News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by malikNF on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:30AM (#32738496)
They built a device around as big as a golden retriever, shipped it to a planet 130 million kilo meters away, and that device is generating its own electricity and generating as much O2 as a tree.

I don’t know man, I think that’s pretty advanced technology.

We went from room sized transistors to nm sized ones in less than a century. No way we will need a billion years to catch up.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by babypuncher on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:01PM (#32738974)
The first transistor was about the size of a Raspberry Pi but I think your point still stands.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by gnu8 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @06:23PM (#32743996)
That might be an interesting project, configuring a Raspberry Pi to emulate a single transistor and then using them to build a computer.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by babypuncher on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @06:40PM (#32744117)
Building something useful out of that would end up comically large.

I should probably qualify my "first transistor" statement; the device I was referring to is the first prototype created at Bell Labs in 1947. The first transistor that someone could actually buy to build a circuit out of came out a year later and was only a little larger than today's through-hole mounted transistors. They did get used to build early minicomputers, before integrated circuits took over.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by geenew on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:11PM (#32745949)
>> That might be an interesting project, configuring a Raspberry Pi to emulate a single transistor and then using them to build a computer.

> Building something useful out of that would end up comically large.

The transistors are MicroSD-size, not RPi-size, but still, it has been done:

https://www.megaprocessor.com/

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:39AM (#32738628)
Multiple decades of very slow progress in fusion, space travel -- and I dunno, almost everything else -- should be enough to make it clear that Moore's Law doesn't apply to every other technological endeavour.

There's no reason to assume exponential type improvements. That's not how the world works.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:46AM (#32738734)
> no reason to assume exponential type improvements

Did we read the same article? This was a test. The full-scale version “would produce oxygen at a rate equivalent to several hundred trees” with close to an order of magnitude more efficiency “because a bigger machine can run at lower pressures, saving energy on compression.” There are better reasons to expect exponential improvements than not.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by Retric on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:55AM (#32738886)
The deeper point isn’t to compare mores law to all new technology but rather to consider how long it takes to get close to some fundamental limit. Early engines had horrible efficiency but that rapidly increased over time up to a reasonable fraction of hypothetical limits.

You see this all over the place, modern guns aren’t multiple orders of magnitude improvements over guns built 100 years ago. But they are orders of magnitude better than the absolute earliest guns ever built.

So, when looking at a prototype the question isn’t can it be improved but by how much can it be improved.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by skykooler on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:07PM (#32740788)
Which is why Moore's Law was a thing for so long: early transistors were so many orders of magnitude off of fundamental limits that the improvements could keep up an exponential pace for a long while.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by withinboredom on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:45PM (#32741372)
Moores law is still a thing, it’s just that the “jumps” between progression along the curve are longer. It will eventually reach infinity, but that’ll be awhile.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by DubiousPusher on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @07:57PM (#32744699)
Aren't there also issues with some fundamental limits affecting the value of increased transistor density? Like we can cram the transistors in but the benefits aren't the same as before?
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by withinboredom on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @05:47AM (#32748566)
Who says we have to use transistors? Moore's Law says nothing about transistors.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by Retric on Wednesday September 07, 2022 @10:03AM (#32750799)
Mores law is specifically about transistors:

“Moore's law is the observation that the number of transistors in a dense integrated circuit (IC) doubles about every two years.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore's_law

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by withinboredom on Thursday September 08, 2022 @06:40AM (#32763718)
Huh, this is the definition I have:

Moore's Law is the prediction that the speed of computer processors doubles every 18 months.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by Retric on Thursday September 08, 2022 @07:04AM (#32763873)
That’s a common misunderstanding, you can read the original quotes but to summarize:

The observation is named after Gordon Moore, the co-founder of Fairchild Semiconductor and Intel (and former CEO of the latter), who in 1965 posited a doubling every year in the number of components per integrated circuit,[a] and projected this rate of growth would continue for at least another decade. In 1975, looking forward to the next decade, he revised the forecast to doubling every two years, a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 41%. While Moore did not use empirical evidence in forecasting that the historical trend would continue, his prediction held since 1975 and has since become known as a "law".

The speed of processors actually increased much faster than the number of transistors on a chip until recently. Smaller transistors used to mean both faster switching speeds and the ability to get more done per instruction cycle. The difference between the days of a 4 bit Intel 4004 and a 32Bit 486 was vast.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by parkingrift on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:33PM (#32739507)
Those are weird examples as they exist under other umbrellas. Energy and space exploration. I would argue that we have absolutely made exponential progress in both fields, and it’s just perhaps not the exact type of progress you’d prefer. For example, solar would be under the energy umbrella so even if fusion hasn’t (or won’t) pan out our progress is still rapid.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by jjulius on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @02:45PM (#32741379)
Who said anything about Moore's Law up until this point? The person you responded to just said they see hope for the next billion (anywhere within that window, at least) years based on the last century alone. That's a pretty long amount of time to advance.

Not sure why you needed to rip them apart for words that you put into their mouth.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by ascar on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:53AM (#32738847)
Transistor progress has been especially astonishing, but if you just look at the progress in basically all areas of living in the last 200, 1000, 5000 years there is absolutely no reason we won't see incredible further improvements in the next century. They don't have to be exponential doubling every 18 months. Steady incremental improvements compound just fine over decades.

I just don't see any of your opening statement being even close to correct given the context. There was even significant progress in space travel and fusion in the last 50 years (e.g. first reactors being net positive after startup and reusable rockets with commercial space flights).

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by psadri on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:46AM (#32738728)
First we build AGI, then we unleash it on all these other problems.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by blue_dragon on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:21PM (#32740159)
> On Perseverance we use up to 300 watts to produce about 8 grams per hour of oxygen, which represents not much more than 10 percent efficiency relative to the amount of electrochemical power it actually takes to pull apart the CO2 molecule. ... It’ll still require a reliable power source, of course. According to Dr. Hecht, a nuclear reactor capable of around 10 kilowatts (currently being developed by NASA) should do the trick.

To me, this is not "generating its own electricity". The device is still an incredible accomplishment, even more so because it's operating on Mars. But it doesn't generate its own electricity. They still need to connect it to a separate energy input to run the reaction.

I want to clarify this just in case anybody skimming the comments gets the impression that chemically splitting the CO2 into CO and oxygen gas somehow produces enough energy to sustain the reaction without external input.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by iancmceachern on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @11:44AM (#32738693)
I love the use of a golden retriever as a unit of size. I have poodles personally, but they come in various sizes so it's a bit less clear.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by rzzzt on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:05PM (#32739957)
It needs to be golden so that corrosion doesn't alter its dimensions.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by unity1001 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:07PM (#32739085)
> They built a device around as big as a golden retriever, shipped it to a planet 130 million kilo meters away, and that device is generating its own electricity and generating as much O2 as a tree

Which could be easily accomplished by specialized bacteria dispensed to that planet's atmosphere. Yeah. Technology is billions of years behind.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by antasvara on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:21PM (#32739301)
I'm curious: do we currently have bacteria that could survive in the atmosphere of Mars? My understanding is that it would require controlled conditions and monitoring to make bacterial growth feasible under those conditions.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by lazide on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @04:59PM (#32743146)
Conditions that support Liquid water is only transitory there. So you’re generally correct.

Most extremophiles we’re aware of tend towards high temps or if low temps, in the context of extreme high salinity and water presence. Which don’t line up with Mars much.

We’d have to be managing the environment they grew in, which makes it hard.

The underlying issue of course being energy gradients and biochemical availability of that energy. Life ‘eats’ to survive, but if the only energy gradients are feeble and biochemically hard to access, it’s not a good environment for life as we know it.

Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by alpaca128 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:22PM (#32739320)
The difficult part about that would be undispensing the specialized bacteria once we figured out that it backfired and contaminated a whole planet.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by peddling-brink on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:39PM (#32740394)
That's the point. Eventually we'll get to the point where we'll be able to mass manufacture at the molecular or atomic level. Until then the best we can do is coax living things into doing our bidding. But as you point out, it's not a solved problem. The point of the parent comment was that we're not there yet.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by baruch on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @01:37PM (#32740366)
One you send humans that you can't sterilize before flight you will inevitably introduce bacteria into the environment anyway, and you will not be preselecting them either.
Re:NASA can now reliably produce a tree’s worth of oxygen on... by cercatrova on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @12:27PM (#32739407)
Room sized transistors? Lol. Then how big were the computers that linked them together?