News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by danieldk on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:45AM (#32712988)
Could you explain what the problems are? I don't have a strong opinion either way, but you can buy hydrogen cars. In the city where I live there are hydrogen buses and garbage trucks and they seem to do fine?
Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by mikeyouse on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:51AM (#32713046)
Mostly hydrogen is the smallest element so molecules of hydrogen (H2) are extremely hard to contain. They leak from everywhere so your entire infrastructure has to be designed with very tight tolerances and even still, you’ll have leaks. In addition, those leaks can prove to be dangerous since it’s so reactive and flammable, so you have a highly leaky flammable gas at high pressure…

So you think, well fine, we can just generate it on site via electrolysis — alas, hydrogen actively destroys metal containers via embrittlement. Not so much in hydrogen gas, but any process where you’re running chemical or electrolytic reactions;

https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by fsh on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:08AM (#32713866)
I have the impression that the problem of hydrogen leakage from vehicles is vastly exaggerated. A study on two commercial hydrogen cars found leakage rates of 2-6 mL/min (Table 4 in [1]). At this rate, it would take over 15 years for the tank content of a Toyota Mirai (5 kg of H2) to leak out.

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s42154-020-00096-z

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by mikeyouse on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:26PM (#32731988)
The Hydrogen isn't leaking from vehicles since they take so many precautions to ensure they don't, including those tight tolerances and special materials. You just need to replicate that at every step of the supply chain which becomes onerous and expensive.
Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by panick21_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:08AM (#32713204)
Its not that it doesn't work at all, but while there are some trial uses of hydrogen in automotive. Its the very extreme minority of cases.

You can buy one of only a few models of car, and those are only sold in absurdly small numbers.

For trucks there are more trials going on but real mass production of hydrogen trucks isn't really a thing for a few more years (and many expect those will be further delayed).

There are many reasons for this. Just something as simple as count how many different sub-systems are required between a BEV and a FCEV. In addition that basic disadvantage, the end to end energy in efficiency is worse, so its more expensive. In addition to that, the infrastructure required is about 10-100x more expensive.

Tesla as one start up rolled out a global (or lets say in the developed world) EV charging infrastructure. The same amount of money invested in hydrogen infrastructure like not even have resulted in enough locations to charge the whole West coast. And because you can't charge at home, you need many more such locations.

So really end to end it makes no sense pretty much from any direction you look at it and has been absolutely destroyed in the market. Some people still have hope for trucks, but there too the trends are pretty clear.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by TrapLord_Rhodo on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:59PM (#32716467)
Hydrogen is significantly lighter though.

If the oil companies chose to expand out their infra on the highway system with hydrogen, it may make more sense with long haul, big truck routes.

Battery power scales more proportionally to weight than hydrogen.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by panick21_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:04PM (#32718158)
For trucks operation cost is the most expensive. Hydrogen itself is far more expensive compared to electricity and hydrogen infrastructure is orders of magnitude more expensive then hydrogen infrastructure.
Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by Fatnino on Sunday September 04, 2022 @01:21PM (#32715354)
Hydrogen has one thing going for it in that it only takes 5 minutes to fill up once you find a pump. Electric takes 4-6 times as long or more.

Electric still comes out ahead despite this handicap.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by danieldk on Sunday September 04, 2022 @02:43PM (#32716309)
Hydrogen has one thing going for it in that it only takes 5 minutes to fill up once you find a pump. Electric takes 4-6 times as long or more.

Right. This is the main issue for us for going electric. We barely use the car, but when we use it, it is often for longer distances (visiting my in-laws, who live in another country, holidays). Having to 'refuel' longer and more often is very inconvenient.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by panick21_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @06:06PM (#32718171)
Most normal people don't drive many hours without making a 20 min break. Doing a 5-10 min break every couple hours seems reasonable. Even just pieing and stretching the legs. As long as the supercharges are placed well its perfectly fine.

I know there are some extreme people who basically push and pie in a bottle if they have to, but most people don't travel that way.

Modern EV can refuel large part of the battery in like 15min.

There is still an advantage, but it gets smaller with every generation of vehicle.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by Fatnino on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:21PM (#32741948)
This simply isn't true.

I've traveled between the bay area and Los Angeles (a six hour drive) many times with a large variety or different drivers. The longest break was a 20-30 minute stop the Greyhound bus makes at a Burger King in the middle of nowhere. But the bus also, doesn't take the shortest route for some reason.

In a private car, the more passengers the greater the chance that someone will ask for a bio break. But if it's just me driving, or I'm the only passenger, the trip is typically a non-stop push. Often without stopping for even 5 minutes at an overpriced gas station in the middle.

Using a current gen EV introduces nearly an hour delay each way when you factor in range limitations and excessive charging times compared to gas.

I expect this will be a solved issue by 2030

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by snewman on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:38AM (#32714173)
Part of the issue is that this rocket doesn't just use hydrogen, it uses cryogenic liquid hydrogen, which apparently is even harder to manage. To quote from an excellent writeup [0]:

> Because it is so tiny, hydrogen can squeeze through the smallest of gaps. This is not so great a problem at ambient temperatures and pressures, but at super-chilled temperatures and high pressures, hydrogen easily oozes out of any available opening.

Elon Musk responded to this article with the following tweet [1], which to my understanding is a pretty reasonable take:

> Accurate assessment. Raptor design started out using H2, but switched to CH4. Latter is best combo of high efficiency & ease of operation imo. Delta-v difference between H2 & CH4 is small for most missions, because CH4 tank is much smaller & no insulation is needed.

[0] https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/years-after-shuttle-...

[1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1566233000458592256

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by mikepurvis on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:52AM (#32713053)
I think it's an okay fit for fleet vehicles where the headaches are closer to worth it, but the volatility + the difficulties in safely and reliably containing the compressed gas are the main issues.
Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by senectus1 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @09:57AM (#32713105)
>I think it's an okay fit for fleet vehicles

This is the thing... there is no "one size fits all" but the nay sayers look at hydrogen and say "nah too hard for anything". They're wrong. Hydrogen will be huge in the NEAR future... it just wont be a silver bullet.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by manholio on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:12AM (#32713911)
You are ignoring economies of scale and the externalities of a mass market technology. Electricity is everywhere and even so, electric cars had and still have a huge barrier to overcome in providing adequate infrastructure. Once a technology takes off, it's virtually impossible for an incumbent to replace it unless it provides drastic improvements, because of the momentum the old technology has.

Well, H2 is an "also ran" at this point: it has lower energy efficiency (losing the majority of input energy in the cycle from electrolysis -> compression -> fuel cell -> electric), it requires more expensive and practically non-existent infrastructure, it's theoretical range advantages are negated by the need to have a small COPV bomb on board, forcing the longest range Hidrogen cars have less range than the equivalent electric, they are more expensive and complex, requiring expensive, platinum based catalysts, pushing the prices of H2 models into a multiple over the equivalent BEV. There is nothing that H2 can do that BEV can't do better, with the exception of fast refueling, which is becoming less and less of an issue.

For cars the race with BEV is irredeemably lost, and even for trucks the hydrogen industry needs to perform some technological miracle to stay in the game.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by panick21_ on Sunday September 04, 2022 @10:09AM (#32713207)
> will be huge in the NEAR future.

Is what fans of hydrogen have been arguing for 30 years.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by senectus1 on Sunday September 04, 2022 @11:25PM (#32720175)
while the dominant powers in the world get fat and rich (and sick) off liquid dino's.

The world finally has motivation to get out of that rut. Dominant powers will make hydrogen work for them because thats how a corrupt capitalist society works.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by zionic on Monday September 05, 2022 @10:25AM (#32724647)
Hydrogen vehicles are essentially an oil company scam. They are fraud, at a physics level, vs EVs. They fall apart the second you take a serious, first-principles look at how they work.

HN rate limits my replies you can read my sibling comment if you’d like more information.

Re:Leak ruins NASA moon rocket launch bid; next try weeks away by senectus1 on Tuesday September 06, 2022 @03:57AM (#32734257)
this is a deeply cynical and irresponsible statement.

granted, most of it is made via non-renewable dirty methods... but there is VAST sums of money pouring into Green Hydrogen. Its going to become dominant in very few years. 5-8 is my guess.