Every parent wants their kids lives to be better than theirs were, for our parents, that meant things like not smoking and making sure your kids go to college. For the current generation, it's making sure they don't turn into dopamine addicts chasing an endless stream of outage and temporary group acknowledgement.
This seems to be a hazardous approach to me.
My young son recently installed a sketchy browser on his computer while trying to install a mod installer for a game. I check on his computer every so often to make sure he's being safe, and noticed the browser. So I asked him where he got it, because he had obviously been using it and it was set to default. He told me it came with some mod installer he installed. So I told him about the checkboxes on install wizards that sometimes install bundled adware and malware. It was a good conversation and he asked questions about what spyware looks for and what the information they collect could be used for. He is now prepared for when this inevitably happens again. He watched me uninstall the browser and click through all the dark patterns in the uninstall process, and commented on how hard they make it to remove this stuff. I also looked at the website where he got his mod loader and, while I'm never thrilled about proprietary Windows binaries, it looks reputable within the community.
Now I feel pretty confident that my son will be more careful when installing things. If I just arbitrarily put some restrictions on his usage of the computer I'm not really preparing him for anything. I'm just delaying his development of skills that he's going to need later. I could either monitor and guide him now, or he could struggle on his own later. You can shield your kids and leave their curiosity to fester and turn into resentment, or you can use their curiosity to impart your wisdom.
That's the equivalent of saying "I will not be letting my children near the internet"
24 hours - 8 hours sleeping - 6 hours at school - [time spent in house] = negligible time left for malfeasance
Good luck with that. Your children will seek things out on their own, against your will.
You might consider being the kind of parent who a trans kid could talk to about their identity issues instead of trying to censor their access to content which they're going to see anyway. Are you aware of the horrifying suicide numbers among this group? Please don't be that kind of parent.
There are no heroes in any story. But in many cases in this field, it's the parents that are the worst villains.
Reading this is hilarious from someone in the know: you're referring to 'Otoko no Ko pharmaceuticals', which is a website operated in South America which asks no questions as to who they're shipping to; they just accept crypto payment and send it off. It's not part of some grooming campaign, and the characters featured are anime characters, not 'cartoon' characters in the sense you suggest targets children as consumers.
Ten years later: why is my kid such a loner?
Discord is the main persistent group chat service in the west (telegram seems popular in the third world except for China). It's used for virtually everything. Socially it's almost equivalent to cutting your kids from any online chat.
Honestly, I would consider a total ban a mild form of child abuse.
I've joining a large number of public discord servers and they've all been safe and well moderated.
Only a miniscule number of people would come across the server mentioned. If your kids want to learn about sex or hormones they'll learn it from plenty of other websites, or their mates. It's also unlikely they would learn about hormones, they would have to intentionally look for it, and they're probably not trans so why would they?
Banning discord in general is of course less damaging, but the reasoning is similarly incorrect. It's an enormous platform for chats about virtually everything.
A general ban on discord is going to socially harm any kid in the west.
Rationale for 1. It's widely supported by the medical community and by scientific studies, and helps improve the quality of life of people with gender dysphoria.
Rationale for 2. Gatekeeping traditionally consist in telling a psychiatrist anecdotal personal stories about your gender expressions and behaviors. Some psychiatrist hold sexist attitudes, and can prolong your gatekeeping or refuse treatment if you don't tell them a nice tradwife story (always known, only attracted to boys (if MtF) or girls (if FtM), always played with [gendered toy]).
This even has the opposite effect of not wanting to talk with them about genuine doubts, since they can deny you HRT if they don't like your adherence to sex stereotypes.
In the end the trans person themself is more qualified to know whether they would like their bodies to be more masculine or feminine.
(EDIT: added rationales)
For that reason I think attitudes like this do more harm for the trans community than good. If I knew a trans person with these views I would do everything possible to avoid any contact with them and my children.
I can't really comment on the US. But thank you for the insight...
I think the solution of having the doctor manage this kind of thing is a lot better than what happens in the US.
> I think the solution of having the doctor manage this kind of thing is a lot better than what happens in the US.
I think it is difficult as in the US medical care is mostly privatised.
You cannot sue a doctor in the UK, you would sue the trust (a collection of hospitals in a geographical area). So if a doctor needs to force treatment on a child and the parents refused it would go to a board who would approve or deny it. All children (and adults) will receive treatment for free, so there is also no gotchas about who is going to pay.
I don't think the medical literature suggests taking homemade drugs from strangers on the internet.
I will refrain from name-calling, but I have never been as angry or disgusted by anyone else on this site.
Edit: I want to make it clear that the dire consequences I'm talking about are NOT feminization/masculinization, nor even common complications of either such as infertility.
Taking uncontrolled doses of hormones, at irregular times, without any kind of tracking of the quantitative effects (blood tests to determine effective levels), especially for someone undergoing puberty, can easily lead to hormone overdoses that can seriously harm pretty much any organ in the body - including at the very least the heart, kidneys and liver. Testosterone and estrogen have many many effects in the body outside of determining sexual characteristics.
How do you make a judgment that some 12 yo kid is more at risk from having to wait for HRT approval due to not being able to find a sympathetic medical professional, vs the risk from being highly suggestible, unable to sensibly judge that HRT is the right solution and consequently causing permanent change to their bodies (including possible loss of fertility, and a number of other side-effects around blood clotting etc.) as they progress through puberty?
It's a widely supported position of the trans community that minors should have access to home-made HRT without any quality control or regulation?
Because honestly, I feel like if you're taking hormone replacement therapy you want some kind of guarantee of quality.
To be trans is to live on the edge of the law and on the very cutting edge of biopunk medical science. A lot of shit is off-off-off-label, where there are no guarantees of quality, but something is better than nothing which is what you'd get if it were up to your parents and doctors.
This is what you said.
And beyond legality, kids self-administering HRT with neither parental nor medical supervision is a truly scary thought. It is certain to leave most with significant health issues, that no amount of good will will help them solve.
Ideally yes you would want a GP to prescribe you HRT. But if in the place where you currently live this is not possible without years of gatekeeping, or parents have veto power, gray-market solutions are the next best possible alternative.
I fully support the right of children to receive puberty blockers to help them achieve a smooth transition when they are old enough to fully understand the consequences. I bemoan states and parents that seek to harm trans children by refusing them access to this type of treatment, and others. But slef-medicating as a child is in absolutely no way an acceptable replacement. Being a non-passing trans adult, as bad as it is, is likely to be much much better than the harms you expose yourself to by accidentally overdosing on hormones as a child.
But as they say, the cruelty is the point.
Doctors and parents should be involved in every single one of these kids decisions, but if the doctors and parents are involved, it's their job to care for their kids. If they decide their kids need to be helped in some way, they should be free to make that decision.
Doctor oversight for the medical industry already exists and is already a very strong structure, and it will adapt over time to keep kids safe from malpractice. You are probably misinformed relative to the experts on these issues.
It is my belief that unregulated handing of medicine to kids is not good. Especially having seen how some of these groups on discord work.
I also think that barring kids from potentially helpful medicine is also not good. You will genuinely hurt people by doing this by denying them care that could save their lives.
This is a place where I think pragmatism is best, and you need to set your biases aside as much as you possibly can. Leave things to the people who are involved with them everyday, and look after your own life with what you see.
Isn't this kind of a whack-a-mole approach to things? The internet is full of hazards... are you going to ban everything that comes up?
Probably not as necessary once they're like 15 or so, but up that age do not let them be on there on their own. And, of course, make sure they know critical thinking and discuss everything that they see online with them instead of heavy-handedly barring them from it.
Teach them about the satanic panics of the 1970s. Teach them about social pressure, teach them about rationalism, show them some good old James randii.
I've seen some of this trend on discord. It is genuinely nasty and you should be keeping tabs on your kids.
Wouldn't it damage the trust between you and your child? I think even monitoring internet usage in-person or outright restricting access to potentially dangerous websites would be less intrusive. If your kid discovers you can access their messages at any time, it would make them more inclined to make other accounts and not discuss about any dangerous interactions on them out of fear of being discovered.
Eventually you have to stop doing this, they have to grow up, but especially when they're very young it is very important that you're actually on their account because they don't know enough to see and report when something harmful is going on.
I'm not a parent, so I didn't want to say that, but it is certainly what I was thinking. =)
But I was also a kid, and I know that if I was barred from doing something I would 100% go behind my parents back and do it anyway, so that's not going to work.
You have to try something else.
That said, my parents always told me that if I wanted to try drugs (like weed), let them buy it for me so that they could at least know I was getting good stuff.
Honestly, that just made it more awkward... but it did instill in me that I should at least make sure that I was not just taking random shitty drugs. It also made me wait until I could find stuff I could trust before trying it.
I don't have the answer, I think OPs solution is the only practical one: constant and even-handed-as-possible vigilance and rules and hopefully a bit of curation too.
Honestly, the internet really isn't a good place for a child and their mental health. I'm in my 30s and have been an internet native for my entire conscious memory, having seen the early 4chan, gore, etc. on the unfiltered internet. Saying all that I think it is somehow even worse today. I'm not sure how I would navigate this if I were to have children.
They use Discord to figure out what other things they’re going to do either in person or in an online game. So this rule hasn’t been hard to follow for them.
It's interesting that your takeaway in light of this knowledge is a strategy that totally misses keeping your children away from the forum responsible for three suicides [0].
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiwi_Farms#Suicides_of_harassm...
USA Today reported on a Twitter thread. They did not claim to have access to any official documents, only second hand accounts of what the police said.
There would most likely have been an official record of his death. Embassies in Japan usually publish records of expat deaths. None of the confirmed expat deaths in Japan in that time window match anything like Near's description.
The only reason information about his death would be blocked is due to an ongoing investigation by police.
It is unlikely that the police would share information about an ongoing investigation with anyone, and if they did it would only be with family.
What it boils down to is that someone on the internet heard from the Japanese police that near had killed himself because of online bullying.
Just to be clear, if I were Near, I might hoax my own suicide if it hurt Kiwifarms. But I don't think there is nearly enough evidence to justify deplatforming Kiwifarms.
I'm just wondering what your plan is to keep your kids off of this other (public) forum that your just learned about (and ones like it), if you have one.
[0] Bathtub hormones being sold to minors in bright packaging featuring a cartoon with the speech bubble: "Don't look at my giant Girldick" and a warning to "Keep out of reach of parents" https://archive.ph/6DnzT
I doubt this person is representative of the trans community, she is probably just the most controversial, and made a name for herself that way. No more heroes, any more.