, why change it"...

Why complain about it then?

> But this is a surefire way to make sure your software is lost and abandoned when the last 2 developers working on it quit.

This is FOSS. You seem to think of this like for-profit software. Development in FOSS is typically done for the developer(s) own need and shared for free with the world on the off-chance that someone else finds it useful, because some people are cool like that. There's no for-profit incentive to make it as widely applicable as possible nor to retain market.

In the case of Texinfo, it's utility is mostly for development in the GNU space. It's essentially to write documentation once and turn it into nicely formed PDFs, single-page HTML, multi-page HTML, and info manuals, each with their format-specific functionality for table of contents and indices fulfilled. That idealizes their documentation for print media, web, and local access.

Do you have a use for that? No? Why do you care if it's lost and abandoned? Yes? Then contribute whatever it is you seem to think it's lacking.

Don't worry about loss of market. The only market developers owe anything to is themselves.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by sanroot99 on Thursday September 08, 2022 @03:06PM (#32770461)
Love this drama ,as always
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Longlius on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:17PM (#32740937)
I mean, it's not even done yet. He doesn't really want anyone reading it yet. I imagine once it's complete we'll have the standard HTML single page, HTML multi-page, PDF, etc. options you see with all other GNU publications.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by steveklabnik on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:49PM (#32742321)
If he doesn't want anyone to read it, why does this announcement say

> Please report any flaws, including any passage that is unclear or hard to understand.

?

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by DiggyJohnson on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:25PM (#32742732)
If you add a bit of nuance to your interpretation of GP’s comment this will make a whole lot of sense.

It’s pre-publish. That’s all they’re saying. And that’s clearly the case, it seems.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by deanmen on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:12PM (#32743264)
Yes they should put the built versions online when it's done.

Right now you can generate a PDF or HTML from the texi

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by davexunit on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:29PM (#32741120)
The link is to the git hosting platform for GNU that contains the texinfo source and seems more intended as an announcement to those that want to get in early and build the manual for themselves. I'm sure it will ultimately be posted in html form on gnu.org, like every other manual.

I'm honestly shocked to see rms using git. He used to refuse to use it.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by tjr on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:10PM (#32742568)
Yes, although, while actually working on the manual, we didn't use Git. We passed diffs back and forth over email.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:18PM (#32743319)
Perl is used to convert texi files to html, plaintext, pdf, etc.^1

How to get the perl script for coverting texi

On Linux install texinfo

On BSD install text2html

Below is a tiny script to make this manual as a 639K text file called "c.txt" to read with less(1) and edited with vi(1), according to personal preferences.^2 Your preferences may differ. We may be different people using different computers and different software.

1. https://www.nongnu.org/texi2html/ https://texfaq.org/FAQ-texinfo

2. Example personal preferences: Avoid git where it's not needed. Use links browser to dump html to text. Indent text at least 4 spaces, leave large right margins (here, column width = 70). Use curl only for HN examples. IRL, use tnftp.

   #!/bin/sh
   set -v;
   x0=c-intro-and-ref.git;
   x1=https://git.savannah.nongnu.org/cgit/;
   test -d $x0||mkdir $x0;cd $x0||exit;
   for x2 in Makefile c.texi cpp.texi fdl.texi fp.texi texinfo.tex;do 
   echo url=$x1$x0/plain/$x2;
   echo output=$x2;
   echo user-agent=\"\";
   done|curl -K/dev/stdin -s;
   case $(uname) in :)
   ;;*BSD) texi2html --no-headers --no-split --html c.texi
   ;;Linux) makeinfo --no-headers --no-split --html c.texi
   esac;
   links -width 70 -dump .html \
   |sed '/^ *Link:/d;/^ *\*/s/\*//;s/^/    /;/Jump to: /{N;N;d;}' > c.txt;
   # personal preference: uninstall perl to conserve space;
   exec less c.txt;
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:26PM (#32803860)
s/text2html/texi2html/
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by mr_gibbins on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:47PM (#32740509)
Agreed. This sounds like the kind of thing I'd like to fill my Tuesday evening with, but had to refer to the instructions from the kind commenter below to install packages to build the LaTeX file since my Texmaker refused point-blank to have anything to do with it.

Of course it's Linux only, so means using WSL on my Windows laptop.

Managed to open the file, no instructions whatsoever for finding a compiler other than 'get the GCC one'. Okay. Found the mirror, downloaded it and just now reading the installation manual. Yes, it's a manual, basically. Two dozen prerequisite packages to install by hand before I do anything else.

It's guaranteed not to work on WSL so I'll have to spend an hour or two just getting a compiler up and running, that's assuming it works at all and I don't just have to fire up a Debian VM and start again.

I get C is hard, and is supposed to be hard, but it's like GNU are going out of their way to make this intentionally more difficult than it needs to be.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by maxlybbert on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:20PM (#32740999)
I’m sure they’ll eventually make a PDF and HTML pages easily available on their site, like they have for plenty of other manuals. This announcement is more along the lines of “if you want to help us with the finishing touches, here’s where to go.”
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Koshkin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:51PM (#32742351)
> C is hard, and is supposed to be hard

I don't know why anyone would say that. C remains a simple little language. It is programming, especially the kind C is used for, that is hard.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by cies on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:06PM (#32742540)
Exactly. C was a lot easier than the alternatives back when it got invented. It's simplicity that characterizes a good design.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by I_dev_outdoors on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:14PM (#32740895)
You are kinda getting of the beaten path here and you seem to know it.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by zauguin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:55PM (#32743086)
I don't know TeXmaker, but it's highly unlikely that you can't compile this with any normal TeX distribution.

It's not a LaTeX file though, it's a TeXinfo file but since it includes the texinfo.tex file it shouldn't matter, you can run it like any plain TeX document. It uses texindex but that's included both in TeX Live and MikTeX, so you probably have it installed already. Just run on some kind of command line

> pdftex c.texi

> texindex c.cp

> texindex c.fn

> pdftex c.texi

> pdftex c.texi

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by kazinator on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:35PM (#32741216)
If we were were to identify what GCC needs most, do you necessarily want RMS on that task?

There are enough people that someone else can work on what GCC needs most, while RMS hacks on a manual.

GCC is a bloated mess with 50+ megabyte back-end executables; in my opinion, what it needs most is to go on some kind of diet.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by cies on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:04PM (#32742521)
> is this really what GCC needs most

Nah. It's what some programmers need most, especially those that cannot/willnot pirate a manual, or want to be able to give back improvements as they study it.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by tbodt on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:43PM (#32743603)
All GNU documentation is written in this format. But here they seem to have neglected the standard procedure of converting to HTML before publishing...
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by mhh__ on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:06PM (#32741735)
If it keeps him away from the rest of GCC then it's good for GCC.

Harsh but realistic.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by deanmen on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:13PM (#32743278)
It's a standard TeX file built using the GNU texinfo macros, it can be converted to a PDF using TeX or a HTML, docbook, or GNU info page using `makeinfo`
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by JJMcJ on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:55PM (#32743089)
Make, tex, dvipdf, makeinfo? Still in active use.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by deanmen on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:09PM (#32743236)
It is possible to convert the TexInfo file to a PDF
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jacooper on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:47PM (#32740504)
Man, the FSF and the GNU project need a new refresh and new blood in them ASAP.

everything from their projects, to their websites is outdated and distant from how people actually use tech everyday.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by davexunit on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:21PM (#32741012)
Here's an anecdote:

In 2014, as part of my job as fsf's web developer (a new position at the time), I suggested moving gnu.org's version control from a private cvs repo (that requires passing a test to get access to) to a public git repo as a step towards attracting new contributors. The argument was simple: Not many new volunteers are coming in to work on gnu.org and very few know cvs any more. Making it operate more like a regular free software project that can receive patches from anyone and using the most popular version control system would lower the barrier to entry and improve transparency. It was viewed as a reasonable goal by the people I worked with at the fsf, but gnu has its own governance and the idea was met with strong resistance from all of the longtime gnu.org contributors, including rms. I even received an unpleasant off-list email (not from rms) because I was viewed as an outsider that doesn't know anything. So, that was the end of that little idea.

There is a glimmer of hope for gnu's future in subprojects such as guix, which is doing technically interesting work and has created a healthy community that welcomes newcomers. Can that positive energy take hold and spread to the rest of the project? We'll see.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by KennyBlanken on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:37PM (#32741251)
A former boss still tells people about the time he emailed an address at gnu.org to inform them that a mirror was broken, and made the mistake of using "linux", and got a page-long rant from Stallman himself about how it was "gnu/linux"

...and nobody fixed the FTP site.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by davexunit on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:58PM (#32742442)
I appreciate what rms did technically and philosophically back in the 70s and 80s, but he is just the worst public relations person ever.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by cies on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:10PM (#32742587)
> he is just the worst public relations person ever

he campaigned a lot in the 80s/90s too, creating a lot of exposure for his ideas.

i think we just have different expectations nowadays...

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by kube-system on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:06PM (#32742533)
I had the chance to speak with him in person once and he did a similar thing to me. I found that if you use a word he doesn't like, he'll just focus on that and ignore the content of your sentence.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by DharmaPolice on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:18AM (#32748366)
>I found that if you use a word he doesn't like, he'll just focus on that and ignore the content of your sentence

This makes it sound like RMS was ahead of the curve since this is the standard operating procedure for a lot of people these days.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by macintux on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:28PM (#32741099)
I still remember in 1996 searching for GNU online only to discover they weren’t running on their own domain, instead something buried on (IIRC) mit.edu.

I also couldn’t find any gcc binaries for Solaris online, had to steal a copy from my school’s IT administrator to help get a startup up and running.

They definitely have serious challenges with inertia.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by teddyh on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:49AM (#32749380)
Probably prep.ai.mit.edu. MIT does that kind of thing; It’s like tsx-11.mit.edu, the famous US Linux FTP mirror, which was, IIRC, originally Theodore Ts'o personal workstation at MIT.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by sidkshatriya on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:22PM (#32741027)
I equally detest websites which are extremely graphics and animation intensive. When I see a lot of graphics and presentation my mind goes: "Sales pitch upcoming. Be careful!!"

I actually like highly functional websites with a light touch that conveys sophistication. GNU's websites don't come in that category, of course.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jacooper on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:30PM (#32741153)
I'm not asking for something full of animations.

I'm just asking for something modern and useful, like GitHub and Gitea.

The total opposite of Savannah.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by pram on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:51PM (#32740569)
IIRC Stallman 'browses the web' with something like a cron job scraping URLs with Lynx, and then it emails him the output so he can peruse it later. This isn't a joke lol
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by davexunit on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:23PM (#32741033)
He did that for a long time, maybe still does for certain things for all I know, but he started using GNU IceCat (a firefox derivative) some years ago.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by bitwize on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:16PM (#32740923)
Given how intrusive, ad-encrusted, and potentially malware-encrusted the web is becoming, this sounds like one of those Stallman absurdities that make increasing amounts of sense the more you think on them.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by gaius_baltar on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:20PM (#32743345)
It is like that "Stallman was right" subreddit is getting righter and righter every day. Except that Stallman is under some kind of Cassandra Curse, so people ignore all the signs, even when they are repeated by persons more skilled in PR tactics.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by starkd on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:46PM (#32741390)
Exactly. We need characters like RMS to buck the trends, even if they come off as a*holes to us. And RMS was right about the danger of software not being under our control.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Joker_vD on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:15PM (#32741860)
Which is why RMS and FSF tried to get the software under their control. Thankfully, they are much less adept at it than the commercial firms, so that attempt ultimately failed.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by starkd on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:18PM (#32743321)
Not understanding how they did this. The movement merely supports a license that insists code is available to end users.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by bitwize on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @10:57AM (#32751491)
The FSF demands copyright assignation for all contributions to its projects. E.g., if you want your code to make it into Emacs, both you and your employer need to sign it over to the FSF.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by ydlr on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:11PM (#32740845)
That sounds... reasonable. There are some web-to-newsletter services that try to sell this feature.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by abawany on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:41PM (#32741317)
Sounds like a great way to prevent brain death brought about by the WMD (weapons of mental destruction) such as infini-scroll, etc.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Koshkin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:39PM (#32742202)
I used RSS to read HN up until Google killed their reader. (Being able to filter the feed by the post title was nice.)
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by AdmiralAsshat on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:59PM (#32740680)
I believe he used to print them out, so perhaps we should consider at least reading them via an email client to be some sort of progress.

Although I'm sure it was to be more "eco-friendly" than anything

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:39PM (#32741275)
I actually envy him for being able to do so.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by b3morales on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:31PM (#32741160)
Personally, most of the times I visit gnu.org I'm browsing the Emacs manuals and I do have to say I appreciate the simple HTML rendering. It makes them easy to read and navigate.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by krapp on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:06PM (#32740773)
>everything from their projects, to their websites is outdated and distant from how people actually use tech everyday.

It makes sense if you think of the FSF as a religion, and consider the thesis of the Free Software movement as theological - free software is an ultimate moral good, proprietary software is an ultimate moral evil, and the FSF sees themselves as clergy spreading the gospel and purifying themselves from the corruption and degradation of modernity. Sacred rituals and texts tend not to change over time, after all, being sacred they don't need to change.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by bogwog on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:29PM (#32741126)
The religion analogy is unnecessary. The FSF is a non-profit with the goal of fostering free software. As a non-profit, their actions and their investments are focused on their goal, not on becoming profitable.

As an example, RMS himself actually recommends the dual licensing model of Qt for organizations looking to make a profit and contribute to the free software movement. With that model, the software is available under a copyleft license (GPL) and a proprietary commercial license (for those willing to pay)

But as the FSF is not focused on profits (again, because they’re a non-profit organization), all of their software is exclusively licensed using copyleft licenses like GPL and LGPL. Not because it’s a “religion”, but because it’s literally the entire goal of the organization.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by KennyBlanken on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:42PM (#32741338)
> As a non-profit, their actions and their investments are focused on their goal, not on becoming profitable.

1)You can't succeed as a non-profit if you don't make money.

2)If the FSF cared about their goal of fostering free software blah blah, then why didn't they fire RMS out a cannon when basically the entire open-source world said "fire that serial sexual harasser who keeps opening his mouth about child rape not being rape, or we stop giving you money / working with you."

They chose, overwhelmingly and very petulantly, to continue letting RMS have a leadership role.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by sweetbitter on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:58PM (#32743749)
They didn't fire him because he did not do any sexual harassment, and his comment about children was made earnestly but out of a place of ignorance. I've met plenty of people who are at least that socially dense with that low of a filter, it's not really surprising that someone like this would have ignorance of such a topic + the lack of tact required to speak about it.

If anything, that kind of sheer honesty and invulnerability to peer pressure gives him an advantage over ordinary people in a leadership role.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by krapp on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:45PM (#32744620)
Except the peer pressure he was under, in this specific case, was the kind he should have been vulnerable to. We're not talking about peer pressure from proprietary software advocates or anything, but "Actually Richard, pedophilia is bad and maybe you should stop creeping on the interns."

A good leader has empathy and the capacity to understand when their actions are causing harm to people, and should be willing to take advice when warned about such behavior, and adapt for the better, if not for themselves and their own reputation then at least for the good of the organization. Stallman's "sheer honesty" has done real damage to the FSF, and the culture around F/OSS as a whole. Granted, because the politics around this are sex and gender adjacent, many people couldn't care less on general anti-woke principle, but Richard Stallman as a leader should care.

Simply crossing his arms, digging his heels in and saying "fuck you I'll do what I want" for years on end hasn't given him an advantage over any "ordinary" person. Being an obstinate prick isn't a superpower.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by random314 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @02:27AM (#32747122)
Can you share an account by the interns that showed him acting creepy?

I have been hearing a lot of allegations against Stallman, but cant seem to find the original accusation etc. If you know the primary source information, please link to it in a reply.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by krapp on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @06:38AM (#32748873)
I don't know what, specifically, you mean by "primary source," but numerous first-person accounts of Stallman's behavior in this regard can be found on the web, as there was a bit of a #metoo moment online after Stallman's original "deplatforming" when a lot of people shared their accounts.

No one is going to do your research for you. If you're actually interested, and not simply trying to yank people's chains, you can read any one of the multitudinous threads about it on HN, or do a bit of Googling.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by random314 on Saturday September 10, 2022 @02:08PM (#32793020)
I found the original comments.

RMS was not a professor or lecturer at MIT.

1st comment- a second hand report by a student that sounds like a joke.

2nd comment- RMS used to sleep overnight in his MIT office.

3rd comment- RMS was needy and pleading when asking for a date in 1985 or earlier.

I recall being told early in my freshman year “If RMS hits on you, just say ‘I’m a vi user’ even if it’s not true.”

— Bachelor’s in Computer Science, ’04

“He literally used to have a mattress on the floor of his office. He kept the door to his office open, to proudly showcase that mattress and all the implications that went with it. Many female students avoided the corridor with his office for that reason…I was one of the course 6 undergrads who avoided that part of NE43 precisely for that reason. (the mattress was also known to have shirtless people lounging on it…)”

— Bachelor’s in Computer Science, ‘99

“When I was a teen freshman, I went to a buffet lunch at an Indian restaurant in Central Square with a graduate student friend and others from the AI lab. I don’t know if he and I were the last two left, but at a table with only the two of us, Richard Stallman told me of his misery and that he’d kill himself if I didn’t go out with him.

I felt bad for him and also uncomfortable and manipulated. I did not like being put in that position — suddenly responsible for an “important” man. What had I done to get into this situation? I decided I could not be responsible for his living or dying, and would have to accept him killing himself. I declined further contact.

He was not a man of his word or he’d be long dead.”

—Betsy S., Bachelor’s in Management Science, ’85

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by random314 on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @01:49PM (#32753776)
I actually have Googled and I keep getting results and commentaries like yours. The search results are garbage.

> If you're actually interested, and not simply trying to yank people's chains, you can read any one of the multitudinous threads about it on HN, or do a bit of Googling.

Yes and all of these threads on HN are content free. The only information in this particular thread is about Stallman chewing his feet. Honestly, it looks like you don't actually know what these instances of harrassment are! I can't find anything in this HN thread or multiple others, or by Googling. It looks like you don't either.

Also HN threads are supposed to link to other sources. The only link here is to a Twitter account that is again just commentary.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by jacooper on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:36PM (#32741228)
I dont see how a "religion" has to have an outdated website, out of touch marketing and projects.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by therouwboat on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:57PM (#32740649)
You open the site and read, what else do you need?
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by spookthesunset on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:09PM (#32740822)
I mean, you kinda can't easily read this language reference from the site. So making that an easy to access set of HTML files would be a start.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Brian_K_White on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:08PM (#32741769)
The reference doesn't exist yet. This is the source to the reference.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:06PM (#32758390)
Funny anecdote from an IRC chat I "overheard" today.

The chat was for a relatively new GNU command line tool. It was discussed whether it would be possible to detect changes to a file being edited through "outside" programs, before saving. The typical "the file you have opened was changed on disk. Overwrite/Reload/..." question.

It was suggested that they could use inotify for that. A GNU developer responded with "there's no inotify on OpenBSD". Then discussion went to "could we maybe use kqueue there?"

The response from said GNU developer? I quote, and this is not a joke: "There are plenty of systems without kqueue. Like TOPS-10"

The other developer jokingly said that he didn't know of anyone still using TOPS-10, to which the GNU developer responded along the lines of "Well, I am intending to compile and run this on TOPS-10, so we should use a mechanism similar to what EMACS does to detect those changes, as that is portable to more systems and is equally safe, i.e. race-condition-free"

I'm not sure if the race conditions in the "EMACS way" are actually there or not (I didn't feel like reading the elisp code for saving files), the discussion quickly went to filesystem requirements, NFS and other remote filesystems, etc.

But the fact that they are considering porting to an OS that has been out of (active) use for more than 30 years over using more recent APIs on more modern OS's shows how far in the past they are stuck. And this is only a very recent example that I wanted to share, there are many more such examples if you know where to look (mailing lists etc.). Things like "we cannot change this as SunOS requires this-or-that" and "this will break on VMS" are still things they are thinking about... I mean I get it, backwards compatibility is cool and all, but some things can be taken a bit to the extreme...

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by starkd on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:40PM (#32741293)
Not every thing is about ease of use. Sometimes doing things without a nice GUI interface forces you to understand the system better.

All the UI's and documentation systems are taking on the same boring corporate gloss. It has its uses, but it feels dead. It's not invigorating.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dwringer on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:43PM (#32741344)
> everything from their projects, to their websites is outdated and distant from how people actually use tech everyday.

That's... kind of the point, no? Most people use computers most of the time in a way that's not free by FSF standards.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:57PM (#32742426)
yeah, I expect GNU to go the way of the dodo in the not-so-distant future. Most projects will survive, of course, but probably under new leadership or something.

In every other industry you learn to adapt to new developments until you retire, yet GNU seems to insist on using decades-old software (cvs, autotools, ...) just because.

That just has to backfire at some point...

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by cies on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:15PM (#32742635)
> Most projects will survive, of course, but probably under new leadership or something.

That is called a fork. For the fork to work you need momentum. Historically this did not work really well. And the forks mostly died.

What I do see is that big biz does not like (L)GPL (and absolutely hate AGPL), so they prefer to through their momentum behind BSD (and similar) licensed code. This is how a lot of momentum was focused away from GNU projects (e.g.: LLVM over GCC)

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:38AM (#32750423)
> That is called a fork

No that's not what I mean.

I mean more like GNOME which once was a GNU project and then left GNU to continue on their own. There are more examples like that. They don't need new manpower or inertia. They just drop GNU if they feel it keeps them back (which a lot of projects recently think, apparently, after the whole RMS drama some time back)

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by teddyh on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @07:53AM (#32749411)
People have been predicting the end of GNU ever since the beginning, perhaps starting in earnest in 1994, when the GNU project was 10 years old! Outdated, obsolete, practically one foot in the grave, surely, people said. And yet here we are in 2022, RMS being more right than ever.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by tpoacher on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @05:29PM (#32743446)
Not true. There's a large number of industries that prefer reliable older tech to unreliable ephemeral new tech.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by KennyBlanken on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:30PM (#32741144)
There is nothing admirable about actively blocking progress by refusing to admit that you are unsuitable for your role as a representative an ambassador of a movement, unpopular to the point of hundreds of organizations criticizing you remaining in a leadership role / refusing to work with your org until you leave, and generally being ineffective.

Stallman should have passed the torch twenty years ago. Open source as a movement would have progressed far more if it had been represented by someone with a more pragmatic view and a modicum of basic social skills, instead of an inflexible, dogmatic, anti-social asshole.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by starkd on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:37PM (#32741250)
Was that really necessary? Like him or not, he is still somewhat of a legend. For all those denigrating someone as being too old, they might look in the mirror. You will end up "too old" one day too. And faster than you think.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by KennyBlanken on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:50PM (#32741458)
Nothing in my comment "denigrates RMS for being too old."

Lacking any form of social grace or interpersonal skills to the point that he picks and eats his toe-cheese while on-stage for a speaking engagement, being a serial sexual harasser and general pest of women (including telling multiple college-age women that if they don't date him he'd kill himself) to the point that all the women in his office kept substantial houseplant collections in their offices because he hates houseplants, and being unable to even shut his mouth about how 'really, age is just a number' when it comes to sex with kids, and becomes extremely petulant about it when everyone objects to those views...

...is not "denigrating someone as being too old."

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Koshkin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:30PM (#32742076)
> twenty years ago... college-age women

That's literally saying "too old."

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by krapp on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:44PM (#32742953)
Too old to hit on college-age women. That's a completely different complaint than "too old" in general.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Koshkin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @10:15PM (#32745635)
There is no such thing as being “too old in general.”
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by starkd on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @09:44AM (#32750524)
Sexual harrassment is not the same thing as being crude or vulgar.
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by ctoth on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:31PM (#32742815)
Does your modicum of basic social skills teach you to call people on the Internet inflexible, dogmatic, anti-social assholes? Is name calling the appropriate method for demonstrating your superior social abilities? I'm asking as I'm rather bad at people and would love to level up!
Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by krapp on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:44PM (#32742963)
RMS is an inflexible, dogmatic, anti-social asshole. That's not even controversial, people have decades of receipts on that.

Hell, a lot of his followers consider those qualities virtuous.

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by dark-star on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:42PM (#32742229)
oh I definitely do not admire HIM.

I admire that he keeps resisting progress, still curl'ing websites and reading them locally in his EMACS just so that he doesn't have to touch a browser, and blissfully hacking away at a C language manual that the world has already hundreds of...

I like to think of him as the Amish of Computer Science. Which I don't mean in a disrespectful or derogatory way, just as someone who continuously resists any kind of progress...

Re:Richard Stallman Announces GNU C Language Reference Manual by Koshkin on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:58PM (#32742441)
> any kind of progress

Perhaps, not "any" kind of progress, just certain kind?